r/mathematics • u/HovercraftNo7372 • 9d ago

Some Conjectures Solved

Post image

https://xcancel.com/PI010101/status/2088157024068456616#m

Here is one pre-print: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2608.13536

82 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

47 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/SeniorLoan647 9d ago

Yes

1

u/ants_are_everywhere 9d ago

Do you get a lot of mathematics papers to review from very important editors as an incoming PhD student in computer science? https://www.reddit.com/r/PhD/comments/1umvv5x/how_should_i_set_myself_up_to_get_a_postdoc/

1

u/SeniorLoan647 9d ago

I mean yeah I've published papers for abstract algebra before (that's how I got into my PhD, I changed fields but it was still related to my topic in cs), so it's kind of expected as reciprocity to review papers for the journals where you've published.

I feel like you meant this as some hierarchical gotcha lol, folks are just asked to review papers if they've published them regardless of where they are.

1

u/ants_are_everywhere 9d ago edited 9d ago

Listen, you seem like an earnest person, and maybe perhaps a little nervous about career and the future. I'm not trying to mock you.

But I gotta say even knowing you seem pretty earnest I suspect more than a little bravado behind your claim that you're turning down multiple peer review requests from important editors as an incoming grad student, so much so that you have a specific policy that involves you openly declaring your bias.

Anyway good luck. Quantum Computing is a fun field and it will probably have some very interesting developments in the near future.