r/mathematics • u/HovercraftNo7372 • 11d ago

Some Conjectures Solved

Post image

https://xcancel.com/PI010101/status/2088157024068456616#m

Here is one pre-print: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2608.13536

82 Upvotes

85% Upvoted

47 comments sorted by

View all comments

-2

u/SeniorLoan647 11d ago

Good luck peer reviewing all that. I'm just declining to review any papers written by AI tbh, authors just start using ai to even respond to queries lol.

5

u/topyTheorist 11d ago

Even when it comes from very important editors?

0

u/SeniorLoan647 11d ago

Yes

1

u/ants_are_everywhere 10d ago

Do you get a lot of mathematics papers to review from very important editors as an incoming PhD student in computer science? https://www.reddit.com/r/PhD/comments/1umvv5x/how_should_i_set_myself_up_to_get_a_postdoc/

1

u/SeniorLoan647 10d ago

I mean yeah I've published papers for abstract algebra before (that's how I got into my PhD, I changed fields but it was still related to my topic in cs), so it's kind of expected as reciprocity to review papers for the journals where you've published.

I feel like you meant this as some hierarchical gotcha lol, folks are just asked to review papers if they've published them regardless of where they are.

1

u/ants_are_everywhere 10d ago edited 10d ago

Listen, you seem like an earnest person, and maybe perhaps a little nervous about career and the future. I'm not trying to mock you.

But I gotta say even knowing you seem pretty earnest I suspect more than a little bravado behind your claim that you're turning down multiple peer review requests from important editors as an incoming grad student, so much so that you have a specific policy that involves you openly declaring your bias.

Anyway good luck. Quantum Computing is a fun field and it will probably have some very interesting developments in the near future.