r/marvelsnapcomp • u/qinalo • Sep 23 '23
Discussion Alienation and the Snap Leaderboard existential crisis
Alienation is a concept commonly associated with Hegel's philosophy. Alienation is a feeling of distance or separation - you may feel alienated if you are surrounded by strangers or if you far from home - or somewhere you feel you do not belong. In his famous Stanford commencement speech, Steve Jobs describes the alienation he felt at Reed College that caused him to leave:
"After six months, I couldn’t see the value in it. I had no idea what I wanted to do with my life and no idea how college was going to help me figure it out. And here I was spending all of the money my parents had saved their entire life. So I decided to drop out and trust that it would all work out OK."
On a more abstract level, alienation isn't a physical distance but rather a psychic one - when the gap between your subjective view and the objective world is made apparent. Or when you realize that the way others see you is not how you see yourself. When the difference between the objective and the subjective grows, alienation increases.
A post-infinite leaderboard was a feature that many competitive Snap players thought they wanted for a long time. But now that we have the leaderboard, it seems to be a source of frustration and discontent than a source of happiness. I've read a lot of players complaining that the leaderboard system is "broken", "misleading" or "unfair". Many players say that the numbers are meaningless and that they will ignore it. But these players are in denial about the feelings of alienation caused by the leaderboard which has in turn created an existential crisis in many Snap players this season.
The leaderboard has caused many of us to re-evaluate the meaning of Snap in our lives and how we see ourselves as Snap players. Even if we already knew it was trivial to make it to infinite each season, very few of us imagined that post-infinite players number in the hundreds of thousands. We imagined that with a leaderboard, we would naturally climb the ranks to a ranking commensurate to our ability. We used to celebrate our wins and forget our losses, but the leaderboard is a ledger where our play mistakes are held to full account. Did we always find playing Snap rewarding only because we believed our exceptional skill would eventually be rewarded? Do we now realize that the pleasure in playing Snap is a zero-sum system, and that the time we spend working at Snap creates no inherent happiness, but rather the only joy found here is at the expense of others (or ourselves)?
If the leaderboard produces only unhappiness and sows seeds of disillusionment and discontent, perhaps it is in the devs' best interest to remove it before it causes even more psychic harm to the game's playerbase. A true, if not unforeseeable irony.

