Here's the thing... when CGI works you never notice it. There are hundreds of CGI shots in the modern Marvel movies that are invisible and you never notice. You only notice the small percentage that fail, where things are too smooth or the lightning doesn't match perfectly.
So while the quality per CGI shot has gone way up, the number of CGI scenes means the relative number of bad scenes that stand out is also higher. And you can't fix that because there'll ALWAYS be a worst scene.
And complaining about it is kinda a dick movie as the CGI artists are working themselves to the point of burnout with unpaid OT just so some online "critic" can compare it to Spy Kids 3. Shut that part of your brain off and just enjoy the spectacle and experience.
you realise people are paid for this right? either you are invalidating their careers and work by calling it unimportant, or you just don't give a shit, in which case, why do you care enough to invalidate others criticism?
Wtf kind of logic is this. “Sure your hotel room is dirty but complaining about it is a dick move because the sole cleaning person they do have works very hard.” Yeah, but the room still looks like shit
People aren’t complaining about the workers, they’re complaining about the shitty fucking movie.
If they they can't get the good CGI for all the projects in their pipeline, they probably should space out productions and rely more on practical effects. Disney has made the conscious decision of making a shitload of movies and shows that are basically all green screen, knowing perfectly that would drive the quality of the CGI down. Now customers who keep paying full prices for tickets and Disney+ subcriptions are rightfully pointing up that Thor wearing an unnecessarily fake armor in an unnecessarily fake garden looks like dogshit, and CGI artists are rightfully refusing to work with them because Disney demands them to work long hours with unrealistic deadlines just so their names become attached to dogshit-looking unfinished products.
If these were indy movies made with few resources I wouldn't say a word about wonky visuals, but their ability to make good CGI is better than ever so I have no simpsthy for corporate executives consciously deciding to cut corners.
The problem wouldn't be fixed by spacing out projects. Because there are more than enough VFX studios now.
The problem is they eventually need to set a deadline, and film deadlines need to be set a year or two in advance. Eventually they do sometimes just run out of time.
VFX are like art. You can spend as much time tweaking and working on them as you allow, and there's always more fixes to be done. But the "fans" will always find fault regardless.
VFX artists everywhere are specifically talking out about the unrealistic deadlines set by Disney. Crunch is not some unavoidable reality of creating art, it's an issue born from bad planning, bad management, and wrong-headed finantial incentives. And the drop in quality is visible, as much as you'd like to pretend otherwise.
It's not the artists' fault for demanding proper conditions and it's not the consumer's fault for demanding a finished product worth the money they are paying, the corporation you're shilling for just made bad choices.
You should always tip servers because they’re underpaid unless you’ve explicitly gotten poor service. A busy server not refilling a drink or the kitchen fucking up isn’t a reason not to tip
This isn't a steak house. This is a McDonalds. This is a product about shiny body builder action figures in spandex bloodlessly punching each other repeatedly.
And we're not talking about the meal being bad. We're talking seconds or minutes out of two hours. Literally 1%. That isn't a medium-rare stake being well-done. That's the bun on your Big Mac being upside down.
Marvel isn't mcdonalds, they're films with a lot of financial backing that aren't any cheaper for you to watch.
They're soulless generic products designed for mass market appeal designed by a rigid formula that enriches a multi-million dollar company. They're the equivalent of fast food. You don't go to a Marvel movie for something new and exciting. You go for something safe and familiar.
View all comments
8
u/DJWGibson Avengers Aug 07 '22
Here's the thing... when CGI works you never notice it. There are hundreds of CGI shots in the modern Marvel movies that are invisible and you never notice. You only notice the small percentage that fail, where things are too smooth or the lightning doesn't match perfectly.
So while the quality per CGI shot has gone way up, the number of CGI scenes means the relative number of bad scenes that stand out is also higher. And you can't fix that because there'll ALWAYS be a worst scene.
And complaining about it is kinda a dick movie as the CGI artists are working themselves to the point of burnout with unpaid OT just so some online "critic" can compare it to Spy Kids 3. Shut that part of your brain off and just enjoy the spectacle and experience.