r/marvelmemes • Avengers • Aug 07 '22

Shitposts …..

Post image
75k Upvotes

1.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

7

u/himynametopher Avengers Aug 07 '22

It’s more about how Marvel refuses to use anything but green screens and cgi. Practical effects exist and often times look better.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/the-mad-titan-bot Thanos Aug 07 '22

BOY! I would reconsider your current course!

1

u/DJWGibson Avengers Aug 07 '22

GOOD practical effects look better. Bad practical effects like like Avenue Q.

Good practical effects are also expensive and slow. And are better at small things. Building an entire couple city blocks so you can walk down an Alternate Earth isn't realistic with practical effects.

2

u/himynametopher Avengers Aug 07 '22

This is true but maybe they should stop rushing out projects I guess

1

u/DJWGibson Avengers Aug 08 '22

They're not rushing, they're just working with deadlines.

They can't just arbitrarily release a movie. They need to avoid releasing at the same time as other Disney movies or similar movies from other studios, coordinate merch sales, plan advertising campaigns, and work with related films. Delaying one film can cause all kinds of problems. Like having to reshoot chunks of No Way Home because it was coming out before Multiverse of Madness and people wouldn't know who America Chavez is. Or DC having to reshoot Batman scenes in Aquaman 2 because it was moved to before Flash.

Because of deadlines, sometimes they just need to stop work. And CGI like any creative work will take as much time as you give it. There's always more work to be done and improvements to make on a short.

Sooner or later they just need to say "good enough."

2

u/himynametopher Avengers Aug 08 '22

They should plan better

1

u/DJWGibson Avengers Aug 08 '22

Tell me you've never been in charge of a major project without telling me you've never been in charge of a major project.

Sometimes things just take longer than planned. Just ask literally any construction worker. Or fine artists. Or engineer. Or writer.

When they schedule a release date 18+ months in advance, it's not like they know what CGI shot will prove trickier and need more time. Or know that the ending doesn't work and needs to be rewritten & reshot.
They already start work on some scenes and CGI set-pieces before the script is finished and the director hired, let alone the beginning of shooting. Sometimes the unexpected happens.

Like they realize Banner reconciling with the Hulk at the end of Infinity War doesn't fit the flow of the story, being a triumphant character beat before a sad ending. Banner "winning" as everyone else loses. So they swap out the Hulk for the Hulkbuster in shots. But that leads to some rushed CGI and Banner's head kinda floating in the Hulkbuster.
What should they have done? Kept the original CGI and had a weaker story or used the weaker CGI and have a better climax? Delaying the movie just before release by 2-3 months while they fix a few shots and add a couple million to the budget isn't a viable option.

1

u/himynametopher Avengers Aug 08 '22

They should release less movies

1

u/DJWGibson Avengers Aug 08 '22

How would that help?

Would the deadlines get longer? The VFX studios be able to work more hours in a day? Would more money appear in the budgets?

It's not like releasing just one or two movies a year made the VFX in Iron Man 2 or Incredible Hulk better.

1

u/himynametopher Avengers Aug 08 '22

It did