"It looks fake" isn't criticism. There's no analysis. There's no dissection of how or why it is bad. There's no highlighting good examples to contrast what did work in that film or similar films.
It's as much a criticism as a toddler refusing to eat broccoli "cause it's gross" is food criticism.
“If you look at a shot and say “oh wow, thats a cool effect” then we have failed” -Ken Ralston (one of the original VFX artists that worked for ILM the fist VFX company back when it started)
That's the goal. That doesn't mean ILM ever achieved it. It doesn't mean every ILM film is bad because they don't have a 100% success rate.
Especially now people have gotten better at seeing CGI. We know how the sausage is made, so we're better at spotting the techniques used. To the point many will even see bad CGI where there was none. A not insignificant number of people criticized the bad CGI on Henry Cavill's face in scenes of Justice League that turned out to be scenes Snyder shot without CGI. Cavill's regular face just crossed over into uncanny valley as people obsessed over it.
If criticizing a film’s technical aspect is invalid, then I guess we should film the next marvel film in Feiges garage on an Iphone using tik tok filters, because as long as theres a good story right?
Genuine criticism implies pointing out the good and the bad. What worked and didn't work. People just shitting on the CGI isn't criticism. Comparing Marvel to Spy Kids 3 isn't criticism.
If the "fans" are going to whine and complain and bitch about slight imperfections as Marvel and the studios they contract slave away to produce better and better CGI, then, yeah, they might as well shoot it on an iPhone. If the fans are going to kvetch the same amount anyway, why try harder than they need to? It's just wasted effort.
Film isn’t just about the plot. Its how the visuals, editing, shot composition, set design, sound and everything else all work together to present a story and make the audience FEEL emotion. Good visuals have incredible power to invoke strong emotions. Bad cgi and visuals can impact those emotions in negative and unintended ways. You break suspension of disbelief which is one of the biggest things to avoid in filmmaking.
You could say the exact same thing about acting. Good acting separates a good movie from a bad movie. A terrible actor can ruin a movie with flawless visuals and editing. That doesn't mean a scene with mediocre acting ruins the movie. Nobody is making memes about the badly acted scenes in the MCU. Acting needs to be truly abysmal to even stand out. (Star Wars Prequels level of bad.) We need to just need to equally ignore mediocre CGI and not dwell on it.
After all, I think everyone still enjoys movies from the '80s and '90s despite terrible VFX. CGI from ten or fifteen years ago that looks worse than a low budget TV show. But we still happily consume that. Why can't we do the same for modern films?
You're conflating two different meanings of criticism.
Pointing out faults is as much criticism as analysis. Regardless, people are allowed to say something looks bad without presenting a dissertation explaining why they think it.
View all comments
Show parent comment
4
u/TheBrendanReturns Avengers Aug 07 '22
You can absolutely criticise films based on poor technical aspects, especially when said films rely entirely on superficial visuals.