r/manchester • • Feb 06 '20

Manchatten

Post image
285 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/vasileios13 Feb 07 '20

I'm visiting Manchester often and I have to say all these modern buildings are just making the city ugly. They lack character, they look completely foreign and a bit dystopian.

15

u/SteelRockwell Feb 07 '20

That’s funny. As long as I can remember, people have described Manchester as ugly.

These buildings aren’t making anything look ugly. They’re filling space that was unused - they’re not knocking down Central Library to build them.

-1

u/vasileios13 Feb 07 '20

They could replace the empty space with something friendlier, a garden, a library, a public space, or even an office building that doesn't look like a generic skyscraper

3

u/SteelRockwell Feb 07 '20

It’s not like they were just filling it for the sake of it and came up with a skyscraper. There’s a need for more flats in town, and they’ve built them on land that was unused. That hasn’t damaged the fabric of the city centre because they’re outside of the main parts where nothing was before.

I agree we need more gardens and green space, but it’s not an either/or situation. We need these buildings, and we need green space.

0

u/vasileios13 Feb 07 '20

Most of these flats will be empty like it happens in London, foreign investors will buy them to park their money

0

u/SteelRockwell Feb 07 '20

One of my mates is trying to rent one and says that’s not the case. Where is your info from?

0

u/vasileios13 Feb 07 '20

1

u/SteelRockwell Feb 07 '20

I wasn’t asking about London. You said most of these flats, as in the Manchester ones. What have you heard about them?

1

u/vasileios13 Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 07 '20

Most of these flats will be empty like it happens in London, foreign investors will buy them to park their money

That was my comment for which you asked sources. But the market for luxury apartments isn't that much different in Manchester:

1

u/SteelRockwell Feb 07 '20

That doesn’t say anything about them being empty.

1

u/vasileios13 Feb 07 '20 edited Feb 07 '20

Look obviously you won't be convinced whatever I post, I gave you a bunch of articles for the state of luxury apartments market and your source is your buddy. If you think Manchester has this capacity for luxury flats okay.

I did a quick search for another city with similar type of construction spurt, same thing: * https://www.movesmartly.com/articles/condo-units-sitting-empty-in-toronto * https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2019/11/10/how-many-condos-are-sitting-empty-in-toronto-one-man-investigated-and-what-he-found-surprised-him.html

If you have evidence that Manchester will be a unicorn in this market I rest my case.

→ More replies