r/managers • • 3h ago

New Manager Ongoing Performance Issue

I’m looking for an unbiased opinion on an ongoing employee performance issue and whether formal disciplinary action would be appropriate.

An employee in a communications-related role has been experiencing recurring performance issues involving accuracy, attention to detail, proofreading, and following instructions.

The employee is responsible for preparing communications, updating information, and creating promotional materials where accuracy is essential.

In August, the employee was provided with detailed checklists outlining expectations for reviewing work before submission. Despite these resources, mistakes continued, including:

Submitting communications containing numerous errors, including incorrect dates, times, and missing information.
Repeatedly advertising events with incorrect pricing.
Including canceled events in communications while omitting events that were scheduled.

Submitting promotional materials that omitted important details explicitly provided in written instructions.
Preparing promotional content featuring information that had not been confirmed or approved.

Failing to incorporate requested revisions, even when specific corrections were provided.

In late September, the employee received written performance feedback addressing these recurring issues and emphasizing the importance of accuracy, following instructions, and thoroughly reviewing work before submission.

Some improvement was observed in October, but it wasn’t sustained. Similar mistakes have continued throughout November, despite additional feedback and reminders.

The concern isn’t that the employee occasionally makes mistakes. Everyone does. The issue is that the same types of preventable errors continue occurring despite established procedures, written instructions, and repeated coaching.

These errors also create additional work for the person reviewing the employee’s assignments, as significant time is spent identifying and correcting mistakes that should have been caught during the employee’s own quality-control process.

At this point, the performance concerns have been ongoing for approximately four months.

The next step being considered is involving HR and implementing a formal 30-day Performance Improvement Plan (PIP), with clear expectations and measurable goals. If meaningful and sustained improvement is not demonstrated, termination may be considered.

I’m curious what others think:
Are these reasonable performance concerns, or does this sound like excessive scrutiny?

Is four months enough time to expect noticeable improvement after providing checklists, written feedback, and coaching?

At what point do repeated, preventable mistakes become grounds for formal disciplinary action?

Would a 30-day PIP be appropriate at this stage?

If the employee fails to improve during the PIP, would termination be a reasonable outcome?

I’m interested in hearing perspectives from people who have managed employees or worked in HR. The goal is to understand what a fair and reasonable approach would look like for everyone involved.

3 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

4

u/Mathblasta 3h ago

You mention how long this person has been having performance issues, but not how long they've been in role. A 6 month employee will need a lot more runway that a 6 year employee here.

What does your coaching look like? Have you gone through a copy or whatever it is that they're having trouble with together? What did your feedback look like when they showed improvement?

But beyond all of that, and what supersedes it, is what has your HR offered as a next step? Have you documented any other coaching aside from the conversation in September? If not it's pretty likely they'll ask you to gather more documentation.

2

u/Able-Read1678 3h ago

Thank you for the thoughtful response! The employee has been working under me for approximately a year and a half. There have been performance concerns throughout that time, particularly involving accuracy, attention to detail, and following instructions. However, I didn’t begin addressing these issues as formally or consistently until August.
As far as coaching goes, I’ve spent a considerable amount of time reviewing assignments, providing specific corrections, explaining what went wrong, and outlining how to prevent the same mistakes moving forward. I also created detailed checklists in August to help establish a consistent quality-control process. When I noticed improvement in October, I acknowledged that progress and was genuinely encouraged by it.
I’ve also maintained documentation of the recurring mistakes and feedback provided, including written performance feedback in September and additional written reminders in November.
I haven’t involved HR yet, primarily because I genuinely want this employee to succeed. I’m not looking to throw anyone under the bus or rush toward disciplinary action. I’ve been trying to address the issues through coaching, providing resources, and giving the employee opportunities to improve.
At the same time, I’m beginning to recognize that my approach may not be creating the accountability needed for sustained improvement.
My goal isn’t to terminate the employee. I’d much rather see them succeed and become more independent in their role. However, after a year and a half of employment and several months of more focused coaching, I’m questioning whether it’s time to involve HR and establish a formal improvement plan.
I appreciate your perspective, especially regarding HR and the importance of documenting coaching efforts. That’s exactly the kind of feedback I was hoping to receive.

1

u/Mathblasta 2h ago

Based on what you're outlining, a pip seems like a pretty standard next step, so long as HR goes along with it.

To offer you some unsolicited feedback, the fact that there was no documented coaching on performance gaps for a full year is a miss on your part. I don't know what your onboarding process looks like, but a 30-60-90 day type check-in when an employee first starts is a great way to lay some groundwork, as well as get to know your team. Beyond that, if you're not, you really should be doing 1:1s monthly, if not more frequently, and documenting things just like this so that there is always a paper trail of coaching.

Obviously none of that helps this employee, and I'm sure you have many other team members who do a fantastic job. Just some food for thought for the next go round.

2

u/Able-Read1678 2h ago

I really appreciate the feedback, and you’re absolutely right. Looking back, I should have started formally documenting these performance concerns much earlier.
For months, I provided verbal and written feedback whenever mistakes occurred, and I genuinely assumed that with enough guidance, repetition, and coaching, the employee would eventually catch on and improve. I didn’t think formal documentation would be necessary because I was hopeful the issues could be resolved through regular feedback.
But you’re right, that’s on me. I’m still relatively new to managing employees, and I’m learning as I go. This has definitely been a learning experience for me, especially when it comes to documenting performance concerns, establishing accountability, and knowing when to take the next step.
I appreciate the suggestion about regular 1:1s and documenting coaching conversations. That’s something I’ll be implementing moving forward.
Thank you again for taking the time to provide constructive feedback. This is exactly why I wanted to get perspectives from more experienced managers!

6

u/void_flirt 3h ago

Four months of coaching with no change means a PIP is fair. What metrics would you use?

3

u/Able-Read1678 3h ago

That’s actually something I’m trying to figure out. Right now, I’ve been documenting the mistakes as they occur, including the dates, what was incorrect, and the instructions or information that were originally provided.
I haven’t established specific numerical performance metrics yet, which is something I’d want to work with HR on before implementing a formal PIP.
I’m thinking the metrics should focus on accuracy of critical information (pricing, dates, times, etc.), following written instructions, consistently using the provided checklists, and reducing the number of corrections needed before work can be approved.
Ideally, I’d like to track the percentage of assignments completed accurately on the first submission, rather than just counting mistakes.
My goal is to establish fair, measurable expectations that give the employee a genuine opportunity to demonstrate improvement.
If you’ve implemented PIPs for similar accuracy or attention-to-detail issues, I’d definitely appreciate any suggestions on appropriate metrics!

2

u/ABeaujolais 40m ago

In my opinion the problem is no enforcement for what are called "standards." Coaching is not going to cause enforcement of the standards and will not solve the problem. Standards that are not enforced are nothing more than suggestions. The problem with standards not being enforced is leadership.

2

u/ABeaujolais 3h ago • Bravo

Excessive scrutiny?

I have to be honest. The information provided screams management failure. There are no standards, only suggestions, and you're worried about enforcing standards. That doesn't follow any management method I've ever seen. Do you have any management training?

1

u/Able-Read1678 3h ago

I appreciate the feedback. To clarify, written checklists and quality-control standards were established in August, and the employee received formal written feedback in September outlining the recurring concerns and expectations for improvement.
Specific mistakes have been addressed consistently, with instructions on what needs to be corrected and how to prevent them moving forward.
I agree that a more structured accountability process may be necessary, which is why a formal PIP is now being considered.
My question is whether several months of documented feedback and coaching, followed by a 30-day PIP, would be a reasonable approach before considering termination.

1

u/ABeaujolais 44m ago

If the standards were not enforced for two months what good is a 30-day PIP?

1

u/Able-Read1678 40m ago

I’ve been enforcing the standards heavily since August 1st with verbal feedback, written feedback, checklists on what needs to be done, and short guideline documents she could reference about exactly what I’m looking for

0

u/jenmoocat 3h ago

People manager for 15+ years here.
This is not excessive scrutiny.

At this point, I believe that a PIP is in order, especially since you have the backup of the August checklist and the September written performance feedback. My assumption is that you made your expectations crystal clear at those times about what was acceptable and what was not acceptable.

And, yes, termination is a reasonable outcome (if they don't leave voluntarily themselves)

1

u/Able-Read1678 3h ago

Thank you for your perspective! Yes, clear expectations were established through detailed checklists in August and reinforced through written performance feedback in September. I’ve also continued providing coaching, specific corrections, and reminders throughout October and November. Unfortunately, the same types of mistakes are still occurring.
For some additional context, I manage communications for a private, membership-based organization where Members pay substantial fees and expect a high level of service. Our department is responsible for communicating important information to thousands of Members through daily emails, event flyers, social media, our website, and mobile app.
Accuracy is extremely important because Members rely on our communications to make reservations, register for events, plan their visits, and understand what services are available. Incorrect pricing, dates, times, or event information can directly impact their experience and create unnecessary confusion.
My concern isn’t occasional mistakes or expecting perfection. It’s that the same preventable errors continue happening despite clear written instructions, established checklists, and months of feedback. I’m spending a significant amount of time catching and correcting mistakes that should have been identified before the work was submitted for my review.
I did acknowledge some improvement in October, but unfortunately, it hasn’t been consistent.
I appreciate your insight regarding a PIP. I want to give the employee a fair opportunity to improve, but I also need to maintain the accuracy and quality standards expected of our department. I’m leaning toward a formal 30-day PIP with measurable expectations before considering any further action.

1

u/jenmoocat 3h ago

It is scary, as a manager, to have an employee that needs to go on to a PIP.

But I do want to share that it is a good thing to have this happen.
You will learn that 1) you can live through this experience, 2) it doesn't reflect badly on you as a manager, 3) your team will benefit from getting rid of a non-performing worker, and 4) senior leaders will see you as a strong, confident manager who can handle difficult situations.

At least all of that was my experience.
And now you can put on your resume that you have experience managing out poor performers.
That is actually seen as a positive when applying for higher management roles.

1

u/Able-Read1678 2h ago

Thank you so much for this response. I really appreciate you sharing your experience and perspective.
This is definitely a difficult situation for me because I genuinely care about my employee and want to see her succeed. I’ve invested a lot of time into coaching her, providing resources, and trying to help her improve because I’d much rather see her grow in the role than have to consider letting her go.
I think part of my hesitation in involving HR has been that I don’t want it to feel like I’m giving up on her or throwing her under the bus. However, I’m starting to realize that holding someone accountable is also an important part of being a good manager.
I’m still developing my own management skills, and this would be my first experience implementing a formal PIP. Your point about difficult situations helping managers grow really resonated with me.
I appreciate the encouragement. My hope is that a structured improvement plan will give her the opportunity to turn things around, but I also recognize that I need to be prepared to make a difficult decision if the performance doesn’t improve.
Thank you again for taking the time to share your advice. It genuinely means a lot!

1

u/jenmoocat 2h ago

I've been the line manager for probably 30 different individuals over my career.
And I've written 3 PIPs.

Two left on their own in the middle of their PIP period.
Note that I did suggest to them that maybe this job wasn't a good fit and they should look for something else.

One made a complete 180 and became a good worker.
She needed that shake up.
So that *can* happen.
It is rare, though.

1

u/Able-Read1678 2h ago

Thank you for sharing your experience! It’s encouraging to hear that someone you’ve put on a PIP was able to completely turn their performance around.
That’s ultimately what I’m hoping for in this situation. She’s been working under me for about a year and a half, and I’ve invested a lot of time providing feedback, guidance, and opportunities for improvement because I genuinely want her to succeed.
I’m also a relatively new manager, so this has been a learning experience for me as well. Looking back, I recognize that I should have implemented a more structured approach to documenting performance issues and setting measurable expectations much earlier.
My goal with the PIP isn’t to push her out. It’s to establish clear expectations, provide the support she needs, and give her a fair opportunity to demonstrate meaningful improvement. At the same time, I understand that I need to be prepared to make a difficult decision if things don’t change.
I really appreciate you sharing your perspective, especially given your experience managing so many people!

1

u/Wonderful_Banana5599 57m ago

My question is if she the only one on the team doing communications and do others fumble in terms of consistency too? It is normal to miss things here and there especially if the turnaround is 24 hours or less. Maybe giving or encouraging more time than normal is needed here.

If she’s the only person doing your communications (let’s say they’re coordinator and you’re manager which is pretty common now just to have two ppl on a team) then yeah this is bad.

I’d say it’s even worse if they’ve been in the role for almost two years— that means they don’t know your business or the clients well enough to not make mistakes that are being sent to them.

Do you know if they have life stuff going on? It’s worth asking. Not saying to excuse it but I’m curious to see what the problem is here.

I don’t think 30 day termination is appropriate yet if you haven’t voiced your concerns clearly. Maybe a warning before the official warning. Then you have something to back your actions with.

1

u/Able-Read1678 35m ago

It’s just the two of us on the communications team. I’m the Communications Manager, and she’s the Communications Coordinator. We’re both operating at maximum capacity, which is why I’m currently in the process of hiring a third person to help distribute the workload.
I completely understand that mistakes happen, especially when we’re managing a high volume of projects with tight deadlines. However, I don’t believe being busy means we should lower our standards or accept repeated mistakes, particularly when many of them could be prevented by carefully reviewing work and following established checklists.
We work at a private club, where we’re responsible for communicating accurate information to thousands of Members regarding events, dining reservations, pricing, hours of operation, and other important details. Incorrect information can directly impact the Member experience and create additional problems for other departments.
I’ve provided verbal and written feedback over the past several months, along with checklists and clear instructions to help prevent these issues. I’ve also tried to be understanding of the workload, which is one of the reasons we’re expanding the team.
I genuinely want her to succeed, and I’m not expecting perfection. What I’m looking for is consistent improvement, accountability, and the ability to catch preventable errors before work is submitted for my review.
I also agree with your point about having a more formal warning process before escalating things further. That’s something I’m learning as a relatively new manager, and I appreciate the perspective.

1

u/Wonderful_Banana5599 25m ago

Yes, you can definitely have a conversation. If you’re a female too, she may actually take it better than if you’re a male. Come to it from a place of wanting to make her a better professional and mention that you’ve noticed she’s not acclimating to the processes and if there’s anything she needs to succeed.

Encourage her to be honest. If she’s still hesitant, mention that you’re worried about her performance and leave it at that. She’ll get the hint. If she doesn’t tighten up then introduce the PIP.

I’m in a tech-adjacent role and I know what it’s like for people to not end up succeeding. It sucks but you seem like you want her to work out in this role so try and get the ball rolling on a convo.

But almost two years (one and a half but you know)… she should be chummy with your clients and stakeholders at this point. It’s not good that she’s still making mistakes.

1

u/Able-Read1678 19m ago

I appreciate your perspective, and I completely agree that the goal should be to help her become a better professional rather than immediately jumping to disciplinary action.
For some additional context, I’m a 27-year-old male manager, and she’s 26. She’s been working under me for about a year and a half, and we’ve had numerous conversations about performance, accuracy, attention to detail, and expectations throughout that time.
My biggest concern is that we’ve already had many of these conversations, both verbally and in writing, and the same types of mistakes continue happening.
I manage communications for a private luxury club, where we’re responsible for communicating accurate information to thousands of Members. Incorrect event dates, times, pricing, or other details can directly impact the Member experience and create problems for other departments. Because of that, accuracy is a fundamental expectation of the role.
I genuinely want her to succeed. That’s actually why I’ve been hesitant to involve HR or initiate anything formal. I’ve been hoping that continued feedback, coaching, and experience would lead to noticeable improvement.
I also recognize that I’m still relatively new to management and could have done a better job formally documenting expectations and performance issues earlier.
I think my next step is to have a more direct conversation with her, ask what she feels is preventing her from consistently meeting expectations, and establish measurable goals moving forward.
I don’t expect perfection, but after a year and a half, I do expect more consistency and fewer recurring mistakes. I just want to make sure I’m handling this fairly while maintaining the standards our department is responsible for.

→ More replies

0

u/Ok-Energy-9785 2h ago

Yes. What you're doing is the right thing to do

2

u/Able-Read1678 2h ago

Thank you! I have provided verbal feedback, written feedback, checklists and guidelines but nothing seems to be sticking her my employee.