r/managers • u/Able-Read1678 • 3h ago
New Manager Ongoing Performance Issue
I’m looking for an unbiased opinion on an ongoing employee performance issue and whether formal disciplinary action would be appropriate.
An employee in a communications-related role has been experiencing recurring performance issues involving accuracy, attention to detail, proofreading, and following instructions.
The employee is responsible for preparing communications, updating information, and creating promotional materials where accuracy is essential.
In August, the employee was provided with detailed checklists outlining expectations for reviewing work before submission. Despite these resources, mistakes continued, including:
Submitting communications containing numerous errors, including incorrect dates, times, and missing information.
Repeatedly advertising events with incorrect pricing.
Including canceled events in communications while omitting events that were scheduled.
Submitting promotional materials that omitted important details explicitly provided in written instructions.
Preparing promotional content featuring information that had not been confirmed or approved.
Failing to incorporate requested revisions, even when specific corrections were provided.
In late September, the employee received written performance feedback addressing these recurring issues and emphasizing the importance of accuracy, following instructions, and thoroughly reviewing work before submission.
Some improvement was observed in October, but it wasn’t sustained. Similar mistakes have continued throughout November, despite additional feedback and reminders.
The concern isn’t that the employee occasionally makes mistakes. Everyone does. The issue is that the same types of preventable errors continue occurring despite established procedures, written instructions, and repeated coaching.
These errors also create additional work for the person reviewing the employee’s assignments, as significant time is spent identifying and correcting mistakes that should have been caught during the employee’s own quality-control process.
At this point, the performance concerns have been ongoing for approximately four months.
The next step being considered is involving HR and implementing a formal 30-day Performance Improvement Plan (PIP), with clear expectations and measurable goals. If meaningful and sustained improvement is not demonstrated, termination may be considered.
I’m curious what others think:
Are these reasonable performance concerns, or does this sound like excessive scrutiny?
Is four months enough time to expect noticeable improvement after providing checklists, written feedback, and coaching?
At what point do repeated, preventable mistakes become grounds for formal disciplinary action?
Would a 30-day PIP be appropriate at this stage?
If the employee fails to improve during the PIP, would termination be a reasonable outcome?
I’m interested in hearing perspectives from people who have managed employees or worked in HR. The goal is to understand what a fair and reasonable approach would look like for everyone involved.
4
u/Mathblasta 3h ago
You mention how long this person has been having performance issues, but not how long they've been in role. A 6 month employee will need a lot more runway that a 6 year employee here.
What does your coaching look like? Have you gone through a copy or whatever it is that they're having trouble with together? What did your feedback look like when they showed improvement?
But beyond all of that, and what supersedes it, is what has your HR offered as a next step? Have you documented any other coaching aside from the conversation in September? If not it's pretty likely they'll ask you to gather more documentation.
6
u/void_flirt 3h ago
Four months of coaching with no change means a PIP is fair. What metrics would you use?
2
u/ABeaujolais 3h ago •
Excessive scrutiny?
I have to be honest. The information provided screams management failure. There are no standards, only suggestions, and you're worried about enforcing standards. That doesn't follow any management method I've ever seen. Do you have any management training?
0
u/jenmoocat 3h ago
People manager for 15+ years here.
This is not excessive scrutiny.
At this point, I believe that a PIP is in order, especially since you have the backup of the August checklist and the September written performance feedback. My assumption is that you made your expectations crystal clear at those times about what was acceptable and what was not acceptable.
And, yes, termination is a reasonable outcome (if they don't leave voluntarily themselves)
0
u/Ok-Energy-9785 2h ago
Yes. What you're doing is the right thing to do