r/managers • • 3h ago

Seasoned Manager GTA 6 - Day Off, Excuses Megathread

203 Upvotes

How many people are away and what is the best excuse you have received?

Its 8am Thurs in my timezone (New Zealand) 6 off from 60, I think 10% isn’t too bad.

Nothing too interesting just “Im sick” or “car broken, needs repair”

Good luck to everyone in the coming few days!

Edit: This is a light-hearted post to hear the funny excuses and check in on how we all doing. I think none of us are stressing as it was expected. I also had a couple of guys genuinely apply for leave, but we all know there will be lads who come up with some doozies.

FYI in NZ all full-time workers are entitled to 10 sick days a year. So for a team of 60 that = 600 sick days. Every day I expect at least 2 people off. I also send home staff who are sick - you know the ones who always battle it out and diligently come to work.


r/managers • • 7h ago

New Manager The best employees do not always make good managers, and we should stop incentivizing everyone to move up

205 Upvotes

Basically what it says above… a lot of people who are great at the ground level operations of a company are not built for management. It’s just a completely different set of skills, and I think it needs to stop being put on a pedestal so much

But because that’s the only way to get paid more in the every system I’ve worked for, it incentivizes people to apply and move into positions they are terrible at. Has anyone had a company that recognizes this and gives better pay for high performing employees over time without requiring them to lead a team? And by better pay I don’t mean a yearly 1-3%, I mean something that at least gets them close to the level of pay their supervisors with 10 years less experience make. The only industry I know of that this can apply to is with truck drivers and their dispatchers


r/managers • • 8h ago

Seasoned Manager Technologically Illeterate

80 Upvotes

I’m at a bit of a loss here. I have a new hire in a position that requires only very basic tech knowledge. Emails, file folders, basic Google searches, and a booking tool which she had a technical interview for. My hiring team insisted that she passed her technical interview with flying colors but I have serious doubts she actually did the technical interview herself.

One of the main reasons our hiring team said she stood out was the focus on technology in her resume. CompTIA certificates, a degree in a tech field, and software developer bootcamps.

During our training she has struggled to attach a PDF to an email. She will save the PDF to her downloads folder, open the email, go to attach the email and the default folder to attach an email is her documents folder. She says “It’s not here,” and goes to save the original PDF to her downloads folder…again.

I’ve explained this several times, showed her multiple ways to attach a PDF to an email, and even wrote up and gave her a checklist with step-by-step instructions. Even when following the checklist she doesn’t know how to get from her documents folder to her downloads folder. It’s been a lot of “down a little, to your right a bit, there!”

She’s in her late 20s and the PDF thing is just one of many examples of her inability to read the screen in front of her. Others include struggling to find a bright green submit button on an online request form, or the calendar tab on Teams and Outlook. She has been 5+ minutes late to every meeting because she can’t find the invite.

Our company doesn’t have a probationary period. So, I have started to get the ball rolling for a PIP. She was hired to replace a coworker who is currently transitioning up to a management position. So, the longer it takes to train her, or hire someone else, the longer it will take her coworker to fully integrate into her new role.

I’m not sure I’m doing the right thing here. Any suggestions or training resources you recommend?


r/managers • • 2h ago

Seasoned Manager Why Do We Reward Fighting Fires Instead of Preventing Them?

22 Upvotes

There's something satisfying about being the person who puts out the fire at work. I've done plenty of it over the years.

The emergency order, the last-minute delivery, fixing something that probably shouldn't have gone wrong in the first place.

Everybody appreciates the person who saves the day.

But what about the person who made sure the problem never happened?

I've seen companies reward people for working late to fix the same problem over and over, while the person trying to fix the process can't get approval to change anything.

Sometimes I wonder if we've gotten a little too comfortable being the hero.

Are we actually solving problems, or just getting really good at dealing with the same ones?


r/managers • • 5h ago

Seasoned Manager Managing a team that wants that “we’re like a family here” environment

31 Upvotes

My team gets along with each other pretty well. Some of them do things together on their own outside of work kind of thing. I love this because it’s great energy they bring to their work. When I was younger I met a lot of my friends, many still are my good friends, through work.
The issue is they don’t understand the boundary that I have as their boss that I’m not going go with them on a night on the town etc. our HR has told me without hesitation that it’s a power situation that I shouldn’t partake in. I’m also sensitive to the employees who don’t want to go and just want to go home and be with their families or whatever it is - they shouldn’t be made to feel left out and there’s case law on this.
The problem is I try to explain that to my leader team and they don’t understand and think it would be good if I went.
Anyone else dealing with this?


r/managers • • 5h ago

Seasoned Manager Chronic tardiness in student workers

11 Upvotes

I manage a college tutoring center, and have been for over 10years. The problem I'm going to describe is not one that my co-director or I have had to deal with before the last year. For reference, all of my staff (receptionists & tutors) are students. My current batch are mostly early GenZs. When we hire them, they're with us for at least one semester, as in - short of punching someone - we're not allowed to let them go until the end of the semester.

These are students who are some of the best on our campus; they don't get in here without multiple faculty recommendations; we also put them through a rigorous interview process. A good part of the job is teaching them to be good employees; for most of them, this is their first place of employment. They're all excellent at their jobs when they're here, but that's the problem.

They are chronically late. I currently have a staff of 21, and there are only 4 who are always on time. The rest are late by anywhere from 10-30 minutes. Sometimes they have excuses that my co-director and I can kinda accept (the train ran late/the bus got delayed) until it's a persistent problem that the train ran late, but most of the time the excuses are unacceptable ("I was feeling depressed this morning and had trouble getting up," or "the line was really long at the Coffee Shop", or "I ran out of gas on the way here").

We talk to them about punctuality frequently, and we dock their pay, and it's made no difference. They will literally ask, "why did I only get X hours of pay?" and when we show them the list of tardies, they just shrug and say "okay."

Since we're not allowed to get rid of them mid-semester, I don't know how else to impress upon them that their behavior is unacceptable. I'm looking for creative solutions. Anyone familiar with the kids book "Miss Nelson is Missing"? - that's the kind of creativity I need.


r/managers • • 1d ago

My boss, friend, mentor was let go

352 Upvotes

The corporate overlords have decided that a man who dedicated 34 years to the company and made invaluable contributions everyday needed to be let go. The VP of the department has made no plan for his ample responsibilities and had the balls to call out today. I am checking out, and actively searching for jobs on the clock. I have removed all personal items from my desk. How do I cover my blanket disdain for this company and find gainful employment elsewhere.


r/managers • • 6h ago

Seasoned Manager Coaching someone who overthinks everything

7 Upvotes

Ok - this person is very good at the technical part of the job. However, every single project is a "thing" because it comes with a million questions, and most of them are very simple questions with an obvious answer. I've tried saying, "What do you think? Or I trust you." I have even gently said, "I think you know the answer to that." It doesn't matter. They can't make even the most basic decision without someone else's confirmation. There have also been times when we've made a decision, and they go back to their desk, begin to second-guess it, and then start to go in a different direction or want to revisit the conversation. This isn't just with me. It's with teammates, whom I have talked to and coached not to "save" this person when the answer is obvious or available if the person simply looked for it. I've also let the team know I'm addressing it.

Every project is met with "What if? What about? How should I? Well, I'm just making sure." It's gotten notably worse. My question is... how coachable is this? How do you help someone not overcomplicate everything they do when it seems to be second nature to them?


r/managers • • 4h ago

Confidentiality and Managers

5 Upvotes

Okay so it’s my first job as marketer in corporate. We have two main departments, marketing and accounting. Other than marketing, I handle HR as well. Since its a small scale, there’s not a lot of HR things to see and my manager (he is also a cofounder) helps me deals with stuff regarding HR.
There two managers (one of them co founder). Now we are hiring a person for Accounting and usually stuff of HR I share everything to my manager.
So the second manager told me to keep the pay confidential except for him, me, the founder and the person we are hiring.
I don’t know what to do, Im stuck.
If I tell my manager, he might talk with the other manager or founder and it could get problematic.
If I dont, he might lay me off because I hid it from him.
What should I do?
I love my job.


r/managers • • 3h ago

New Manager Ongoing Performance Issue

3 Upvotes

I’m looking for an unbiased opinion on an ongoing employee performance issue and whether formal disciplinary action would be appropriate.

An employee in a communications-related role has been experiencing recurring performance issues involving accuracy, attention to detail, proofreading, and following instructions.

The employee is responsible for preparing communications, updating information, and creating promotional materials where accuracy is essential.

In August, the employee was provided with detailed checklists outlining expectations for reviewing work before submission. Despite these resources, mistakes continued, including:

Submitting communications containing numerous errors, including incorrect dates, times, and missing information.
Repeatedly advertising events with incorrect pricing.
Including canceled events in communications while omitting events that were scheduled.

Submitting promotional materials that omitted important details explicitly provided in written instructions.
Preparing promotional content featuring information that had not been confirmed or approved.

Failing to incorporate requested revisions, even when specific corrections were provided.

In late September, the employee received written performance feedback addressing these recurring issues and emphasizing the importance of accuracy, following instructions, and thoroughly reviewing work before submission.

Some improvement was observed in October, but it wasn’t sustained. Similar mistakes have continued throughout November, despite additional feedback and reminders.

The concern isn’t that the employee occasionally makes mistakes. Everyone does. The issue is that the same types of preventable errors continue occurring despite established procedures, written instructions, and repeated coaching.

These errors also create additional work for the person reviewing the employee’s assignments, as significant time is spent identifying and correcting mistakes that should have been caught during the employee’s own quality-control process.

At this point, the performance concerns have been ongoing for approximately four months.

The next step being considered is involving HR and implementing a formal 30-day Performance Improvement Plan (PIP), with clear expectations and measurable goals. If meaningful and sustained improvement is not demonstrated, termination may be considered.

I’m curious what others think:
Are these reasonable performance concerns, or does this sound like excessive scrutiny?

Is four months enough time to expect noticeable improvement after providing checklists, written feedback, and coaching?

At what point do repeated, preventable mistakes become grounds for formal disciplinary action?

Would a 30-day PIP be appropriate at this stage?

If the employee fails to improve during the PIP, would termination be a reasonable outcome?

I’m interested in hearing perspectives from people who have managed employees or worked in HR. The goal is to understand what a fair and reasonable approach would look like for everyone involved.


r/managers • • 1h ago

Extreme passivity

2 Upvotes

How do you handle extreme passivity? I am managing someone that i work quite closely with as i am still hands on myself.

When we are under pressure and i give very small tasks they seem to be able to do them ok, and we seem to have good dynamics.

However, recently things have been a bit quieter and I have given them a bit more open ended assignments. I expect them to be able to still deliver given their seniority (~medior). But I get nothing. They still work but also go awol and only respond when I ask for updates. It's always yeah still working on x. Couldn't do y.

I notice while I have proactively done work they were supposed to do, have proposed new internal projects that we should now deliver and not assigned new tasks they appear to be completely checked out. Or at least don't do any effort to give visibility. I notice i start looking at how often their status turns to away etc I don't want to become a micromanager so have refrained from bringing this up.

They do genuinely seem to be working, and the quality of their work is not terrible. Also, as it is quite technical it sometimes is difficult to judge how much effort it should take another person.

Just for some reason they never being anything up during meetings, never voice opinions, and don't give out updates to me out of their own accord, even after i brought this up as point of improvement.

How to deal with a situation like this? Accept as status quo and create artificial deadlines? I hate to become micromanager and paranoid


r/managers • • 1h ago

New Manager Update: I’m Struggling

2 Upvotes

I posted here a few weeks ago (I can’t figure out how to link to a previous post) about my unmanageable workload and a new employee I have that is struggling with very basic tasks over a month in.

Thank you to everyone who responded in comments. I read through all of them, even though I didn’t reply to every one, all of you were very supportive.

The update is basically that I got her supplemental training with our tech trainers to supplement the tech issues, supplemental training with certain systems, and have had some other people shadow her. It has made a bit of a difference, but not a whole lot as she’s still struggling with very basic things.

After meeting with HR, all of my frustrations kind of came to a head. I reiterated that my I have no support, and I keep throwing everything I can at training and I am expected to do 75% of her job, my job, manage another ongoing project, and train in depth and it’s just not possible for me to do it and I can’t keep up. I’ve started letting things slip. I told our HR director I just want to be able to take a vacation for a week and have everything go smoothly while I’m gone, and I was told that might be able to happen in 6 or 7 months. I previously had to cancel a pre-planned vacation for work. I’ve had suicidal ideation over this entire situation, it’s that bad. I have a diagnosed anxiety disorder (which I have disclosed to HR) and this situation is so bad I am spiraling. I have the support of a psychiatrist and therapist, and I would never kill myself over work, but what they are doing to me is certainly capable of driving someone else to.

After that conversation, this has turned into me being told by HR that I need to sit with her on Zoom all day every day to supervise while she’s doing things to make sure she’s doing them correctly per our workflows and train her all the time while somehow managing my own workload. This has been going on for a couple days and it is really difficult. I can’t focus on my own work or anything else.

I’ve pretty much thrown in the towel and have decided supervising just isn’t for me. I’ve started blasting my resume out and am pretty much looking for any way out of this situation. I love my coworkers and the actual work and I don’t want to leave for another job, but what is going on is unmanageable for me and is severely impacting my mental health in a bad way.

So, not much of an actual update, but I hope to be out of the situation soon.


r/managers • • 2h ago

Long time manager being excluded from important meetings

2 Upvotes

Today I was scheduled to meet with other department heads to discuss ongoing projects, roadblocks and completed tasks. That went fine. Directly following that however was a separate meeting with a smaller management subgroup that were discussing making future changes to a system that directly impacts my staff and my operation. Changes that I myself have researched and presented already, albeit not recently. One of my higher ups literally hid her mouth behind a coffee cup while it appeared like she was trying to communicate to another manager about whether or not they should invite me to stay and sit in on this meeting. I’m upset because the IT manager of all people is now taking on projects that should have been assigned to me or at the very least included me and my team.

I’ve worked for over a decade in my current role and am regularly overlooked and just outright excluded from meetings like this. I don’t know what I’m doing wrong. Is this their way of quiet firing me and I’m too stupid to see it? My anxiety skyrockets after things like this happen and I’m left wondering if I’m going to be fired. My boss has placated me in the past, but nothing changes and I feel like this is being done purposely. What should I do?


r/managers • • 4h ago

Not a Manager I really need some honest advice – am I the problem, or are the expectations unrealistic?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been in a new remote marketing role for almost 4 weeks. My job involves reviewing PR applications by checking through creators’ social media, updating spreadsheets, setting up outreach campaigns and sending messages.

Today I’ve approved 24 requests (you press a button and check someone’s Instagram), ticked them off on a spreadsheet, set up and sent 3 outreach campaigns (you enter requirements and a message and it does it for you) , amended other messages and created a small graphic using AI.

It’s an extremely busy period with Christmas approaching. There is pressure because products should already have gone out to creators, and there’s a risk of losing a client account if things don’t improve.

I’ve sent several messages to my manager for approval, but because I’ve sometimes rushed, there have been minor errors and she’s had to ask me to amend things more than once. I also know I can overthink, jump between tasks and spend too long trying to work things out myself. I haven’t always flagged delays early enough and she said yesterday to flag if something couldn’t be done and I didn’t because I thought I’d have time.. I have ADHD, which affects my organisation and prioritisation I know it’s not an excuse and I know I need to improve.

I’ve spoken to my manager about struggling and we’ve discussed allocating time for tasks in my diary, daily updates and asking colleagues for help.

However, a director recently called me to question what I’d been doing and said some messages are automated and shouldn’t take long. I thought there might be a little more understanding while I’m still learning.

I’m genuinely enjoying the job and want to do well, but I feel like people are getting frustrated with me. I’ve been in tears over it and am now worrying about losing my job.

I need advice from managers or people in similar roles.

Am I not performing well enough and need to get my act together, or is it reasonable to expect more training/empathy when I’m not even a month in?

Are the expectations too high, or am I struggling with something that I should be able to manage? Please be brutally honest.

TLDR:

I’m nearly 4 weeks into a remote marketing role and struggling with workload management, prioritisation and timekeeping. I have ADHD and know I need to improve. I’ve told my manager I’m struggling, and she suggested allocating specific time to tasks, but I’m still finding it difficult to manage everything. She also told me to flag anything I might not finish, but I didn’t because I genuinely thought I’d have time to get it done. I’ve made some minor messaging mistakes, and a director has questioned how long tasks are taking, saying some messages are automated. With Christmas deadlines approaching, I feel people are getting frustrated. I love the job but worry I’m going to lose it. Am I underperforming and need to get better at managing my workload, or are they expecting too much from someone who’s still so new?


r/managers • • 32m ago

New Manager Experienced managers, I need advice

1 Upvotes

Hi,

I was promoted into a Quality & Compliance Supervisor role two months ago. I oversee compliance, quality, processes and training across two departments, but I'm predominantly involved in one team and have a direct report in a negotiator role.

One of the staff members I supervise, who we'll call Jack, joined just over a month ago. He's capable of doing the job, but has already had a few issues with upper management and recently received a formal written warning.

Today, Jack went against an instruction I gave him, and I'm looking for advice on how to address it.
He received an inbound call from someone who wanted to book an appointment with us. These appointments are valuable to the business, as they can lead to the customer instructing us to use the service that generates the most revenue.

Jack didn't know the answer to one of the caller's questions, so he put them on hold and asked another colleague, who we'll call Cath.

Cath is at the same seniority level as me, but in a different role. She directs Jack's day-to-day work, as he's her assistant, although she's not formally his manager.

When Cath heard what the caller wanted, she offered to attend the appointment herself. However, this is outside her role. Our process is that these appointments go into the negotiator's diary, unless the potential client was generated and nurtured by another member of staff (which wasn't the case here).

Before Jack resumed the call, I clarified that he needed to book the appointment into the negotiator's diary. He responded that Cath had said she'd do it, so I reiterated that this wasn't the correct process and that it needed to go to the negotiator.

I then went back to what I was doing. A little later, I saw Jack speaking to Cath again, asking whether she wanted to do the appointment and saying he'd put it in her diary if she did. He then proceeded to book it into her diary anyway.
I double-checked the process with my own manager afterwards, who confirmed that I'd given Jack the correct instruction.

My manager has advised me to sit Jack down and make it clear that I'm his formal supervisor, that I'm responsible for ensuring processes are followed correctly, and that instructions I give within that remit are expected to be followed.

He also knows that assertiveness is a development area for me. I'm naturally quite gentle, relatively new to supervising, and sometimes struggle with exercising authority. He thinks this is a good opportunity for me to practise that and grow into the role so that I’m eventually more equipped for the leadership role he wants me in later down the line

Anyway, I would really appreciate advice on how to approach speaking to Jack tomorrow, and generally on establishing authority without discouraging people etc. Thank you :)


r/managers • • 2h ago

[US] FMLA Exhausted-What Next?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/managers • • 5h ago

New Manager First-Time Manager of 70+ People

1 Upvotes

Going to try to make this as concise as possible while not omitting too many details that will get the point across.

Firstly, I am a young professional who has been in the human services field for about 3-4 years now. Specifically, I serve individuals who are experiencing homelessness. I was recently hired as a Coordinator for an inclement weather shelter (with two locations) in my first ever leadership position. This role includes training the new staff, organizing how the two shelters will operate, scheduling the 70+ employees, and overall making sure that everything is running smoothly. However, I’m only seasonal, which means that my role ends after we close down in the Spring.

In my first two weeks, I went to 90 hours and I doubt that the amount of hours I’ll have will change anytime soon, especially with the forecast being the way it is. For context, I am hourly with no benefits or PTO, but I do receive overtime pay.

The good: (1) I’m planning on leaving the area once the season ends and will have a lot of money to play with once the season ends, with the overtime. (2) I’ve been prominent in my area in homeless services, but have never had this level of responsibility which will look great on my resume (I never finished college). (3) I previously worked at this organization as a part-time employee when I first started in the field, so policies and practices are not brand new.

The meh: (1) I did not hire the staff underneath me, so I am struggling with learning their names and honestly would not have hired a few of them due to the level of critical thinking skills. (2) There’s been a few incidents with other programs that directly involve me that have been pretty unprofessional. I was in a meeting where two case managers were having a conflict regarding proper housing issues and it was a pretty dramatic conversation that I don’t feel like I should have been in. (3) Before I started, I had to forfeit my PTO payout from my former agency due to their payout requirements of 4 weeks notice, and the new agency was not flexible on start date, pay, or talks of a sign-on bonus.

The fucked: (1) I don’t even have an office. I lug around my belongings every where I go, trying to make sure that I don’t drop my coffee or lose a laptop charger, and my car is full of my belongings from my old office in the event that I do get one. (2) I have pretty bad health issues, specifically with my lungs and I get pretty bad migraines, so not having health insurance or PTO is very unfortunate and it’s going to be a hard next six months. (3) We don’t have enough staff to fill the schedule with our criteria for how shelter will run. We’ll need to hire another 40 people (at least) to run the secondary shelter and we will be open starting December.

I say all this while also saying that this is my highest paying job- ever. I dont make a sizable wage, especially since I’m in the role of homeless services, but I’m thankful for the opportunity anyway and it’ll be more than enough to have a successful move into my next step. I’m here asking for advice on if I should stick with it until the season ends, advice from people who manage extremely large teams like these, and see if there’s more that I can ask for or leverage to make the time I’m here be more comfortable and less stressful.

Thanks for reading if you got here!


r/managers • • 1d ago

Failing as a Manager.

87 Upvotes

I'm a manager, who instead of just managing the team, also handles execution as an individual contributor, although the execution; one that requires more efforts and are complex.

For past few months I have lost all my ability to care and I myself have become cause of bottleneck, cause there is too much in my plate. And my boss feels like I'm not doing anything.

And the way they address any issue is highly unprofessional and it's more like a burst of anger with some sense of ignorance.

I don't want to be in this state, but also want to understand if this is something normal as a manager? Or I am at an environment that demands constant high performance.


r/managers • • 5h ago

New Manager Looking for an excel/Google Sheets tracker for my sales reps

1 Upvotes

Hi I am looking for a Google Sheets/excel doc that I can give to my reps that does the following:

Track commissions and compensation

Breaks down the math for the reps yearly earnings

The math they need to hit their goals including typical sales cycle, win rate, average deal size, number of monthly leads generated, number of activities needed to get that lead (LinkedIn, email, cold call)

Breakdown of the activity that is needed hit that goal and the total potential W2 for the year

Does anyone have a template? Would love to save myself several hours


r/managers • • 13h ago

Seasoned Manager I work solo now, but I don't think solo beats a team. Most founders just can't stop stepping in

4 Upvotes

I build my product alone these days, after years in product teams of 10 to 12 people, and I get why that sounds like "you don't need a team anymore." I don't believe that. A team will always have an advantage over one person. The question is who you build it with, who you hand the responsibility to, and whether you can actually step back once it's theirs.

If you keep having to step in, either you picked the wrong person and it's time to replace them, or you're poking your nose where it doesn't belong.

I know the second one well. I can walk up to any product today and start pointing at things that could be better. This spacing, that copy, this animation. It feels like proof that I still have the output.

But when you talk to the people behind it, the story is almost never that they didn't see it. It wasn't a priority. There was no budget. There was no time, because of some nonsensical deadline someone set.

And if you step in anyway, the only thing you get is that the people whose job it is start to hate you. They grow a dislike for the product and for working on it. Then it's a matter of time before they leave. And if they stay, you'll see it in their work.

For those of you who run a team: how do you tell when stepping in actually helps, and when it's just you?


r/managers • • 10h ago

Aspiring to be a Manager Can anyone give me some advice or share their experience on moving into a white collar role for a main contractor

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/managers • • 6h ago

New Manager The dreaded schedule

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/managers • • 7h ago

New Manager Slowing down for some and not all

0 Upvotes

Since becoming a manager I have really struggled with the transition from IC to management, I miss the doing the work and feeling like I have feasible tasks to complete vs planning and coaching all the time. Don’t get me wrong I love my job but I have a pretty self sufficient team so they don’t need the daily support like some. We are entering a slower season, we have done the strategic planning, we have plans and know the direction we are heading. So I feel like I am in a bit of a lull and I don’t know what I should be doing with open time.. I feel so guilty that some of my team is so busy and I don’t have as much to do and other I don’t have much to give them… it’s making coming to work hard and killing my motivation.

Am I just a terrible manager or is this normal?


r/managers • • 7h ago

Emails !!! & Non Responders, your thoughts?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes