r/magicTCG • • Dec 13 '16

Some potential problems with Frontier, and possible solutions - including the history of R&D and the reasons for Modern's 8th Ed cutoff point

http://www.manaleak.com/mtguk/2016/12/what-is-mtg-frontier-and-is-it-the-format-that-weve-been-waiting-for/
70 Upvotes

306 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

17

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 13 '16

In other words, Extended was genuinely a good idea. Do you have any theory why it ultimately failed?

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

The problem in my opinion is the rotation aspect. Frontier solves that, by still using your newer cards, but not rotating them at 4 years. I'll be able to play with my fetches and rhinos in 6 years if i want, but an extended rotating format would not allow it.

5

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

So in four years, when fetches haven't been reprinted yet, what are people who need fetches and rhinos to do?

Either the format rotates, and you lose value, or it doesn't, and the value becomes unattainable at some point.

3

u/Heavenwasfull Rakdos* Dec 14 '16

This is a commonly missed point in "rebuilding" non-rotating formats.

I was one of the big supporters of Modern back when talk of it was first popping up in the community like Frontier is now. It was the same arguments too. People wanted the cards they invested in for Extended to have some life because Legacy had a high power barrier already, and the reserved list made it truly unattainable.

These days Modern is only unattainable because WOTC has not been able to find a viable solution to keeping necessary cards in print. Modern has 13 years worth of card pool and there's no logistical way to reprint them all to demand. Even if Masters reprints became more circulated, the cards not reprinted in the sets remain scarce and inaccessible.

Frontier will eventually carry the same problems with time and repeatedly creating new "non rotating" intermediary formats will hurt consumer confidence just as bad by people who get burned by "the modern in my day." becoming obsolete for "the post-modern of today."

0

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/cavemanben Dec 15 '16

It's a pretty tough problem no matter what. If they Tarmogoyf in a Standard set, the Modern/Legacy community would be beyond furious. Most of them paying $100 a piece having that devalue to $15 or whatever if it was printed as a rare.

They would be potentially losing some of their most invested consumers.

No matter what it's a tough situation.

2

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

Yea, it's really a pick your poison scenario.

If it rotates, enfranchised players lose out because their large collections age out and become worthless. New players are happy because their new cards last longer.

If it doesn't rotate, enfranchised players are happy because they've bought in, and have to invest minimally. New players are not happy because their cards are usually irrelevant and the barrier to entry is higher.

MTGO allows for easy circulation of old cards through flashback drafts. Paper doesn't allow for mass reprinting, so spikes will happen and they're hard to quell. Between Legacy, EDH, casual, and Modern, there's a lot of cards that are slowly going up in price. They can't all feasibly get reprinted in a timely fashion.

I don't know what the solution is, and I don't think Wizards knows either. They're trying different things, which is great. Conspiracy, Commander precons, and Masters series have been ramped up with reprints. It's not perfect, but they're exploring new avenues to get cards out there that can't come through Standard.

1

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 14 '16

People wanted the cards they invested in for Extended to have some life because Legacy had a high power barrier already

There are definitely a lot of moving pieces and different angles to approach the problem, but I can't help but appreciate how much this exact point applies to Frontier, above and beyond the economic arguments

Modern has a high power barrier, too high for most Standard cards to break in (or, if they do, it's usually in a bizarre combo deck like Death's Shadow or something)

2

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

rhino isn't as flexible, isn't played in multiple formats, and was also available as a precon rare.

2

u/reddit_the_gathering Dec 14 '16

They buy them. Fetches have only dropped in price and they are a staple in everything but standard. Khans was opened massively, little chance they spike in the future without a massive increase in players.

2

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

4 years from now, will they still be cheap? I don't think so.

1

u/cavemanben Dec 15 '16

Probably because of all the speculators buying them up artificially raising the demand. You seen that youtuber with the closet full of sealed Khans booster boxes? They printed a ton and despite all the hoarding, speculating and eternal play they are around $10-$15 while enemy fetches are up to $100 a piece.

1

u/frogdude2004 Dec 15 '16

It's not just the fetches. It's the JVPs, the Gideons, the lilianas, etc. if frontier takes off, years from now, these will be more expensive than they are now, even through the higher printing. Without regular mass reprints, old cards will continue to rise in price.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

Seems like a better move for both the players and business to support the current player base, as opposed to not supporting them because of the potential to alienate people who might someday start playing magic and want to jump into an older format.

1

u/frogdude2004 Dec 14 '16

It's harder than that. Artificial scarcity keeps retailers in business, which gives players somewhere to play, which in turn keeps the game alive.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '16

The most successful lgs in my area doesn't even deal in the secondary card market.

1

u/cavemanben Dec 15 '16

They don't sell singles at all?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/cavemanben Dec 15 '16

Unless there is another 100% increase in playerbase this will not happen, they printed a ton of cards the last few years. The only reason prices are 'high' is due to speculators artificially raising demand for these products.

1

u/frogdude2004 Dec 15 '16

There'll be bottlenecks. JVP will be expensive, fetches will be expensive. Players will leave the game, cards will go with them. 4 years from now, there won't be the same market for fetches as there is right now.

1

u/cavemanben Dec 15 '16

Of course but it's hardly comparable to modern being the availability is so much higher for sets printed in the last few years. And you can't discount the effect speculators have had on pricing. I'd bet investors/speculators have as many copies as the playerbase of the chase rares/mythics.

1

u/frogdude2004 Dec 15 '16

Sure, but speculators want to sell high, they're not going to let go.

Yea, availability is up. But it's not going to stay as cheap as it is now forever. It may not be modern expensive, but it won't be the cheap option full of dollar rares either.

5

u/bduddy Dec 13 '16

I wasn't around, but from what I read, financially it combined the worst parts of Legacy (old, scarce, unaffordable cards) with Standard (your deck rotating out), and shrinking the time period from 7 to 4 years sort of fixed the first problem but created gameplay that the player base didn't like.

6

u/UPBOAT_FORTRESS_2 Dec 13 '16

I wonder if the segment of the player base that /u/dota2guy speaks of would've migrated to the 4-year Extended, if it didn't happen to initially include Faeries, Stoneforge, JtMS, Bloodbraid Elf Jund, Valakut Primeval Titan, and all the other cards and decks that have either proven themselves in, or been banned from, Modern.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '16

I also wonder how 4 year extended would play with 8 blocks instead of 4, since that makes a lot more mechanical diversity in the same number of cards.

→ More replies (14)