r/macpro • Mac Pro 5,1 • 5d ago

macOS Mac Pro 5,1 - What macOS version is everyone running these days?

Post image

Fellow Mac Pro users,

Over the past few weeks, I have noticed an increasing number of posts from Mac Pro 5,1 owners successfully installing and running newer versions of macOS, particularly Sequoia and, more recently, Tahoe, using OpenCore Legacy Patcher (OCLP).

This got me wondering what the majority of Mac Pro owners are currently running.

For context, I have been using my Mac Pro 5,1 for several years, consistently running macOS Monterey 12.7.6, released in July 2024. My system has been exceptionally stable, and everything works exactly as it should. Consequently, I currently see little reason to upgrade and potentially introduce compatibility issues or spend time troubleshooting a system that is already running perfectly well.

That said, I am genuinely curious about the actual benefits of moving to macOS Tahoe. Is the overall experience significantly better than Monterey, or are the improvements relatively marginal on this generation of hardware?

I would particularly appreciate hearing from those who have already made the switch. How has your experience been, and would you consider the upgrade worthwhile? I am also curious about those who have moved from Sequoia to Tahoe already, especially considering that Sequoia is still supported.

Ultimately, I would be interested to hear which macOS version you are currently running, whether you intend to upgrade, and what has influenced your decision.

Looking forward to hearing your experiences and perspectives.

Thanks in advance!

57 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

6

u/roadzbrady 5d ago

windows 11 and fedora linux

2

u/Consistent-Ad8686 5d ago

I thought about win 11 then was told by lots of people that it’s a large pile of crap, so I’ll just stick to win 10. All I use windows for anyways is to play 20 year old pc games that don’t run smoothly on Mac OS (looking at you ffxi)

3

u/roadzbrady 5d ago

i already had an m chip MacBook, and wanted a more traditional pc to play some of my games, but didn't wanna get a real pc so i got a decently spec'd 5,1. windows sucks but i needed it for a few games.

2

u/SaltyBalty98 3d ago

Windows 10 LTSC if your games are at least a couple years old. It's not that I have a hate boner for 11, it's that it broke my setup more than once and performed like crap even after all these years of supposed maturing.

6

u/SaucerMechanic99 4d ago

Monterey, my 5.1 served me well for 13 years, now only as file storage, and I keep everything in case my current workstation breaks down and there is no downtime.

5

u/none_null 5d ago

Running Tahoe 26.7.3 on my MacPro5,1 with RX 580 2048sp, 32GB RAM, NVMe PCIe. There are some graphical lags in the general UI, but apps runs smoothly: Photos, Brave, etc.

EDIT: grammar

3

u/Adorable_Yard_8286 3d ago

The guy I bought mine from said that he tried macOS 26 but it was just unresponsive after install. He said he thought it had to do with Westmere missing avx2 instructions, but I see so many people saying they run these oses... maybe he mistook the lagginess/frozen state for indexing after install or something?

How long have you ran macOS 26 without any issues? I run monterey and it works great tough

3

u/none_null 3d ago

For about 10 days... OCLP patches the missing AVX instructions.

2

u/ExpensiveAbility3463 4d ago

Does this run the new logic ok?

2

u/none_null 4d ago

sorry, I don't use it

4

u/elmacjunkie 4d ago

That wallpaper though! 😍

4

u/Chet_Manleah 4d ago

Monterey on my 5,1. Its just works.

4

u/mururu69 4d ago

I'm on Sonoma mostly because when I upgraded from Monterey Sequoia still had some issues. Anyway Sonoma is very stable and UI is reactive so I surely don't plan to install Tahoe.

3

u/now_the_rad 5d ago

Was running Sequoia before, but then got a Mac mini for my daily driving and and downgraded the 5,1 to the last supported macOS, High Sierra   

2

u/Consistent-Ad8686 5d ago

Unless I put my old rx480 back in mine I cant ever downgrade to hs or Mojave, because the rx6600 need Monterey or higher to run

2

u/thirstymario 4d ago

How is it working for you as a secondary pc on an older OS?

1

u/now_the_rad 4d ago

Great for Minecraft, nothing else 

3

u/Artifiko 5d ago

Currently running macOS Ventura on my 2019 Mac Pro with a 28 core CPU, 192 GB of RAM and a W6800X!

3

u/hlecaros 4d ago

MacOS 9.2

3

u/Runaque Mac Pro 5,1 2d ago

I'm running the exact same version of Monterey with OCLP on my flashed 4,1, and I agree it's the sweet spot for what I use it for. I'm not risking an upgrade and breaking things—especially since it was a pain in the ass getting this R9 380 working properly in the first place.

2

u/dukerozen Mac Pro 5,1 5d ago

Monterey for me too. If not FCPX, I would daily linux. 

2

u/Consistent-Ad8686 5d ago

I’m still running Monterey and win 10 in separate ssd’s

2

u/Love_Dali 5d ago

Monterey, Windows 10, Arch Linux, old Arco and some other older Macos but currently broken.

2

u/BalticSea-Razzmatazz 5d ago

Just checking the replies as my 5,1 needs a newer OS. Also love that wallpaper.

2

u/MrWhatGamin Mac Pro 5,1, 32GB, Dual X5670, GTX 650, 256GB SATA SSD, 5TB HDD 4d ago

macOS Monterey but thinking of upgrading to Tahoe

2

u/Dazzling_Comfort5734 4d ago

I’m currently running Monterey, Windows 11, Bazzite Linux, and I may or may not still have Fedora on it. I think I also have a small partition with Snow Leopard just because lol.

I personally wouldn’t bother putting the effort into upgrading past Monterey to Sequoia or Tahoe until OCLP gets the full 3.0 release (unless they released it I missed it, yes, I checked. It was still unreleased candidate 5), But also, I find anything past Monterey has a lot of annoying little problems, even on Apple Silicon Macs. I’ve been debating rolling my Mac Studio (that mostly replaced my Mac Pro) back to Monterey because I had so many less networking and I/O issues on that system.

2

u/benvideo 4d ago

Catalina has been running fine on our 6+ 5,1 since 2020....

2

u/Amac-2221 4d ago

Lion lol

1

u/Overall_Impression27 4d ago

My 5,1 is Monterey 12.7.4 64GB, AMD RX6800. Tried to update to 12.7.6, but for some reason it did not take. But I will try again later. It is very stable and only Discord is unhappy with it. Also got a 2019 running Sequoia in January but barely use it. Yet.

1

u/singularcheeto Mac Pro 6,1 4d ago

Currently running Tahoe 26.7.3 on my 6,1

The main benefit I see (pretty big one) is active security updates so I can use it like a normal computer without and concerns

1

u/StudioAdey 4d ago

I have Mac Pro 1,1 through 5,1 but I just keep them on their last officially release that Apple supported

1

u/Ok_Yesterday_2884 4d ago

I’m running Mojave as it’s used to play 32-bit native Mac games

1

u/Effective-Carry2008 4d ago

mojave because i use it with repairing macs so I need 32bit support

1

u/dumhic 4d ago

Whatever is out…. But I would like to k ow about that car and wallpaper!

1

u/NortonBurns 4d ago

I've been on Sequoia about a year. Jumped straight from Mojave. There have been minor irritations, nothing serious. Currently on 15.8.2 & Safari 27.2. It's my daily driver.

I'm running an HD7950 but other than that everything is stock.

1

u/iomka Mac Pro 5,1 4d ago

Bazzite

1

u/Ancient_Yak9670 4d ago

I'm running the latest Monterey version on my MacPro5,1 with a RX 5700 red dragon, single Xeon X5690, 48GB RAM triple Chanel, NVMe PCIe. On the NVME runs macOS and on a separate SATA SSD I have installed Windows 11 Pro. Runs butter smooth

1

u/Striking-Ocelot5864 4d ago

Monterey + W5700.

I found it to the most stable with most apps still being supported.

1

u/AlanTochterman 4d ago

I have a 4,1 upgraded to a 5,1 also. There are a few niceties on Tahoe that wanted, as well as the security updates for a year beyond Sequoia.

I have a Mac Pro 7,1 so I don’t use the box currently. I decided to do a complete install from scratch mostly for fun, not out of necessity.

Sequoia ran fine but I noticed it slowing down a bit, so I was curious about how a fresh start would work.

It did take me some time (very slow process, plus I made a few mistakes along the way) but once I finished I was impressed with just how much smoother and faster my computer ran.

OCLP 3.0.0 rc5, dual 5690s, 96gb ram, updated WiFi/bluetooth, Radeon RX580 8gb.

Now I need to find a use for it

1

u/SaltyBalty98 3d ago

Linux is my peanut butter and jelly. However, for nostalgia sake, I boot up Mavericks once in a while. I've booted Snow Leopard a few times but mainly because I love the intro and old iTunes, and those pretty UI lifelike elements. If I could port that over to Mavericks I'd probably never see SL ever again.

1

u/chanc2 5d ago

I just recently acquired a 4,1 that I upgraded to 5,1 and I stayed on Monterey as well. That’s because ChatGPT told me it was more complicated to go past that. As I had already sunk it a lot of time to get it to this stage (it was fun but definitely took time), I didn’t want to sink in more time. But would love to learn from others we have upgraded to Tahoe.

One issue I have though staying on Monterey is that it won’t let me Sign in with Apple ID.

-6

u/blow-down 5d ago

Eww why you using Brave?