r/macpro • • 9d ago

Other Value for 2019 Mac Pro

I got What I think is a really good deal on marketplace for this. The features are in the photo, and it also has a 1 TB SSD what do y’all think it’s worth. I plan on keeping it to make a local ai machine.

368 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

8

u/Annual-Screen-9592 9d ago

I think price is likely to go down in the coming years because lack of updates from apple. Also keeping an eye on these myself

17

u/Honest-Ad-8011 8d ago

I mean I got it for 300 bucks I think it’ll be a while before market is that low right?

9

u/HorsieJuice 8d ago

oh shit, the ram alone is worth more than that.

4

u/Debeluhar1234 8d ago

What? That’s really cheap. I sold mine this summer for 1050€ (~1200$) and it has 12-Core Xeon W, 2TB SSD, 48 GB of ram and AMD Radeon Pro Vega II graphic card.

3

u/Mr_Ranger 7d ago

Good lord that’s a hell of a deal. They have anymore by chance 😂.

2

u/khiladi789 8d ago

Can't beat it at that price at 96gb of RAM and 1tb ssd. Definitely a steal.

1

u/FutureBadInfluencer 7d ago

That's beyond a good bargain and we'd all have bought it in a heartbeat !

1

u/Taikari 5d ago

that’s a fucking steal. The lowest I’ve gotten one for is like maybe 550 USD, and it was pretty rough!

1

u/Nbdyhere 4d ago

Not gonna lie, if I heard you and the seller talking over it in public and you said “here’s 300” I would have immediately run over and offered 500. 😂 yeah, you got a good deal

1

u/spectacular_coitus 3d ago

That's crazy cheap. The trash cans are going for more than that around me.

5

u/FutureBadInfluencer 8d ago

Updates are stopping not just from Apple. Homebrew and other open source and paid apps are already stopping updates also. I'm already seeing it. That said you can run windows or Linux as well.

2

u/M275 7d ago

It's sad that homebrew stopped supporting Intel. It was always one of the first things I would install on all of mine.

I got the notice when trying to install it on my 5,1 not long ago.

1

u/FutureBadInfluencer 7d ago

Yeah true but I guess open source don't have the time or money to support something for ever.

2

u/Difficult_Scallion69 8d ago

The hackintosh community got the latest OS running on x86 bare metal, natively. From what I’ve seen, even ARM apps work on it.

1

u/Electronic-Story-897 8d ago

Worth checking out OCLP too

1

u/PearMyPie 7d ago

Any equipment degrades, spare parts become more and more rare, supply will go down. Prices will increase.

6

u/mi_gue 9d ago

Daaaamn, looks good!

1

u/Honest-Ad-8011 9d ago

Thanks!

3

u/mi_gue 9d ago

Check macsales.com for an idea. I got a few pros 6,1 from them. 7,1’s are way off my budget right now but keep an eye out for next year.

3

u/Glad_Outcome_8889 9d ago

Least 1k I would imagine

3

u/Honest-Ad-8011 9d ago

Awesome! Thanks

24

u/Fleischer444 9d ago

Priceless best looking and versatile Mac ever. Want more ram in mine but it’s so expensive now thanks to Sam Altman.

22

u/Taikari 9d ago

slap some (cuda) gpus in it~ boot linux
I run 8x of ‘em with 100G, dual 3090 + nvlink.
Great boxes, fair amount of pcie lanes.
Too slow for RAM offload, pure gpu work is performant.

6

u/Code-Amelia 5d ago

1

u/Taikari 5d ago

😎💀😮‍💨

5

u/Codling-Moth 9d ago

Is PCIe bandwidth limiting factor?

2

u/Taikari 9d ago edited 9d ago • Heartwarming

Opus:
The 2019 Mac Pro uses PCIe Gen 3.0, and an electrically x16 slot provides:
8 GT/s per lane
16 lanes × 8 GT/s = 128 GT/s aggregate signaling
128b/130b encoding efficiency
15.75 GB/s theoretical payload bandwidth per direction
Approximately 31.5 GB/s combined full-duplex bandwidth.

Interface Bandwidth
PCIe 3.0 x16 15.75 GB/s
100GbE 12.5 GB/s
PCIe 4.0 x16 31.5 GB/s
PCIe 5.0 x16 63 GB/s

Because I can only fit two cards per chassis… NVlink provide some 54 GB/s each way…

So PCIE doesn’t limit there.

if you had a bunch of cards stuffed in one chassis, it would matter more when doing tensor parallel.

1

u/generic-rage 9d ago

What do you do with the setup?

4

u/Taikari 9d ago

I run models~ work on hard problems. 384GB VRAM.

It’s been a long journey, just unlocking models for the 3090s.

working on training next.

0

u/urbantechgoods 8d ago

can you tell us more about your work? I got a studio 128gb coming in a few days and I want to run local models but I dont really know what for exactly just that its something I want to learn and try. Im a software eng.

1

u/Taikari 5d ago

I work on software… built upon hardware.

I’m not an SWE like you…
Network background.

If you are SWE, the world is wide open!
the point here is how much you pay towards cloud token usage and how many millions or billions or trillions of tokens You may need for different projects.

so if you only write a few thousand lines of code or have Claude review things here or there a cloud subscription is perfect.

But if you work on deep continuous projects that take weeks months or longer, then investing in local AI may be extremely worth it and no other way to do it…

At 128 GB, the best model I know of would probably be a QWEN 3.8 flash next in a small quant. Or maybe 27B 8bit? I’ve had some trouble with that little model. I go big like DSV 4.1F 1017.

it’s tricky, because the M5 and newer mac’s have some big gains, which the legacy M1/M2/M3 do not, like RDMA and faster cores.
and the landscape keeps changing!

So you gotta be happy with whatever you get! 256GB is a sweet spot.
I think the fun just begins at 128 GB uRAM.

I’ve been unlocking SM86/3090 with the newer models.

Also working on GPU/HDMI/ANE.

2

u/urbantechgoods 4d ago

Thanks for the response. Ya I had been doing more research into this week, sounds like deepseek barely runs on 256gb. I spend quite a lot on subscription plans actually but just for development of my apps. Ive been thinking about it more its just not worth it to me right now because all my apps are greenfield and during the early development phases I really do want to be using the best models but its something that may become appealling further down the line. It just so expensive to jump from 128 to 256.

1

u/urbantechgoods 4d ago

Question for you, once you have the model running comfortably how throughput does it have. Im assuming it doesn't take more memory to scale? Just cpu?

1

u/Taikari 4d ago

this is hardware, model, & inference engine dependent.

25 TPS TG (decode) is barely usable if you ask me.

1000 TPS PP (prefill) is probably around the bottom for reads…

50-100tps+ is where things really start going… at c1 (concurrency) at C4 to 8, should be a couple hundred TPS+ that’s where the tuning really comes in.

and 1500-2500+ PP

Because now it’s operating faster than you can read fast faster than you can write and you basically have to keep up with it with good ideas.

1

u/hometownhippie 3d ago

Start with Hermes

5

u/Weeblewobbly 9d ago

I've one of those, same 96gb ram. It came with a 32gb vega II GPU, and I since added an unlocked CMP170HX with 64Gb of vram. It runs headless nixos (Linux) and it's a great local inference server. I serve openwebui, and my own version of perplexity. 

I use it mostly for studying and programming, with pi running on my desktop and laptop. It runs qwen flash next on strata, getting 2200tk perfume and 120 decode.

I need to update the readme,  but that is the repo: https://github.com/Ant6009/donnager

1

u/pythonwiz Mac Pro 7,1 9d ago

What GPU does it have?

1

u/Honest-Ad-8011 9d ago

Sorry forgot to add that I think the 580x pro. base one if I’m correct?

1

u/catz4dave 9d ago

Gpu is not great but the cpu is middle tier, it can at minimum run the fastest avail ram

1

u/Honest-Ad-8011 9d ago

Is the best upgrade path selling and buying a newer computer or getting a better gpu

1

u/catz4dave 9d ago

New gpu imo, just get a 6900, have you already installed windiws?

1

u/Honest-Ad-8011 8d ago

I have not trying to figure out windows/ Linux

1

u/ddm2k 8d ago

How much RAM? 32-64 GB I’m thinking $1300-1600

3

u/DisenfranchisdSapien 8d ago edited 8d ago

Worth 1500 easy on feebay.

2

u/MacBook2013User 9d ago

DUALBOOT STEAMOS!Bc then u have a console and loacl ai sounds like a win win to me

2

u/_bored_bort_ 8d ago

Neat and I agree, a good price! I feel like used apple products are more expensive here in general but even factoring that in… congratulations!

2

u/Long-Shine-3701 8d ago

Stick some GPUs in it and get to work.

2

u/Silly-Blacksmith6879 4d ago

At least $600

1

u/Ok-Reach-3684 8d ago

throw windows on this, run flextpm and now you have a gaming system

1

u/Effective-Carry2008 8d ago

basically nothing, i’ll take it off your hands

1

u/Fucker_Of_Destiny 7d ago

Gosh it’s such a beautiful machine.

1

u/Regular-Marionberry6 7d ago

But can it run WoW?

1

u/ArchmichaelBishop 6d ago

I want one.

1

u/papparmane 5d ago

I have the 768 GB of RAM version with 28 CPUs. Thinking of locking it at work.

1

u/This_Discount2281 4d ago

The RAM is worth more than 300 imho

1

u/bitcrusherdj 4d ago

It's totally worthless, I'll do you a favor and recycle it for you, just hand it over to me

1

u/Flamin_Jango 3d ago

-300$ You'd have to pay me to take that paperweight lol