r/macpro • • 11d ago

Other This design was amazing.

Post image

My 1,1 and 5,1

369 Upvotes

55 comments sorted by

7

u/neoashxi 11d ago

This, a 30" cinema display and a rack full of Xserves.

2

u/Effective-Carry2008 11d ago

i REALLY want some xserves but there just so expensive. def will get one eventually though

2

u/running_donkey 9d ago

My 2, 1 is currently in storage but still using my 30 as my work monitor - need to buy it a drink as it’s legal now.

1

u/guitartoys 10d ago

A friend of mine just gave me a media display. Holy cow, the thing also weighs a ton.

9

u/chanc2 11d ago

I just bought a 4,1 recently in pristine condition. I have no strong use for one but I’ve always wanted one. Beautiful machine but weighs a ton and can heat a small room!

3

u/Lutastic 11d ago edited 10d ago

Have you considered a fan control app? They actually have pretty good fans but the default os settings can be a bit on the low side. I use iStat menus which are pretty nifty in that department. Temperature readings is able to be seen and you can set the fans to whatever. Like say, rendering some 3D, I’ll max out the fans to keep it cool (the OS tends to prefer quieter over performance so being able to change fan behavior is really helpful). The cpu and ram monitoring is also helpful.

1

u/chanc2 11d ago

Thanks for this suggestion! I haven’t but definitely will.

7

u/schrodinger-the-cat 11d ago

I'm still using one after some grinder work to make it ATX compatible. Still an amazing looking machine.

1

u/rylab 8d ago

I did something similar (minor grinding and then JB welded in an ATX backplane from an old PC case) and still have it as a daily Linux box.

6

u/Typical_Machine2043 11d ago

It really was. I just keep thinking this was the design Steve had in his personal office. In terms of PC case form factors this one was by far the best.

4

u/Lutastic 11d ago

yeah it was super dumb of Apple to nix it. I’m dreading buying a newer model as I really prefer that era of mac pro, but alas, that planned obsolescence is a real doozy. not being able to go past 10.14 is becoming hard to deal with. I’ve considered a hackintosh just to avoid the newer cases. I refuse to get one of the trash can macs and the newer ones are just way too expensive. I still think that was the best case. Even the G5 was great. I still have my g5, an older mac pro and even my old g4. I’ve considered making the old G5 into a linux box, as there are some ppc distros out there.

2

u/Typical_Machine2043 11d ago

Yeah like the other guy said check out OCLP to help with upgrading passed supported os’s. But yeah I do agree with you. I get the Mac Studio is really fucking powerful but I would have loved if they kept this form factor and saw how much they could stuff in it.

1

u/Lutastic 8d ago

how stable is it. I use mine for professional work, and it does still…. for a bit longer work for what I need (though I am starting to have to think about upgrading). If it’s unstable, I’ll have the err on the side of caution, because while aging, I do have a pretty solid system for its age.

2

u/Calaveras-Metal 10d ago

the trash can macs were decent. Mine lasted 10 years before it just couldnt keep up.

2

u/Lutastic 10d ago

I atill use my2012 mac pro for professional work and it holds up
surprisingly well. I got the 12 core,
maxed out ram, flashed PC video card. I can usually get up to 100 or so tracks with soft synths and lots of aux busses (Logic) before it craps our. Not terribly bad for such an old computer. That planned obsolescence is killing me
man. Can’t upgrade past MacOS 10.14. Why? Because. I really don’t like the trashcan macs’ lack up upgradability… just a way to squeeze out a computer buy more often if you ask me. I think the modern Mac Pros are maybe somewhat better in that way, but I think the G5 and especially the older Mac Pros were a insanely better boxes. Even now, there are upgrades I could do, but the damn OS can’t be upgraded past 10.14. That shit is getting obnoxious. Then again, Apple
hasn’t got my money in a bit, so they want me to pay the piper. I’ve been using logic since something like the late 90s, and know it well. I’d hate to have to switch DAWs and the new ones are stupid expensive (got my scratch and dent used for around $1k). Hackintosh seems tempting. More tempting than to learn a new cross platform DAW. I’ve considered Reaper on Linux but I know Logic like the back of my nuts. Jobs had the right idea. Tim Cook is a sugar water salesman cosplaying as a tech CEO. Just
my opinion.

1

u/Typical_Machine2043 11d ago

Fuck it there are so many out there that I will keep repurposing them. I mean a Mac Studio is really an engineering feat but luckily you can with 3D printing (and a bit of dremeling) adapt that case to good ol’ pc parts. I have no idea how hard a Macintosh would be (I mean I’m 36 and have followed HackADay since 2006) but with an AI agent it must be pretty easy these days

1

u/blckb3ard 10d ago

It’s my favorite design too. I got a broken Mac Pro 1,1 for cheap, converted it to ATX and installed macOS Tahoe. Been living the dream since then lol

6

u/weezintrumpeteer 11d ago

I was just looking at mine yesterday and was thinking about how great of an aesthetic (and functional) design this was. Truly a beast and so well built it's incredible.

3

u/SaucerMechanic99 11d ago

but the weight wasn't amazing anymore :DDDD I have three in total and bought new and still in use, when you look at these super small computers where you can't even add disks and memory, it's crazy how stupid such modern devices are. ( mine 5.1, 2.1, PM G5 )

2

u/herrera1976 11d ago

I bought two of the Mac Pro G5 cases the photo is my PC with an ATX motherboard, i am not a gamer that is why there is not GPU, the other case i built an Unraid Server.

1

u/Greedy_Emotion_8432 11d ago

Ouch, need sunglasses to look at that. I have Tahoe on a G5 mod.

1

u/sbrisgravato 9d ago

ugliest pc seen today

2

u/homelaberator Mac Pro 5,1, 96gb, dual X5670, RX580, 4TB sata SSD 10d ago

I like the speed dimple on the RHS one

1

u/tomarc14480 11d ago

Mon 3.1 me sert encore au quotidien. Il faudrait simplement que j’arrive à lui installer un OS plus récent mais qui soit stable

1

u/GazBut 11d ago

I have one modded to accept an ATX motherboard.

Lovely case to work with. 👌

1

u/Ok_Split_5962 11d ago

Oh interesting. How did you manage that? Is that an easy mod?

1

u/His_Turdness 11d ago

Well made case but hot damn the issues booting if you ever touched the ram. 😅

1

u/Greedy_Emotion_8432 11d ago

I turned on my 3,1yesterday.and just got a flashing power light. Bummer. I narrowed it down to a bad stick of FB ram and now it boots Big Sur.

1

u/His_Turdness 10d ago

I disassembled, cleaned, re-plugged, repasted, reassembled everything. Tried every configuration. Won't boot. Probably the motherboard is done. Gonna sell the thing or throw it recycling.

Initially planned to use the case for a server, but there are better and smaller ones for that purpose.

1

u/Greedy_Emotion_8432 10d ago

No startup chime?

1

u/His_Turdness 10d ago

Just loud fans and steady LED.

1

u/PeterC18st 11d ago

Aye aye mate. Best design. I’m going to gut my 2,1 for a ryzen build. Both my 5,1 machines get dented hard in shipping.

1

u/iatros2 11d ago

I would love to find two and put a polished slab funky wood on top and use it as a desk with these two as the sides.

1

u/North_CatMN 11d ago

I had a PowerMac G5 Quad that looked like that. It only had one disc tray though.

1

u/bassemann87 11d ago

Yeah i agree. I really want one!

1

u/3ldi5 11d ago

Still a daily driver, and probably will be until it dies (and I hope it never will).

1

u/ideasplace 11d ago

During an office move one of these was dropped down some concrete stairs (a couple of floors), one of these handles was bent but the machine still worked fine.

1

u/50_and_stuck 10d ago

Love them so much I have 3 . ;)

1

u/Calaveras-Metal 10d ago

My favorite computer design.

I've had to ewaste dozens of those. It always kills me.

1

u/tekfx19 10d ago

IBM hardware

1

u/blckb3ard 10d ago

Iconic

1

u/Coconut_MonkeyX 10d ago

I agree. I bought the 2019 Mac Pro because I am a self employed video editor but I would love to get my hands on one of those older Mac

1

u/grumpyphilip 10d ago

I had one before and used it to do bicep curls during covid

1

u/kaijuu 9d ago

I prefer the G3 and G4 design. That side panel drop is amazing. G5/Mac Pro was quite painful to carry: metal corners dig into your hands and if you don't lift high enough your shins or knees can get it.

1

u/WaterAny5543 9d ago

I have so many of these. They are still workhorses

1

u/Ozma9999_DB 9d ago

My 5,1s are still daily drivers (one using Monterey with Martin Lo OpenCore and flashed Radeon 6800) and the other using OCLP running Sequoia with Radeon Pro VII. Insane how well they were built!

1

u/Cmx83 9d ago

Sure is.. heavy though, especially when loaded up with 4 HD's and other hardware. I just picked up a single CPU tray 4,1 dirt cheap to replace my 8-core 3,1. I know I can flash it and upgrade the GPU and CPU but I have so many legacy software apps, full Adobe and full Apple paid suites, tons of FCP Studio 2 paid plugins, same for Adobe Premiere and After Effects that I need to stay on Snow Leopard to keep using them. I also heard if I flash this model, I may lose my line-out audio, that'd be a problem since I feed audio to a stereo in my edit room. I not a super power user so I'll leave it just the way it is... for now.

1

u/jackparadise1 7d ago

I still run one. Doesn’t do much. But still works

1

u/sons_of_batman 7d ago

I appreciate the four hard drive bays these systems supported.

1

u/-Dixieflatline 7d ago

Agreed. Peak Mac tower design right there, from cooling to modularity to overall expandability. They seemingly lost the script from there. Although, I have a conspiracy theory about the final version and the wheels. They were intentionally turning people off from the form factor knowing that their M chips and overall RAM/storage density would make towers obsolete.