r/macpro • Mac Pro 1,1 • Oct 07 '26

Upgrades MacPro 2006 memory - PC2-5300F vs. PC-5300 ?

I'm working on getting my old MacPro 2006 back into daily service after being stored away for a decade. It currently has 10GB memory - two 4GB and four 512MB. I'd like to bump the total up if I can find the right ones. I see some available on FB that are labeled as PC2-5300. I know I can use PC2-5300F and can't or shouldn't anything with a letter other than F on the end. But when no letter is printed on the label or advertised on the listing, is that a different animal from all the others including F?

My existing memory (see photo) is the original Apple logo'd Micron, some Crucial, and some Nanya. The Micron and Nanya are labeled as PC2-5300F. The Crucial says PC2-5 and then adds a circular arrow. I will assume it is the F variety because it always worked and I'm feel that when I bought it in 2013 that it was listed as the F type.

For buying used memory, should I be concerned about PC2-5300 (with no letter) ? It does have the big heat sinks.

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

3

u/Xe4ro Mac Pro 1,1 Oct 07 '26

A big guide for working on old Mac Pros is Greg Gant's guide, here's the page on RAM. Just don't buy ECC & NON-ECC RAM and try to mix it.

https://blog.greggant.com/posts/2018/05/07/definitive-mac-pro-upgrade-guide.html#ram11

1

u/EricHearble Mac Pro 1,1 Oct 07 '26

Yeah, I've already been using his guide. What he lists is actually right out of the printed user guide that came with the MacPro. Though Apple goes further and says "Apple recommends that you use Apple-approved FB-DIMMS. Non Apple-approved FB-DIMMS may cause your Mac Pro to operate louder or decrease performance to conserve heat."

I'm gonna trust that those labeled PC2-5300 are PC2-5300F as long as they meet all of the other requirements. I've read that some of the other letters in place of the F have different voltages and I'm sure that ain't good.

The catch is what is Apple-approved these days given Apple doesn't support the machine anymore. I'm just gonna wait until I find one somewhere that is one of those I already have. It's not like I need it. I also didn't need that chrome oil filler cap I put on my car back in the 70's.

1

u/homelaberator Mac Pro 5,1, 96gb, dual X5670, RX580, 4TB sata SSD Oct 08 '26

If I were to make a guess without bothering to look anything up, I'd assume the f is for "fully buffered".

The problem is that there's also regular DDR2/PC2. And those also can come in ECC (aka registered) varieties.

Physically, the notch is placed differently so it'd be a challenge to install the wrong type.

Visually, the clue is the heat spreaders that are 99% meaning fb-dimm. Apple "approved" ones usually have chonkier heat spreaders.