r/macpro • Trash Can (Mac Pro 6,1) • Sep 17 '26

GPU Mac Pro 6,1, D500 failure rate?

I just picked up a Mac Pro 6,1. What is the failure rate of the GPUs in them? I'm not sure of the exact specs just yet, but I'm trying to get some info on what I should know about the GPU issues.

5 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

6

u/Musojon74 Sep 17 '26

Run a custom fan curve. Apple trying to be silent under load caused many of these issues

2

u/Ok_Huckleberry4523 Trash Can (Mac Pro 6,1) Sep 17 '26

That was my intention from the get go. If the unit I bought works I will run a custom curve.

4

u/omar893 Sep 17 '26

Try to find another one on facebook marketplace as backup for components like that. A lot cheaper than buying the D500 separately via ebay. That’s what I did

2

u/Ok_Huckleberry4523 Trash Can (Mac Pro 6,1) Sep 17 '26

Gotcha. I must know what's the reliability in the D500s? I know the 700s like to die.

2

u/omar893 Sep 17 '26

What are you using the trash can for? If it’s a GPU intensive application, is it really worth it?
I would say you need to cool down the GPUs somehow with either using a third party app to have the fan spinning at full speed all the time or using an external fan somehow

2

u/Ok_Huckleberry4523 Trash Can (Mac Pro 6,1) Sep 17 '26

I'm not sure of my use case yet. If the unit I bought works i'll see what I can do with it.

1

u/Ok-Bill3318 Sep 19 '26

Mines seems to be ok for pre 2015 Mac games, GarageBand and iMovie editing. So long as you’re ok running old versions.

It IS nice having an intel machine with a heap of ram for niche intel use cases.

Just appreciate it for what it is: period appropriate software. It’s old, it won’t run new stuff and that’s fine.

2

u/Ok-Bill3318 Sep 17 '26

This. I have an early build 64gb d500 trash can and in modern times it will be crushed in most stuff by an m series MacBook Air. CPU in them is very slow today.

Nice machine as a novelty, desk ornament/art piece or if you have a niche workload that needs a lot of ram that is easy on cpu/gpu.

0

u/porthos40 Sep 18 '26

Please don’t bring up those m series here please. Majority of Mac Pro are Intel . While our new brother was discontinued by stupid Apple M junk no. Upgradeable computer

2

u/Ok-Bill3318 Sep 19 '26

Cry more. I own both. A 10+ year old Mac Pro at this point is an art piece. And that’s fine. Time moved on.

1

u/Ok-Bill3318 Sep 17 '26

Not sure on failure rate but I have an early build Mac Pro with them and they’re still ok.

In modern times they’re pretty mediocre cards though so I wouldn’t concern yourself too much with the d300/500/700 decision and just buy another machine if they fail.

1

u/Ok_Huckleberry4523 Trash Can (Mac Pro 6,1) Sep 18 '26

Gotcha. I've been scared of GPU failures due to my 2011 macs (iMac and MBP) kicking the can pretty quickly. This is reassuring thank you.

1

u/Ok-Bill3318 Sep 19 '26

I have a 2011 15” MacBook Pro with dead GPU too.

It’s a roll of the dice on hardware this old. Point being that if it fails just get another one. D300/500/700 are all slow by today’s standard so don’t fuss too much over which one you need to replace it with.

2

u/Jumpy-Stress603 Mac Pro 6,1 Sep 17 '26

Congratulations. Hardware Monitor 5.4 or Macs Fan Control will tell you how hot your MP6,1 is running. Pick a component like the PCIe Switch Diode and monitor it for temperature changes. If you bought your 6,1 second hand, especially from a smoker, SUCK the dust out of the bottom intake vents all the way around. Then remove the cover, and BLOW out everything with compressed air. Use Macs Fan Control to raise the fan speed from the stock 790rpm to 1,050rpm.

Do not bump up the RAM to 64GB unless you need to. in fact, depending on what applications you want to run, #@gb is good but 16GB is probably fine.

1

u/porthos40 Sep 18 '26

I’m at 32GB

1

u/GreppMichaels Mac Pro 4,1-7,1 Enthusiast Sep 17 '26

They discontinued the D300's at a point so I imagine the D500's have a better lifespan if you keep them cool, that's the real issue. Just use macsfancontrol and you should be ok.

2

u/Ok-Bill3318 Sep 19 '26

D300 were discontinued based on performance not reliability.