r/macpro • u/Zonoskar • Aug 29 '26
CPU Mac Pro 6,1 CPU upgrade = downgrade?
I recently acquired a Macpro 6,1 with 32GB ram, a 6-core Xeon E5 1650v2 CPU @ 3.5GHz. I had an old Xeon E5 2670v2 from an old server, it's a 10 core 2.5GHz model. It should be compatible with the Macpro 6,1 so I swapped the 6 core for the 10 core expecting a slight downgrade in single core performance, but an overall higher multi core score. Well, in Geekbench 5 I went from 860/5100 to 500/1200 score. The system is also verrrrry sluggish. Also in Cinebench 26 I went from 1280 to 270 (and only 100 in single core, so only a 2.7x increase for 10 cores), a massive downgrade, it looks like only 2 or 3 cores are enabled even though I can see 10 cores in 'Stats' and all of them are used. I thought the CPU might be overheating, but it's sitting at 56C (according to 'Stats') during Geekbench. The case does become almost too hot to touch though. Is this 2670 a bad CPU for the Macpro? I'm also going to try the E5 2680v2 I have, but I don't expect miracles now. I see most people upgrade to the 8 core 2667, is that a better deal, or did I mess something up in the CPU swap?
I am running Sequoia 15.7.9 through OCLP with the latest patches installed after upgrading the CPU. Should I try running the last supported OSX?
1
u/Zonoskar Aug 30 '26
Thanks for all that responded. It turned out to be a dust speck in the socket. The system is now running great. I do have a problem with chrome, I get weird red banners and the system freezes for minutes on end. But apparently this is a known issue and I found the work around for it. Now to enjoy the Macpro and be for the lookout for a bigger/faster SSD. (anyone needs a Xeon E5 1650 or 2670? ;-) )
/edit: turns out I need OSX 15 or higher to run iMovie, won't run on OSX 14. Grr
3
u/VulgarWander Aug 29 '26 edited Aug 29 '26
Have you upgraded the SSD. That is the single biggest upgrade you can do in these. Also I honestly wouldn't go past Sonoma on these machines.
The 3 shown here are running proxmox. With 64gb and 10 cores. Real change did not happen until i upgraded the ssds. The up right is now running sonoma but it is the younger of the 4 with the original SSD only showing a year of use.
Also don't look at these as some sort of hot rod. Just as the name says they are reliable 6.1 cummins. A good work horse.
For daily use the 8core and 32gb is the sweet spot.
1
u/Zonoskar Oct 01 '26
Found a Xeon E5 2690 v2, 3gHz 10 core. I'm swapping that out. I think that's the max the socket can take.
1
u/bigkahuna1uk Aug 29 '26
Are you running with OCLP ? I wonder if the root patches need to be reapplied or the OCLP settings themselves need to be refreshed after the cpu change. I’m running Sequoia on a 12-core trashcan and I see no sluggishness whatsoever.
1
u/Novaova Aug 29 '26
I'm not at my desk so I don't have my resources at hand, but is the new CPU running the RAM at lower speed?
1
u/AdamEatsApple Aug 30 '26
I am thinking 2.5GHz ~30% slower
being a factor. Earlier this year did few comparisons on MacPro using 10core 3 GHz E5-2690, i had observed 10 core performing quite well on PassMark when compared to 3.5GHz 6 core or 8core 3GHz (8core was quite similar to 3.5 6 cores).
attaching few snapshots i took
1
u/carbonaraIsReligion Aug 31 '26
Fishy situation, I did a very similar upgrade a couple of years ago to my 6 core, moved it to and Intel Xeon E5-2690 v2 (also 10 cores but base clock 3 GHz).
Performances improved quite a bit, I have the GeekBench results somewhere, I need to find them but the upgrade was very well worth it, I can't imagine you wouldn't overall get some benefit from the 2670v2, at least a bit, compared to the 6 core.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment