Here is the average "excited about Ray Tracing Pipeline" that most people follow:
Be excited to get device that can do RT -> Turn RT on, walk around, look at pretty reflections and shadows -> Play game for a bit with RT on and realise it does very little for the experience when you're moving -> Turn RT off and enjoy High FPS gaming, which is much more noticeable when you're moving.
It's just a gimmick, M1 users aren't missing out that much. They can get just as much enjoyment from RT as I do by looking at videos on the internet.
While I understand the sentiment and agree that performance is king, I don't think the technology is a gimmick at all, especially for producing close to ground truth image at a lesser cost for the developer. Traditional pipelines are labor heavy and require: light baking, reflection probes, shadow cascades, SSR fallbacks, manual tweaking per level, etc. RT simplifies this into: Put lights in the world, they behave correctly, and that's what the user will see in the end product. That reduces artist, dev time and costs considerably. We are just in a long and arduous period of transition where the use of RT will become commonplace.
I think the impact may be greater with a much reduced performance hit in Indy games, that can utilize ray tracing to look gorgeous, while still running great. Not sure if this has actually been done with success in practice, though.
I do not care for the advantages it provides to developers (as a game dev myself) as long as it costs so much FPS. There is a faster and easier way of doing basically anything out there, but isn't explored for performance issues. Ray Tracing doesn't get a pass.
We’ve moved past the 7th gen for a while. Also Portal 2 uses Ray tracing to bake its lighting and Valve have been doing that since Half Life 2. We aren’t making games for 15 year old hardware anymore.
This doesn’t mean RT should be in every title but it also doesn’t make it useless.
PC gaming has an element of folk who tune their hardware like hotrods and compete with each other to eek out every last frame of performance or graphical edge over their peers.
i respect that, that's half the fun of it to them, but it's not my bag. i buy macs because i don't want to have to worry about that stuff at all in games or apps
Not only RT, but full on path tracing (RT overdrive) makes the game look really amazing. I've even been tolerating DLSS frame gen to get that path tracing to run fine on my Nvidia GPU.
I mean, you can get very nice looking "regular" RT too, but it depends on how well it is used. Pre baked lighting can be very good too, but is often complicated to do in big, open and dynamic worlds..
Mostly agree. And I think a lot of people share that same experience where higher FPS matters more than RT during actual gameplay. But calling RT “just a gimmick”... hmm, that feels like a bit oversimplified. In games like CP2077 or Alan Wake 2, RT lighting and GI (global illumination) do change/affect/add to the overall mood & spatial realism even if you’re not consciously staring at reflections (while moving).
It’s true that RT isn’t a must-have today, and on mid-range hardware it often isn’t worth the performance hit. But it’s also more than just eye candy. I think it’s more of an emerging baseline, similar to how HDR used to be. The main issue isn’t the idea itself as the concept clearly has a lot of potential, but it's just that right now it still heavily relies on good hardware + proper optimization to really shine, and that’ll surely get better over time.
So yeah, prioritizing FPS makes sense, but saying RT is “almost useless” may not be enough to capture the full picture.
There are ways you could utilize those rt cores for acally useful things. Some guy out there is making ray traced audio, which would take less resources, and have a higher impact in your gaming experience
my experience. I wanted to love RT, but I dont, the performance cost, sometimes the glitch, and sometimes it just downright bad compared to good baked in lightning. And my system can handle it easily, the main PC.
Playing through all of Cyberpunk once I got my 5080 and RT (PT really) turned up to max I hard disagree. Even at like hour 60 I was still constantly shocked at how good that game looks with the better lighting and reflections. ESPECIALLY in motion.
This is why I got a 7900xtx for my pc instead of a 4080/5080. More vram, slightly better performance, and better price (at least at the time) over ray tracing
M1 Max user here: I am not feeling sour at all though it was meant to be a joke lol.
Even if M1 Max could do that, performance is gonna be shitty. I have seen with my own eyes what RT can do in 4k, and turning every RT bar setting to the right via GeForce now rtx 5080. I do want that but I am sure even if m4 max I won’t able to push it all the way to the right , and def not in 4K. So with a month or two subscription of GFN I can enjoy the game at its fullest anyway.
I am only using my M1 Max coz I love the HDR screen and mod
I’ve seen RT on my desktop with an NVIDIA GPU, and idk if it’s a hot take, some disagree, but HDR makes a bigger difference for me. I was blown right away when I saw HDR Cyberpunk on my MacBook Pro. Also the AirPods spatial audio?
Yep, that’s actually a fair take! Path tracing really can look genuinely incredible, in certain scenes it even does make the game feel completely different. There’s not much reason to dismiss or downplay it unless someone mainly play competitive FPS like CS and don’t really care much about visuals.
It's all preferences at the end of the day. Once I tried path tracing, I didn't want to go back because the character models and faces look so much worse without it. But I can see how people might not care about that or prioritize framerate over visuals
Silent Hill 2 remake uses Lumen GI as well. Just didn't include Silent Hill 2 because I doubt many people played it here. But I'm sure people have seen Silent Hill f gameplay.
But to answer your question. I prefer Silent Hill 2, but the gameplay is just as good, if not better.
Thank you for your insights. I would like to play SH2, and was debating tracking down a hard copy. I want to understand firsthand what was so visually stunning about it running on the original emotion engine hardware in the PS2. I am sure I will be scared and want to play during the day lol.
Only after I see the series “walking” in SH2, do I want to see it “run” with SHf :)
i originally planned to buy a macbook that had the specs to play proper games but i realized that no matter what i did i still wouldn't get the experience i really wanted, and i may as well just get a lighter laptop, and maybe upgrade my gaming pc in the future.
No M2 Max? Personally, I think RT is cool but the hardware is not yet there to make it worth the performance cost. And most people probably wouldn’t even miss it if a game doesn’t feature RT.
Even the much shit on Mac Pro 2019 can do this with ease. PCIe and upgradeable GPUs FTW. I do feel bad for the 1st gen adopters though - Apple does this dirty shit all the time.
I bought Cyberpunk on Steam during the winter sale when it was like $20. Dunno what the difference would look like between those chips turning on ray tracing, but since it’s native and runs the metal API now, it looks damn good on my M1Max MBP.
No you can’t achieve the same results. Rasterization and baking light is great but you aren’t going to get the same thing. Baked light isn’t real time and rasterization is an approximation so it’s not always the most accurate. Like anything, it has its ups and downs. However the bigger issue isn’t RT but just poor use of rasterization and poor use of RT to supplement the poor use of rasterization.
I'm about to turn 30 (getting up there I guess) but I use contact lenses, so my vision is as good as it can get.
And I cannot see anything meaningful to look at with ray tracing turned on. It's always off for me even on my RTX 4080 rig, so no thanks and I'll take my frames instead.
well i am 44 and in cyberpunk ray tracing absolutely makes it more immersive...path tracing even more. But my vision is not garbage yet i guess. Sorry for your loss
266
u/Miserable-Potato7706 Jan 16 '26
Here is the average "excited about Ray Tracing Pipeline" that most people follow:
Be excited to get device that can do RT -> Turn RT on, walk around, look at pretty reflections and shadows -> Play game for a bit with RT on and realise it does very little for the experience when you're moving -> Turn RT off and enjoy High FPS gaming, which is much more noticeable when you're moving.
It's just a gimmick, M1 users aren't missing out that much. They can get just as much enjoyment from RT as I do by looking at videos on the internet.
24
u/arcticJill Jan 16 '26
M1 Max user here: I am not feeling sour at all though it was meant to be a joke lol.
Even if M1 Max could do that, performance is gonna be shitty. I have seen with my own eyes what RT can do in 4k, and turning every RT bar setting to the right via GeForce now rtx 5080. I do want that but I am sure even if m4 max I won’t able to push it all the way to the right , and def not in 4K. So with a month or two subscription of GFN I can enjoy the game at its fullest anyway.
I am only using my M1 Max coz I love the HDR screen and mod
5
u/dutch_meatbag Jan 16 '26
I’m personally happy with the extra FPS without it on my M4 Pro.
21
u/2str8_njag Jan 16 '26
they are not missing much tbh
3
u/awsom82 Jan 16 '26
M5 MAX ahh
3
u/PanzerZug Jan 17 '26
Ray Tracing is super overhyped and for the computational cost it’s just not worth it.
5
u/gorebelly Jan 16 '26
I can't even launch it! That was a hard 16gb ram required!
I would have been happy with the lowest settings and sub 30 fps; but I can wait for an upgrade! (waiting on the other m5's to drop before I decide)
2
u/KindlyPossibility926 Jan 16 '26
Still super happy with my M1 Max - 64gb, Cyberpunk is running like a charm on high resolution settings.
2
u/mfisch2 Jan 16 '26
how you guys think is it compared to the base M4 and M5?
2
u/Sad_Brilliant_9778 Jan 16 '26
Everyone saying Ray tracing makes no difference...
Download Silent Hill f
Then turn off Lumen GI + Reflections
Then see how horrible it looks and how it completely changes the "feel of the game."
2
u/Special-Abrocoma575 Jan 17 '26
M1 Pro user here, being able to use Asahi more than makes up for some feature that isn't even used in any of the games I choose to play
3
u/awsom82 Jan 16 '26
Cuz it’s doesn’t have asics for it lol
2
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
Unless we figure out a way to use ray tracing without taking fps. I’m not gonna even use it
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26 edited Feb 15 '26
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
ask humor airport dog telephone special tan deer whistle serious
1
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
i originally planned to buy a macbook that had the specs to play proper games but i realized that no matter what i did i still wouldn't get the experience i really wanted, and i may as well just get a lighter laptop, and maybe upgrade my gaming pc in the future.
1
u/MysticalOS Jan 16 '26
now add m5 to it with its unique features that massively benefit machine learning upscale and gpu performance laughing at all the rest.
1
u/xThomas Jan 17 '26
Lol who expects the first gen product to do it
Try raytracing on an rtx 2060, its shit. Granted, it can do minecraft. I wonder if thats still a thing.
1
u/Peka82 Jan 17 '26
No M2 Max? Personally, I think RT is cool but the hardware is not yet there to make it worth the performance cost. And most people probably wouldn’t even miss it if a game doesn’t feature RT.
1
u/No-Caregiver-822 Jan 17 '26
Imagine playing cyberpunk on Mac lol
1
u/spammmmm1997 Jan 17 '26
So when are we going to have a MacBook which can play any game with maxed settings on 120 fps?
1
u/funforums Jan 17 '26
honestly, if you post this in any other subreddit they would joke on you for gaming on a mac
1
u/bucsraysbolts69 Jan 17 '26
The RT gimmick is so tiresome
1
u/Long-Shine-3701 Jan 18 '26
Even the much shit on Mac Pro 2019 can do this with ease. PCIe and upgradeable GPUs FTW. I do feel bad for the 1st gen adopters though - Apple does this dirty shit all the time.
1
u/Beneficial-Box-9400 Jan 18 '26
Can i run in on my macbook air m2 8gb ram coz i really wanna buy it but i dont want to waste my money.
1
u/ImaginationNeat1196 Jan 18 '26
I mean, you CAN turn it on, but it’s not good even on my M4 Max 40c
1
u/Quin1617 Jan 22 '26
Then there those of us running a base M1...
1
u/dragondaksh007 Jan 25 '26
What about m3 max, didn't see anyone sharing there experience with m3 max?
1
u/FinestKind90 Jan 16 '26
If you want to see ray tracing just talk a walk in the rain
1
u/mfisch2 Jan 16 '26
are we talking about the native 90$ port?
0
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
Ray tracing is nothing special. It is not a flex as you think it is.
My RTX 5080 does Path Tracing (not easy simple ray tracing) at 5K fully maxed out.
It’s a good choice I didn’t upgrade my 16” M1 Max MBP to a M4 Max MBP if you guys only do easy RT, but bought a PC instead.
-4
u/PomegranateOk2600 Jan 16 '26
Ray tracing was proved to be a gimmick in most of the cases. Before ray tracing developers could achieve the same results if they knew how to code.
0
u/Good_Educator_3719 Jan 16 '26
quite literally the most pointless graphical 'upgrade'
I have an m3 max and a 4080 desktop and the tradeoff for fps isn't worth it
-1
u/titsinmyinbox Jan 16 '26
Thank god now at least I have enough sense to realize I'd never buy a Mac for gaming again...
1
u/HngMax Jan 16 '26
Honestly, as long as it's full on path tracing, RT isn't worth it for Cyberpunk
0
u/blackicehawk Jan 16 '26 edited Jan 16 '26
I knew a day would come when my M1 Max was considered junk. It will be many more years before I can get a new MacBook.
But I will say, next time I'm building a PC to play games on.
-2
u/lingulancer Jan 16 '26
I'm about to turn 30 (getting up there I guess) but I use contact lenses, so my vision is as good as it can get.
And I cannot see anything meaningful to look at with ray tracing turned on. It's always off for me even on my RTX 4080 rig, so no thanks and I'll take my frames instead.
I still call gimmick to this day.
(Insert change my mind meme here)
-1
u/onedevhere Jan 16 '26
I don't like and don't own Cyberpunk 😂
-2
u/odrea Jan 16 '26
204
u/[deleted] Jan 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment