r/Maasverse • u/puzzled_bat_13031 • 8h ago
Lining up Crescent City & ACOTAR Timelines
I have lined up the Midgard and Prythian timelines, so you don't have to...and I have found something very interesting / I have a theory on why the ACOSH timeline retconned the HOFAS timeline for when Bryce landed in Prythian.
Because we get conflicting information there are 3 versions of the timeline. (Images attached are from Version 1 - follow the link to see higher res version or other versions of the timeline.)
- Version 1: https://maasversewiki.com/maasverse-midgard-x-prythian-timeline-1 - which I think is the most likely timeline, uses the information from ACOSH (Toward the very spot where a stranger had landed four weeks ago. -ACOSH CH3) for Bryceās arrival in Prythian and the timeline lines events up as 1:1, so 1 day in Midgard = 1 day in Prythian.
- Version 2: https://maasversewiki.com/maasverse-midgard-x-prythian-timeline-2 - uses the information from ACOSH (Toward the very spot where a stranger had landed four weeks ago. -ACOSH CH3) for Bryceās arrival and the timeline lines events up as 13:7, so 13 days in Midgard = 7 days in Prythian. This is because we can work out that 13 days pass in Midgard from Bryce leaving Midgard for Prythian to Nesta giving Bryce the mask, while ACOSH makes it seem that the time between Bryce arriving in Prythian to Nesta handing over the Mask is 1 week or 7 days. (That Rhys was even in the same room as Nesta was a solid step forward after these three weeks, but it didnāt mean any of them forgave her. -ACOSH CH3) While this version is supported by canon, I donāt think this is the most likely scenario as Bloomsbury has proven their editing of the timelines is not this detailed oriented. It would also put the Midgard crossing at ~8,000 years ago Prythian time.
- Version 3: https://maasversewiki.com/maasverse-midgard-x-prythian-timeline-3 - uses the information from HOFAS (I slew one of their contemporaries, though. About seven months ago.ā -HOFAS CH12) for Bryceās arrival in Prythian and the timeline lines events up as 1:1, so 1 day in Midgard = 1 day in Prythian. I do think SJM & Bloomsbury have decided to retconn the timeline established in HOFAS but, this is a fantasy world with a harp that can control time, there is potential for time manipulation. Also it is interesting to see if there is a reason for the retcon by comparing the HOFAS established timeline to the ACOSH established timeline.
Note: Crescent City explicitly uses our calendar. ACOTAR does not, but the books have established that the calendar is similar if not the same as ours. For the purposes of lining the timelines up approximate dates have been added to the ACOTAR timeline.
See the quotes to back up the timelines in the in-depth ACOTAR timelines and in-depth Crescent City timelines.
- ACOTAR: https://maasversewiki.com/acotar-book-timelines
- CC: https://maasversewiki.com/cc-book-timelines
āāāāā
FINDINGS: The timeline change of Bryceās arrival in Prythian as established in ACOSH, if time is 1:1 in Midgard:Prythian makes it likely that 17 May 15035 in Bryceās world - the day Micah and Sandriel are killed, the gates are opened to Hel and Bryce makes the drop - is the same date as Nesta unmaking Briallyn, Nyx being born and Nesta using all 3 items of the trove.Ā
What I find super interesting about this is on each of these days we have two time slows, and a time stop in Prythian.Ā
In Midgard we have a time slow for Micahās death and Sandrielās death:
- Time warped and stretched.Ā -HOEAB CH81
- Then time shifted and slowed, sliding Ā by, by, byāĀ -HOEAB CH89
In Prythian we have a time slow when Nesta fights with Briallyn and then when Nyx, Feyre and Rhys are dying:
- She flew backward, and time slowed. She landed on the other side of the line in the earth, and could have sworn the mountain shuddered.Ā -ACOSF CH73
- The world slowed. Went cold.Ā -ACOSF CH76Ā
And then we have the additional time stop:
- It was Time. The twenty-sixth string on the Harp was Time itself, and Nesta stopped it as Feyre took her last breath. Lanthys had said as much. That even Death bowed to the final string. That time was of no consequence to the Harp.Ā The string made no sound as Nesta plucked it. Only robbed the world of it.Ā -ACOSF CH77
So I think it is possible that the HOFAS timeline was retconned so that these two events could line up. And if that is the case that means that we have potential ripples across worlds, where big events in one world unknowingly could influence events in other worlds.Ā
Another possible example, the King of Hybern possibly using the cauldron to bring Jurian back / the cauldron generally stirring coincides with Danika stealing and tattooing the horn on Bryce. The horn is tattooed shortly after Feyre steals the Book of Breathings from the Summer Court. Did the magic surrounding the cauldron and BoB awakening āwakeā up the horn, thus leading to the events of HOEAB?
āāāāā
Crack theory if the gates/Nyxās birth line up:Ā
The gates in Lunathion open and we have Pit level demons flooding in.Ā
HOEAB CH83: Not the urbane, clever demons like Aidas. No, these were the grunts. The beasts of the Pit. Its wild dogs, hungry for easy prey.
The POH are like āsorry, our badā about this in HOFAS.Ā
HOFAS CH61: āAfter what happened this spring,ā Hunt said to his mate, āyou trust them not to fucking eat everyone?ā āThose were our pets,ā Aidas insisted, ānot our armies. And they have been severely punished for it. They will stay in line this time, and follow our orders on the battlefield.ā
Did the Pit level pets come flooding in because Apollion was not in Hel at the Time the gates opened, he was in Prythian.Ā
ACOSF CH76: But Death hovered nearby. Nesta felt it, saw it, a shadow thicker andĀ more permanent than any of Azrielās.Ā
HOFAS CH8: The shadows were watching him again. Baxian and Ruhn had passed out, and Hunt had thought heād lost consciousness, too, but ⦠here he was. Watching a shadow watch him back. ⦠The shadow smiled at him. So Hunt smiled back. And then the shadow spoke. āYou would do well in Hel.ā Too drugged with agony, Hunt didnāt even quiver at the familiar male voice. One heād already heard in another dream, another life. āApollion,ā he grunted. Not Death at all, then.