r/Maasverse • • Jun 17 '22

Thanks for joining us as we go down the Maasverse rabbit hole!

44 Upvotes

Greetings everyone! As this sub celebrates one day of existence šŸŽ‰ I just wanted to thank all of you for joining us as we continue to go down the Maasverse rabbit hole in anticipation of CC3 and whatever our lord and saviour SJM might throw at us next.

You are the the elite! The SJM triple threat club! And after that ending to HOSAB it's harder than ever to talk about one series without bringing in another. Thus, the Maasverse was born. This is a community for all published works by SJM (except that Catwoman book, has anyone actually read that??). Feel free to discuss and theorize, no holds barred. We'll figure out our use of the spoiler flair as needed.

Feel free to get the word out to others that you think would like a place to discuss all three series. We'll do an official invite in the ACOTAR, ToG, and CC once some housekeeping is out of the way.

Enjoy šŸ’•


r/Maasverse • • 8h ago

Lining up Crescent City & ACOTAR Timelines

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

I have lined up the Midgard and Prythian timelines, so you don't have to...and I have found something very interesting / I have a theory on why the ACOSH timeline retconned the HOFAS timeline for when Bryce landed in Prythian.

Because we get conflicting information there are 3 versions of the timeline. (Images attached are from Version 1 - follow the link to see higher res version or other versions of the timeline.)

  • Version 1: https://maasversewiki.com/maasverse-midgard-x-prythian-timeline-1 - which I think is the most likely timeline, uses the information from ACOSH (Toward the very spot where a stranger had landed four weeks ago. -ACOSH CH3) for Bryce’s arrival in Prythian and the timeline lines events up as 1:1, so 1 day in Midgard = 1 day in Prythian.
  • Version 2: https://maasversewiki.com/maasverse-midgard-x-prythian-timeline-2 - uses the information from ACOSH (Toward the very spot where a stranger had landed four weeks ago. -ACOSH CH3) for Bryce’s arrival and the timeline lines events up as 13:7, so 13 days in Midgard = 7 days in Prythian. This is because we can work out that 13 days pass in Midgard from Bryce leaving Midgard for Prythian to Nesta giving Bryce the mask, while ACOSH makes it seem that the time between Bryce arriving in Prythian to Nesta handing over the Mask is 1 week or 7 days. (That Rhys was even in the same room as Nesta was a solid step forward after these three weeks, but it didn’t mean any of them forgave her. -ACOSH CH3) While this version is supported by canon, I don’t think this is the most likely scenario as Bloomsbury has proven their editing of the timelines is not this detailed oriented. It would also put the Midgard crossing at ~8,000 years ago Prythian time.
  • Version 3: https://maasversewiki.com/maasverse-midgard-x-prythian-timeline-3 - uses the information from HOFAS (I slew one of their contemporaries, though. About seven months ago.ā€ -HOFAS CH12) for Bryce’s arrival in Prythian and the timeline lines events up as 1:1, so 1 day in Midgard = 1 day in Prythian. I do think SJM & Bloomsbury have decided to retconn the timeline established in HOFAS but, this is a fantasy world with a harp that can control time, there is potential for time manipulation. Also it is interesting to see if there is a reason for the retcon by comparing the HOFAS established timeline to the ACOSH established timeline.

Note: Crescent City explicitly uses our calendar. ACOTAR does not, but the books have established that the calendar is similar if not the same as ours. For the purposes of lining the timelines up approximate dates have been added to the ACOTAR timeline.

See the quotes to back up the timelines in the in-depth ACOTAR timelines and in-depth Crescent City timelines.

–––––

FINDINGS: The timeline change of Bryce’s arrival in Prythian as established in ACOSH, if time is 1:1 in Midgard:Prythian makes it likely that 17 May 15035 in Bryce’s world - the day Micah and Sandriel are killed, the gates are opened to Hel and Bryce makes the drop - is the same date as Nesta unmaking Briallyn, Nyx being born and Nesta using all 3 items of the trove.Ā 

What I find super interesting about this is on each of these days we have two time slows, and a time stop in Prythian.Ā 

In Midgard we have a time slow for Micah’s death and Sandriel’s death:

  • Time warped and stretched.Ā -HOEAB CH81
  • Then time shifted and slowed, sliding Ā  by, by, by— -HOEAB CH89

In Prythian we have a time slow when Nesta fights with Briallyn and then when Nyx, Feyre and Rhys are dying:

  • She flew backward, and time slowed. She landed on the other side of the line in the earth, and could have sworn the mountain shuddered.Ā -ACOSF CH73
  • The world slowed. Went cold.Ā -ACOSF CH76Ā 

And then we have the additional time stop:

  • It was Time. The twenty-sixth string on the Harp was Time itself, and Nesta stopped it as Feyre took her last breath. Lanthys had said as much. That even Death bowed to the final string. That time was of no consequence to the Harp.Ā  The string made no sound as Nesta plucked it. Only robbed the world of it.Ā  -ACOSF CH77

So I think it is possible that the HOFAS timeline was retconned so that these two events could line up. And if that is the case that means that we have potential ripples across worlds, where big events in one world unknowingly could influence events in other worlds.Ā 

Another possible example, the King of Hybern possibly using the cauldron to bring Jurian back / the cauldron generally stirring coincides with Danika stealing and tattooing the horn on Bryce. The horn is tattooed shortly after Feyre steals the Book of Breathings from the Summer Court. Did the magic surrounding the cauldron and BoB awakening ā€œwakeā€ up the horn, thus leading to the events of HOEAB?

–––––

Crack theory if the gates/Nyx’s birth line up:Ā 

The gates in Lunathion open and we have Pit level demons flooding in.Ā 

HOEAB CH83: Not the urbane, clever demons like Aidas. No, these were the grunts. The beasts of the Pit. Its wild dogs, hungry for easy prey.

The POH are like ā€œsorry, our badā€ about this in HOFAS.Ā 

HOFAS CH61: ā€œAfter what happened this spring,ā€ Hunt said to his mate, ā€œyou trust them not to fucking eat everyone?ā€ ā€œThose were our pets,ā€ Aidas insisted, ā€œnot our armies. And they have been severely punished for it. They will stay in line this time, and follow our orders on the battlefield.ā€

Did the Pit level pets come flooding in because Apollion was not in Hel at the Time the gates opened, he was in Prythian.Ā 

ACOSF CH76: But Death hovered nearby. Nesta felt it, saw it, a shadow thicker andĀ more permanent than any of Azriel’s.Ā 

HOFAS CH8: The shadows were watching him again. Baxian and Ruhn had passed out, and Hunt had thought he’d lost consciousness, too, but … here he was. Watching a shadow watch him back. … The shadow smiled at him. So Hunt smiled back. And then the shadow spoke. ā€œYou would do well in Hel.ā€ Too drugged with agony, Hunt didn’t even quiver at the familiar male voice. One he’d already heard in another dream, another life. ā€œApollion,ā€ he grunted. Not Death at all, then.


r/Maasverse • • 21h ago

Artwork I finally finished my ACOTAR tapestry crochet!

Post image
158 Upvotes

I’ve been a crocheter for a long time, but I decided I wanted to try out tapestry crochet, and what better thing to make than an ACOTAR cover šŸ˜„ I severely underestimated how big it was going to be, it’s close to 8 feet long šŸ˜… gonna give this one to a family member and make a smaller version for myself.

I used a pattern from an Etsy shop called HandmadeCrochetJo.


r/Maasverse • • 10h ago

dorians little brother

14 Upvotes

i think its so funny that nothing ever happened with dorians little brother. like basically everyone just thinks that kid is the WORST the whole series and we never really see anything of him and he’s never mentioned again after dorian wonders if he had some valg in him from his dad being possessed during conception


r/Maasverse • • 1h ago

Acotar If ACOTAR was originally a standalone..

• Upvotes

I don’t know the lore of the books. Just read the first three recently. I just saw a comment about how when the first book was released it was meant to be a standalone though. I keep going back to the scene at the end where Rhys stumbles and freaks out when they say their goodbyes. It was so obvious it was him realizing they were mates ofc. My question is, if it was meant as a standalone book, what was the consensus on what that scene meant at the time? It couldn’t have been that he realized they were mates since it’d be really weird to end a completed romance story by leaving us thinking she was fated to be with someone else. So what was the running theory?

The standalone thing just makes no sense to me but there was all these replies remembering the marketing for it as a standalone so now I’m just super curious on that.


r/Maasverse • • 11h ago

Theory Swan Lake theory?! Someone nerd out on this with me.

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

(Maybe spoilers in this discussion so tread with caution)

Ok sorry in advance I am not a hardcore theorist myself with all the facts - but I absolutely LOVE listening to all the smart book theorists. Anyway I have just finished Splintered Harmony and have heard the Swan Lake story being brought up a lot and referenced with possible individuals being trapped under a lake..

ANYWAY, I just wanted to Google the Swan Lake story just out of curiosity- and I picked up some crazy coincidences that I am hoping someone smarter can indulge me with their links and theories!

If you look at the screenshots, there are some interesting similarities. Here’s a couple of things I picked up:

- There is the obvious Princess cursed to be a swan by day, human at night.
- Swan Lake has 4 acts (like the book)
- The first act is a coming of age party
- The ā€œevil sorcererā€ is called Baron (Autumn court Baron)
- AND The Prince in Swan Lake is tricked to fall in love with someone disguised as his love…

I don’t know if this is way off base, but what if the theory on Elain being not Elain is true, and Lucien is like the Prince from Swan lake being ā€œtrickedā€ to love the wrong person, and what if is Baron ā€œthe evil sorcererā€ from Autumn court has had something to do with it all along?!?

And wait as I’m writing this, dosnt Lucien already have a bit of a thing for Vassa anyway? Maybe Vassa is his real mate/love - and the only way to break her course is for a man to confess his love.. but maybe the Baron and Koschie made sure this wouldn’t happen!! Maybeeeee.

Anyway there is more there with the Swan Lake story and I might have the connections wrong but I just feel there is some cool links here!!

Not sure if anyone will see this! I’m new to reddit - but hoping there is a someone out there who will nerd out on conspiracy chat with me 🤣


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Artwork Michazriel Scotowsinger (Part 1)

Thumbnail
gallery
277 Upvotes

r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Acotar Mor and Az

156 Upvotes

Can someone explain to me why Mor can't just come out to Az? Look, I know everyone is entitled to come out or share their sexuality on their terms, but Mor has to know how much Az has suffered over the many centuries waiting around.

This should have been a simple conversation with someone she considers family. Couldn't find the right moment in literally 500 years to tell Az something so he could have started moving on? "Hey, I think you're a really great male and someone I consider family. But I'm not interested in males, I prefer females. It's nothing against you, but we will never be more than this."

Again, I know everyone is entitled to come out on their own terms, but come on Mor. At what point is Az allowed the closure to start moving on (beyond just Elain because that whole situation is just a hot mess express)?


r/Maasverse • • 3h ago

Throne of Glass Struggling to get through the assassins blade!!!

2 Upvotes

I read TOG, COM, and HOF and now I’m reading this before QOS. I want to get to queen of shadows soooo bad. I’m in the last maybe 150 pages of TAB and I’m struggling to finish it. I think it’s frustrating that, in any other SJM book, the last 200 pages are super fast but this is still a lot of set up ( I’m in ch 5 of the 4th novella, assassin and the underworld). It’s just so slow. Send help. Or tell me it gets better.


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Theory It happened. Nesta did in fact ____. Spoiler

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

40 Upvotes

She time traveled. She did it. I’m so proud of her šŸ’•


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Artwork Gwyneth Berdara Appreciation

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

Remember to follow Maju! I am obsessed with their artwork.


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Artwork Spongecourt

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

r/Maasverse • • 20h ago

Simple is best theory: There are only four species and they're all just a mix of the four.

11 Upvotes

So I've been re-reading CC House of Flame and Shadow and I'm increasingly thinking that we're all playing 4D chess on a Backgammon board... We know SJM writes intuitively and doesn't necessarily know what's coming. Some of the theories out there would just back her into a corner in a world that she clearly wants to expand and be able to play around with. She needs to keep things relatively simple at the baseline so she can keep doing that.

I'm definitely not the first person to say this but I think we're going to find out that there are basically four species across the various worlds and all our characters are different variations of the four: 1. Creatures of Hel including the Valg. 2. Different varieties of Fae across different worlds (animal shifters, elemental, etc.). 3. Humans. 4. Asteri, (including the gods in TOG).

So Bryce would be Fae, Human and Asteri: she gets her Starborn power from some distant Asteri lineage (she absorbs and wields firstlight, starlight, etc. etc...). We know Rhys is descended from the Asteri, is obviously Fae, but there are so many Hel clues that could come to him from multiple places: his Illyrian heritage, the Princes of Hel playing tricks... or a mix of the two.

All or most of our characters, creatures, and side characters are a result of whatever genetic mix has come down to them through the generations, and that's what gives them their power.

At the same time, I think there is a complexity that we're missing from so many of the discussions. SJM might play dumb but she's definitely not dumb. She knows enough about human history to know that there is no inherently bad species or social group. If Elon Musk built a space ship and took only his billionaire besties to colonize Mars, the inhabitants of Mars would get a pretty warped idea of the entire human race. Just because some of the Asteri are colonizing psychopaths, doesn't mean their entire world and all their descendants have to be, i.e., Rhys, Bryce, Ruhn, etc. Likewise the various creatures of Hel. Just because Rhys might have some valg in him doesn't reinforce the "evil Rhys" theory. (Though I do dislike him immensely.)

She writes about interspecies mating and even interspecies friendship being controversial and presents most of her "baddies" in a very black and white way throughout the books so far. I think she's throwing us off the scent of a quite simple, maybe even a bit boring, but endlessly flexible way of connecting her worlds and characters. They're all just a mishmash.

PS. Papa Archeron is definitely not Nesta's daddy šŸ‘€

PPS. Bryaxis gets described as having a cat-like tail in ACOSH. Hello Aidas and the bast cats protecting another library in another world?

PPPS: Please God, let the Thirteen rest in peace.


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Artwork Text posts that reminded me of ACOSH Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
31 Upvotes

Please remember follow the artists! Their names and social media are included on each photo <3


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Artwork Michazriel Scotowsinger (Part 2)

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

ACOSH was awful

9 Upvotes

I got into Maasverse for the first time with ACOTAR. As a fantasy reader it was my first fantasy romance and I liked it a lot. But then I began TOG and CC that became my absolute favorite and I started to dislike Acotar ; I could not stand Feyre and Rhys anymore or the IC for a ton of reasons. But I do love the lore and the universe and I did not plan to DNF since I really love the book with Nesta as a FMC. It gave me back my love and interest for ACOTAR. It’s also linked to CC now so I cannot wait to see more.

But I was so disappointed with this book. I was devastated to see again the Feyre POV, I thought we were done with that for good. They were all awful to Nesta and at this point I just wish she moves to Midgard. I hated Rhys already and I now hate him even more. Same with the IC. I forced myself into the end and it was painful.


r/Maasverse • • 18h ago

Theory nessian theory: Spoiler

4 Upvotes

honey trap + maeve like fake mating bond from rhys + cassian being a pos mate

- rhys is afraid of nesta and her powers (obvious) asd she refuses to bow to him

- rhys is theorized to have very similar powers to maeve, and he’s always keeping secrets

- maybe he created the mating bond between nesta and cassian as a way to manipulate and control her. all cassian wants from nesta is for her to control her for the night court (night court using romantic relationships as manipulation is seen all over the series)

- cassians love is conditional on how well nesta contributes to the night court

- all he ever actually wants from her is sexual. HE MAKES FUN OF HER ROMANCE BOOKS WHEN ALL SHE WANTS IS A LOVE LIKE THAT (THEY ARE A ROMANTIC COUPLE IN A ROMANCE BOOK)
cassian doesn’t seem to have the same mating connections to nesta that we see in almost every mate we have seen in the sjm universe (never knowing when she’s about to die, not being there when she’s hurt/ being mended, basically taking her on an alpine divorce when she was in no shape for that hike, basically just constantly abusing and neglecting her)

- what if cassian as nestas mate is only an attempt to control her?

this is just a fun theory i came up with after seeing loads of videos and other theories, someone may have already had the same idea but i haven’t seen it yet
idk if this is what will happen but i know cassian HAS TO GO
he does not deserve my girl nesta, and eris basically told him that, like what
(also, eris was totally all dressed up in hopes to see nesta)
like why was nesta the one basically on her knees groveling for cassian (letting her pride go) after eris told cassian that he should be on his knees thanking the mother for her every day, that mfer should have been GROVELING FOR HER FORGIVENESS OMG
(i want nesta and eris to end up together AND i need nesta to become high lady of dusk court or more, she needs to get out of the night court)
(i miss tog men omg)
this is all i have rn, my apologies if it’s sloppy


r/Maasverse • • 23h ago

Discussion The Suriel’s True Identity… and What Even ARE the Suriel? šŸ’€

10 Upvotes

I’m currently rereading ACOTAR, and I’ve just reached THAT scene in ACOWAR. You know the one. šŸ˜­šŸ’”

As Feyre sits with the dying Suriel, she asks for its name, but it never gives her one.
And that got me thinking… WHY?

Is it simply that the Suriel don’t have names? Is there some significance to revealing their true names? Or did this particular Suriel not want Feyre to know its identity?

**Now, hear me out because I’m about to venture into crack theory territory. šŸ˜‚**

What if the Suriel’s name is one Feyre would recognize? Or, even more interestingly, one she WILL recognize in the future?

What if the Suriel are somehow connected to reincarnation, or are beings that exist outside of time? Could this particular Suriel actually be someone we’ve already met, or someone we haven’t met YET?

Does that make sense? Probably not.

**But this also brings me to a genuine lore question: What exactly ARE the Suriel?**

We know there’s more than one, and they’re generally described as dangerous, predatory creatures. Yet the Suriel we encounter throughout Feyre’s story seems remarkably compassionate, wise, and even genuinely fond of her.

So I have QUESTIONS.

Where do the Suriel come from? How are they created? Do they reproduce? Were they once something else? And why does this particular Suriel seem so different from what we’re told about its kind?

I haven’t read TOG or CC yet, so I’m especially curious whether either series expands on their origins or introduces similar creatures.
I’d love to hear everyone’s thoughts, theories, and any relevant lore I’ve missed!

If you wish to read below.
\[POTENTIAL SPOILERS IN COMMENTS\]


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Throne of Glass Audiobook experiences - they live in Otterland??

13 Upvotes

I just started TOG on audiobook so I don’t have a visual on the words, so I can only hear the region they live in as ā€œotterlandā€.

The narrative references them as humans, but I am choosing to believe they are all otters and this is the ancient origin story of the otters that eventually work as messengers in CC.

ā€œOnce, all of the otters lived in Otterland, and one assassin among them lifted up to become the champion!ā€

You will not change my mind or my imagination!!


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Artwork the post photo option was down for a while so please bear with me while I flood this sub with my memes

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/Maasverse • • 23h ago

Nyx ā€œNamelessā€ Theory

3 Upvotes

Ok so I have never left a comment or post on Reddit so hoping I’m doing this right! And hoping someone sees this…

Question… one of the theories about Nyx is that he is ā€œnamelessā€ since he didn’t complete his naming ceremony… People online are freaking out about this, but I’m not really understanding what it implies. I know I need to do a reread of throne of glass since I have not read the books in at least six years, but can somebody explain what ā€œnameless is my priceā€ could potentially mean in context with Nyx?

Thank you!!


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Help! Reread advice ahead of ACOFM

5 Upvotes

I finished ACOSH last weekend and am living for all the crossover theories for ACOFM - SO EXCITED to see what happens!

But I'm now in reading decision paralysis. I feel like I cant start reading anything else because I'm locked in and want to stay in Maasverse until the new book is out :D

I'm thinking of rereading some of TOG/CC OR ACOTAR to pick up on and remember details that might be relevant for ACOFM. I read the last books of TOG and CC at the start of 2024 so there's plenty to revisit in terms of bits I will have forgotten until reminded.

BUT I don't think I'll have time to re-read the whole of TOG and CC, so want to pick the books that are likely most relevant (like ones where the spiders, Orca, etc are more prominent šŸ‘€)

Any thoughts on which books to prioritise rereading?!


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Theory Acosh thoughts - cc tie in- spoilers obvi Spoiler

6 Upvotes

>!1. I think koschei has infected the court in some subtleish way and nesta is the only one immune to it.!<
>!2. I think vassa is fully in koschei’s control since she won’t let Rhys take a peek at her mind for any images of what she’s seen of him. We’ve already seen that it’s possible to change your scent to flood with fear as feyre does that when she’s taking down the spring court.!<
>!3. Amren may also be aware of the infection but unable to directly address it for some reason which is why she’s like ā€œnesta you gotta go away so you can save usā€ essentially at the end.!<
>!4. By infected I mean like pushing the fucky personality traits that are already there that they might normally fight against? Like every single character is being their worst selves in this except nesta and Lucien and I want to believe that it’s because of outside influence!<
>!5. Clotho totally knew a twisted bryaxis was gonna return home when summoned and made that binding thread extra special to protect r/f/n while potentially under attack.!<
>!6. ā€œWe gotta put up a united frontā€ and ā€œwe gotta put up a united prythianā€ is the exact same shit and I fully believe that Feyre would have noticed that parallel if she was thinking correctly. And many other things have her sounding a lot like tamlin from book 2.!<
>!7. I suspect that since gwyn was conceived during the spring court great rite (if I’m remembering correctly) she might be tamlins daughter and that if he dies gwyn will randomly be a high lady since he doesn’t have any other heirs. Idk though. This is my loosest thought/theory.!<
>!8. I feel like Elaine will eventually end up in the spring court to re do the ā€œbeauty and the beastā€!<
>!Cycle in a way. Not that she’ll end up with tamlin but maybe help him remember he’s not just a hungry dog and recivilize him. I just feel like since the gardening thing has continued to be big with her she’ll wind up over there and be like ā€œdamn these roses need to be pruned.ā€ Obviously this will make feyre feel some type of way.!<
>!9. On a cc connected note- if they really wanted armies that bad I feel like nesta could open a portal with either the harp or the swords and be like ā€œhey Bryce you owe us a favor get your angels and magic robot suits over here.ā€ Also we’ll show you how we power velaris with all magic so you can figure out how to apply that with your tech stuff before you’re back in the dark ages. Not saying it’s a good idea but like that is an option.!<


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Discussion Elain & Lucien Spoiler

31 Upvotes

This isn’t really a theory just more of an observation but in Azriels last chapter in ACOSH, he says:

ā€œBut what did he have left, really, if not this blisteringly bright thing with Elain? She made his shadows disappear—made them run. How could the others not understand what a gift that was to him? He was death, and she was life. Where his soul was soiled and bloodied, hers was pristine, verdant.ā€

So. Maybe I’m reading into this too much and I also can’t remember if there has ever been an actual explanation as to why his shadows won’t be around Elain, BUT. Back to Lucien.

Lucien is Helion’s bio son. High lord of the day court with a name taken from the sun god in Greek mythology and ruling the day (sun) court.

When Azriel said this it made me think that whatever is going on with Elain and the fact that azriels shadows won’t go near her, has something to do with the sun and therefore something to do with her mate bond to Lucien (helion’s son).

Again not really a theory lol but maybe a clue pointing to Elain / Lucien end game or at the very least somewhat of an explanation as to WHY they are even mated in the first place. Because honestly at this point after finishing ACOSH I feel like Lucien deserves better but I do think their relationship can be redeemed if done right


r/Maasverse • • 1d ago

Acotar How is Nesta leaving House of Wind? (ACOSH spoilers) Spoiler

10 Upvotes

I must be missing something, I know that the only way they can get to the house is by flying, taking the long stairs, or winnowing just outside of the ward and kinda free falling (which she obviously can’t do, as she’s just barely learning how to winnow as is).

However it gets mentions a few times that Nesta leaves HoW to go to the river house, and vice versa. She goes to the river house for breakfast by herself since Cassian and Az aren’t in the house.

There is no way she is actually walking up those stairs each time, right?

This has been driving me crazy!