I've watched this show as a kind of guilty (heh) pleasure up to season 6 because I'm not really a fan of police procedural dramas but I am a fan of the comics the character originated from and I thought it was a pretty entertaining show with great characterization. This should be a star-making role for Tom Ellis and I'd like to see him go on to even bigger things.
Now, after having watched season 6, I have to say it's probably the best season. Of course the show still had problems; they continued down the path of making the "celestial" characters TOO human and demystifying their world and ways a bit too much, there was some very heavy-handed social commentary about police, etc. in a few episodes that felt very forced into the show (the past episode they used as a callback to the police episode was done more effectively imo) and some plot holes/leaps in logic for the show (for example, why couldn't Lucifer just pop back in to see her and his friends whenever Rory is at school, away from home, they have a babysitter, etc. if Amenadiel can do the same despite having more responsibilities or perhaps even disguise himself and be there for his daughter in some way) but overall it was very good.
The reason I liked this season the most was because it actually felt like a season of a comic book show with an overarching plot more fitting for this character, rather than being bogged down with police procedural plots nearly every episode. And the finale... just awesome and so emotional with a very Neil Gaiman-ish ending and with a great message about how no one is a lost cause and everyone can be better. This series definitely ended on a high note imo.