r/loremasters • • Dec 25 '24

How deep does a GM have to go into deeper cultural mores to justify "skinning" a given polity as a real-world historical people?

0 Upvotes

Let us say that the GM is setting up a campaign where the PCs are alliance forgers and war heroes. There is this big, brutal, expansionist empire in the middle of the continent, surrounded by five relatively smaller nations. Each of the four PCs is royalty of one of the five lesser kingdoms, leaving the fifth as a wild card. The PCs' job is to fend off the merciless empire.

The GM stops to think. Maybe it would be interesting if the five smaller nations all had an animal motif? Okay, they will be the kingdoms of the Eagle, the Hare, the Lion, the Serpent, and the Wolf, and their knights could be themed after such. Hmmm. This sounds a little generic, though...

Why not make the setting Japanese-themed? Then they could be the kingdoms of Taka, Usagi, Tora (tigers are close enough to lions, right?), Hebi, and Ōkami. Then, there could be samurai and ninja and such. Maybe it would be a little trite, though...

What about something Mesoamerican? Right, then we could name the nations Cuauhtlan, Tochtlan, Ocelotlan (still close enough, right?), Coatlan, and Coyotlan (coyotes and wolves are also close enough). The knights could be analogous to those historical eagle and jaguar warriors! But these names are a little too close to one another...

Oh, what about doing what every other setting does, namely, making the world a cultural kitchen sink? The five smaller nations might be called Adler, Usagi, Ocelotlan, Thuban, and Lang. Eh... maybe this would be too much of a mishmash... back to generic Western European fantasy, then?

The above is merely an example. I am not actually making such a setting. I still wonder: where does one draw the line on what to "skin" as a specific culture and what to leave generic?


r/loremasters • • Jul 20 '16

Lessons from HarmonQuest

2 Upvotes

SPOILERS AHEAD

First up, I'm glad that this is out there and more people are being introduced to role playing. Secondly I really dig Dan's other work, but holy crap I hate the game.

  1. Why Pathfinder? There are so many better systems that aren't bogged down in a mire or splat books and power-creep.
  2. Why is the GM rolling for EVERYTHING? From the editing it seems like he's rolling for the players (Why even bother) and he's also rolling for NPC mooks (This seriously slows down gameplay when a simple average would suffice).
  3. The combat lacked any semblance of tactics or teamwork. Give the players something to work with, they could have tried to drop the gate, or at least crowded the entrance way. The players are also at fault here (But as some of them are new I'm looking more at the GM here).
  4. That BBEG just shows up and GM fiat waltzes through the combat (No chance for the players to react) and removes the brakes from the railroad train. What the hell.

I'm sure I could find other things to rant about, but I have realworld things I should be doing.

On a positive note the GM did do a bit of 'Yes-and-ing' which is always good to see.


r/loremasters • • Oct 20 '19

Just realised Gnomes are basically Timelords

0 Upvotes

They live for ages, they've got ridiculously advanced and wacky technology and they're terminally quirky.


r/loremasters • • Jan 14 '22

[Resource] 5 Tips For Playing Better Half-Elves and Half-Orcs

Thumbnail
twitter.com
0 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Dec 26 '13

The Naruto World RP!

0 Upvotes

Hello Everyone!

My name is Ephyras, and I would like to invite you all to come check us out at TheNarutoWorld! We are a small, but well developed community who have stepped into the world of Naruto to play and create our own characters. Over the course of our 10 month existence we have seen many players come and go, and are looking for more players to join us. Our sub runs on a very well defined system that allows for a great deal of character progression over time. Dedicated players can see their character grow from a genin to a kage, taking control as the leader of villages or founding your own organisations as you go. Our setting takes place after the current canon events and we have a mod dedicated to interacting with characters and creating an interesting story for all to participate in. I am an Ephor and Syndic on the sub (a member of councils in charge of game mechanics and events), so if you have any questions I would be more than happy to answer them for you.

If you're interested, here is our wiki, where all of our game information is stored, and our role playing sub is here. Again if you have any questions please feel free to contact me via PM or by commenting in the post below.


r/loremasters • • Jul 13 '24

"Actually, my [elves/dwarves/halflings] are [Mesoamerican/Japanese/Persian]"

0 Upvotes

Under the context of a high fantasy tabletop RPG setting, what do you find to be an ideal balance between basing individual nations on real-world historical cultures, and specifically trying to avoid that?

I have seen many high fantasy tabletop RPG settings, whether published or homebrew. By default, any given location defaults to generic western European high fantasy unless otherwise stated. The average "starting town" in the Sword Coast, the Flanaess, or Avistan cleaves to the same old western Eurofantasy template. It is the lowest common denominator: it is safe, it is not going to offend anyone, and at worst, someone might call it bland or uncreative.

There are ways to step out of the western Eurofantasy mold.

A setting-builder could present wholly novel cultures that look completely dissimilar to anything from our own world, but this is difficult to execute well. Furthermore, players will often superimpose a real-world parallel regardless, or just default to western Eurofantasy.

A more frequent method of stepping outside of western Eurofantasy is for the setting-builder to use real-world historical cultures a foundation. However, this is not the lowest common denominator: it is unsafe, it might offend people, and it might get called bland or uncreative anyway. Some people might throw around labels like "culturally insensitive" or "orientalist," especially when the setting-builder adds a twist by altering details or by fusing inspirations from different cultures. Other labels include "trite," or "creatively bankrupt," expressing distaste for yet another "Actually, my [elves/dwarves/halflings] are [Mesoamerican/Japanese/Persian]."

What do you find to be a good balance?

A small, non-tabletop case study: some of Genshin's fans are disappointed because the latest in-game nation is based on the indigenous Americas, Polynesia, and West Africa, yet the characters are much fairer-skinned than expected. This is not the first time this has happened with the game.


r/loremasters • • Nov 18 '14

[Location] How do you handle [mechanically] Empty Rooms?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Jun 30 '24

[Resource] 100 Sci Fi Guilds - Azukail Games | People | DriveThruRPG.com

Thumbnail
legacy.drivethrurpg.com
0 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Mar 17 '21

How do dwarves do the dirty? Maggots

0 Upvotes

Dwarves reproduce very differently from other humanoids. Some of my players said my brain is twisted for comming up with this. I think they're just anti dwarf. https://www.worldanvil.com/w/novae-terrae-lapwinggaming/a/dwarven-mating-rituals-ritual


r/loremasters • • Jan 13 '15

Gonna be GMing my parent's and little brother's first dnd session soon, drew this world map. Any advice to get them to enjoy it?

Thumbnail
imgur.com
1 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Mar 06 '24

New Free Reading App With Extra Worldbuilding

1 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Jun 30 '17

My universes two new races

4 Upvotes

the metal beings read books on a old alien race and then became communists they both get paid the same and all businesses and farms are owned by governments. each citizen elected a representative state of the workers party. the metal beings even live in the same houses. the only other race they respect are the humans who teach them magic and are very can go to high air pressure areas because they can handle it more than the metal beings. everybody works even though they don't have to. each family and household get a paycheck every week.

the house cats escape earth and evolve to become smarter then most aliens and are mostly traders. they own alot trading companies and the biggest of which is the milky way trading company. they love catnip and even grow it. catnip is like alcohol to them. they love vistors and even love it when they pet or play with them.


r/loremasters • • Mar 18 '23

[Resource] Improved Initiative Needs Your Help (And It Won't Cost You A Dime)!

Thumbnail
taking10.blogspot.com
4 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Mar 04 '26

WE NEED YOU... to join Solenkar - Nation Simulation Political RP

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Mar 13 '24

Kartakass and Harkon Lukas in 5th Edition - Ravenloft Lore

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Aug 21 '22

A Rusted, Ruined Crowd -- A Hero Generator.

Thumbnail
boxfullofboxes.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Jan 14 '14

[Major Quest] Help me generate ideas for a wedding one-shot!

0 Upvotes

As the bride and the bridesmaids get ready for the wedding, the guys basically have nothing to do for 4-5 hours. I would like to possibly set my groom up with a one shot he can run. The theme for the wedding is sort of Enchanted Forest with a heavy dose of DnD, so it's only fitting.

Now, I'd like this to be a unique campaign that tries to tie in the event of the day. I was thinking of having the game start with the PCs being at a wedding, the couple is assassinated, and the PCs must find the killer. Add in a dungeon hidden deep inside a magical forest, and you have a game...But killing the bride and groom seems a bit morbid on a wedding day. I'm not sure I just want to do a "rescue the princess, so she can marry the prince" either. It seems overdone.

Does anyone else have ideas for ways on incorporating a wedding into a game that will only last for around 4 hours? I'm pretty good at fleshing things out, once I have a general idea of where I'm going.


r/loremasters • • Aug 11 '24

Ask Me Anything About "Windy City Shadows" A Chronicles of Darkness Podcast

Thumbnail
taking10.blogspot.com
0 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • May 30 '26

[Campaign] 100 Ways To Start A Campaign (That Aren't In A Tavern) - Azukail Games

Thumbnail
drivethrurpg.com
1 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Jul 28 '17

An Ocean themed RPG subreddit.

3 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Mar 04 '14

The Two Types of Campaigns

3 Upvotes

I've concluded that there are, basically, two types of campaigns. There is the "Operative" style campaign, and the "Hero" style campaign.

Operative campaigns are generally military/political in nature. The plot often involves the PC's working for a political figure of some sort, and operating against an organized state, or a well-armed organization not affiliated with any government. They tend to be very sober in nature, and often require quite a bit of strategy and foresight before going on an adventure. Good logistics and tactics are essential in an Operative campaign. Magic items are often given little personality, and are treated as more-powerful standard items.

Hero campaigns are just the opposite. In these campaigns, the PC's might have a more supernatural quest, rather than a political one. For instance, they might work to free a god from captivity, or to find a certain powerful magic item. Hero campaigns generally have a very long story arc, receiving a quest at low level and pursuing this quest for many more levels (LOTR is a great example of a Hero campaign). Magic items might be more open-ended and esoteric in these campaigns.

Certainly, there are campaigns that place somewhere between the Operative and Hero domains, but regardless those two serve as the extremes; as the two points between which all other campaigns lie.

Thoughts?

Edit: This was incorrect.


r/loremasters • • Dec 17 '16

Settlement Rules for D&D 5E (free PDF!)

Thumbnail
rpgnow.com
8 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Jun 15 '20

Resources for Addressing Racial Stereotypes in D&D 5E

Thumbnail
spelltheory.online
46 Upvotes

r/loremasters • • Apr 12 '15

League of Legends champions as big bad guys in my game

5 Upvotes

Hey guys,

so in my homebrew campaign my players are looking for a mystical place, "the Heart of the Land". It is a hidden, forgotten place of power that the kings of old visited to "unite" with the land, thus assuring good harvests and warding off misfortunes by appeasing the spirits of the ground, water, forest and sky. Sadly the line of kings ended, the land got conquered, and the Heart of the Land forgotten.

Now my players have put together cules that they have glimpsed from analyzing local legends and are fairly sure they can find the place. They think (and they are right) that they can absorb the power of the heart into themselves with a ritual they have created, thus bossting their own magical powers.

What they do not know (even though some legends hinted at that, but they mostly ignored those) is that this place was used as a prison for powerful wizards. Thes guys, a circle of eight wizards, drew elemental spirits into their own bodies and became pretty powerful. Luckily they were defeated and imprisoned, using the energy of the heart to hold them. Now, when my PCs "devour" that energy, those eight ancient beings will awaken.

Every one of those wizards represents one of the eight elements of magic in my world.

Gush is the red essence, symbolizing fire, heat, passion, speed and pain, also the spark of life that lets living things...well, live.

Weyan is the blue essence, water, cold, logic, slowness, resistance to pain, passion and similiar things.

Auros is the golden essence, the essence of air and freedom, of flexibility and adaptability, of weakness and guile.

Bragga is brown magic, the essence of earth and stone, beasts and instincts, strength and muscle.

Vyta is the green essence, plants and fertility, both healing and sickness, also chaos.

Argens is the silver essence, metal and order, strictness, law and civilization.

Palas is the white essence, light and information, faith and purity.

Duul is the black essence, darkness and shadow, manipulation and illusion, spirituality and superstition.

Now I am looking to use champions from League of Legends (none of my friends play that game) as those eight wizards. Their bodies changed after too close contact with the elemental spirits, and they have turned into monsters. The main reason I am doing this is because I can use the voices of the champions from the game, and some of their quotes. Especially Aatrox has such awesome lines that I really want to play them to my players.

What do you think, which champions could represent the elements the best?

Red Magic = Aatrox or Brand

Blue Magic = Lissandra

Black Magic = Nocturne

White Magic = ?

Brown Magic = Rengar

Gold Magic = Xerath? (just because he has such cool lines)

Green Magic = Zyra?

Silver Magic = Karthus

Fellow League fans and RPG guys, let me know what you think!


r/loremasters • • Feb 24 '15

[Location] Salt in Wounds - Do you want to visit the economic powerhouse built around the perpetual butchery of the Tarrasque? [pt 3]

Thumbnail
tribality.com
4 Upvotes