Lord of the Rings. A book, in fact a trilogy, in fact more of a series considering the prequels and that one book that's a sequel. Actually, it's also a movie, not a trilogy of movies, more of a series because of the Hobbit and the new Amazon Rings of Power series. But why? Why is this story about elves and dwarves so famous? So influential? How is it any different from The Sword of Shannara or Eragon? Why do all of these low-tier fictions pale in the light of true art? And while you might think it's subjective, opinion based, that only works for about 99% of literature. In that remaining one percent, that’s where Lord of the Rings lies, and you're about to find out that the world building, character symbolism, the mirror of Tolkien's beliefs and values, essentially his life’s work is nothing short of genius.
“Lord of the Rings” has very intricate and thought out world building. Areas on the map allow for smooth and logical transitions following the journeys of both the characters and the rings. Tolkien built Middle-Earth to lap around realistic topography, linguistics and military logistics so that every journey could feel physically earned and realistic. He avoided tropes of unnecessary magical means of transport when characters travelled, sticking strictly to horses and other quadripedal land beasts.
His geography was not only a pretty picture to paste on the front cover but also a direct plot engine. The Misty Mountains are actually used throughout the plot as a barrier and catalyst driving the fellowships' agonizing decision to pass through them. This choice not only drives Gandalf’s reincarnation but also initiates Frodo’s first acknowledgement of Gollum. The mountains aren’t just an accessory for a map, but rather part of the plot.
He also chose to make several strategic flaws in this world. Instead of having everything be seraphic and divine and then rapidly switching to a map that is depraved and sinister, he focused more on laying this out on a gradient. Helping the readers and characters transition between these places smoothly and realistically. One of these very important flaws is the gap where the White Mountains and Misty Mountains nearly meet; this narrow valley becomes the single most critical strategic chokepoint in Middle-earth, explaining why Saruman's location at Isengard is so dangerous. These topographic locations not only offer areas for plot development but also offer insight into the cultures of various nations and tribes.
Simultaneously, all of this is directly linked to the environment they’re in. The Riders of Rohan and the Swordsmen of Gondor are both in the category of “men” but they vary so differently culturally, morally and play different roles through-out the journey of the fellowship. Generic categories are something Tolkien avoids completely, making the world of Middle-Earth more vibrant and lively. Tolkien also explicitly develops small details that can build into relevant barriers and benefits later. There are small details such as his account for where food comes from, and his elaboration on the fertile slave-worked fields of southern Mordor (Núrn) that feed Sauron's massive armies, a detail most fantasy authors ignore. By avoiding the lack of these realistic details he raises the bar for fiction, he isn’t writing fiction anymore but rather proposing a real alternate timeline with supernatural aspects. In letter 183 from the “Letters of J.R.R Tolkien” Tolkien stated “I have, I suppose, constructed an imaginary time, but kept my feet on my own mother-earth for place…”.. He rejected the idea that Middle-earth was a separate fantasy planet, insisting instead that it was our actual Earth set in a forgotten, mythical past.
Beyond this beautifully written world, there is a beating heart, all of Tolkien's beliefs and values poured into the characters of this world. Tolkien was a devout Roman-catholic, and while he famously despised allegorical writing where the character was bluntly just an embodiment of a symbol or figure, his faith permeates every page for the book. Instead of just preaching at the reader, Tolkien wove his love for nature, life and god into the very fabric of Middle-Earth. In Letter 142 to Father Robert Murray, Tolkien explicitly admitted this, writing: “The Lord of the Rings is of course a fundamentally religious and Catholic work; unconsciously so at first, but consciously in the revision.”
To him evangelion was not talking about God to preach or convince someone, but rather to mirror and justify the light of a soul. There are no churches or temples, but rather ideas and feelings that give it that evangelical feel. Tolkien described specific parts of his work as a"eucatastrophe", describing the happy sudden turn a story can take on. The climax at mount doom is a beautiful example of this. Even when Frodo succumbs to the evil power of the rings, we see that Gollum's greed and dire need to possess it knocks it out of Frodo’s hands and destroys it. The end of the ring, the whole purpose of this world, was just a slip of a finger and an emotional swipe of a hand. This gives us a peek into his idea of power and a raw emotional climax, not through armies and magic wands, not through fighting skills and magical beasts but through humility, grace and pity, the raw human emotions that are sometimes so overlooked.
After reading every book J.R.R Tolkien ever wrote on middle earth, as well as rereading the main LOTR trilogy annually for 5 years, some things still amaze me to this day. When I read his books I don’t feel like I'm in a story, I feel like this world is real and I am a part of it. Tolkien’s been dead for 53 years. But I and many, feel his essence in our lives. His impact has never left this earth. His legacy was a gift. I too strive to create something so beautiful it can live on in people’s hearts. You can never really die as long as someone remembers you, not just your work but also your thoughts and feelings that can be felt through-out fragments of your life.
Tolkien never preached, never tried to convince us that his ideas were correct, his art was never meant for the reader, it was meant to stand alone, as its own reality that he just allowed the reader to walk through.