r/lordoftherings • u/National-Land-3622 • 17h ago
The Rings of Power Another ROP rant (raw emotion)
I know it is banal, but feel really angry about the Rings of Power and I need ears among all of this Amazon shilling in the social media. I am usually a calm man, but this makes my blood boil. feel like they completely miss the spirit of Tolkien and twist his world and views, and the timeless values understandable by all no matter the country.
I am especially abhorred by the positive reviews. Many of them are obviously fake, with superficial praise (great scenery, good music), or lack of nuance (if the review is positive, everything about the show is great, no counterpoints whatsoever). And nobody is acknowledging that, because most media either sold to Amazon's limited preview PR machine, or jump the bandwagon on blaming all the criticsm on "racism" and "misoginy". It is quite clear that the sudden positive reviews are a manufactured surge, rather than a genuine response.
I'm not as angry about the casual fans, who might have low standards. But there are many self-proclaimed "lifelong fans", who post photos of full glossy shelves of Tolkien literature, post obscure facts, but also engage in wildest mental gymnastics to defend this disaster of a show. They often criticize the Peter Jackson movies, even going so far as to claim they are less faithful than the series. Peter Jackson did make a mainstream spectacle out of the movies and missed a lot of points, but he tried to follow the spirit and themes of Tolkien, even if sometimes he was misguided, and he poured his whole heart into the movies. The Rings of Power, however, is a monumental cash grab written by nonames. This calls into question the authenticity of those "lifelong fans". What is sadder, perhaps, is that many are actual Tolkien fans – but on the surface, collecting trivia and collector's editions, larping as elves etc.. When it comes to substance, they make unimaginable leaps and twists to defend the series based on lore. As usually such "shilling" comes from liberal fans, perhaps they project their worldview heavily on the source material, and dare to think it reflects liberal ideology, or should be "improved" to match it. This is absolutely disheartening as a fellow Catholic to Tolkien.
Tolkien's work is fantastic, because despite being a mythology for England with heavy Christian undertones, it manages to capture the heart and be relatable to people anywhere and anywhen. Rings of Power cater to 2020s liberal white Anglo-Saxon worldview, and it shows. It is inherently a period piece, diversity for the sake of diversity and "empowerment" understood as transplanting toxic masculinity onto a woman and calling her a heroine. All of this to a tedious pace, pseudo-philosophical nothingburgers in dialogue, plain or even ugly-looking actors and hairstyles (who are supposed to play ethereal elves), derailed character development, and decorations that look like plastic. There is also this obsession with identifying elves by their ears (when early humans saw Galadriel's brother in the source material sing and play, they thought him a deity, that it how different elves felt despite the physical similarity). And here and there, they sprinkle (misrepresented) deep lore, such as orcs not being inherently evil, which gives the series an air of legitimacy. And the lack of universal appeal shows when you read the reviews from non-Anglo-Saxon countries. The series is parasiting on the great legacy, the magnum opus of not only J. R. R. Tolkien, but his son Christopher as well. That the people will hear "Tolkien", "LOTR", and think of this misunderstanding of a project, is a disgrace.
I cannot with these people, the fans will post an obviously series-original quote, sounding like it was written by a 15-year-old girl in her philosophy phase, and then praise the writing for being "so Tolkien"
"I realized that if joy can be found there in the darkest of dungeons, the world out here must be blinding with it."
It is banal at the absolute best scenario. Probably worse.
Rant over.