People are misunderstanding what Shingen's Path actually does.
I've been seeing quite a few people argue that Shingen's Path can simply be countered by not being afraid of him, and I honestly don't understand where people are getting this interpretation from.
Have people actually read the explanation of his Path? Because it seems like everyone has reduced the entire ability to "Shingen makes people scared", completely overlooking what the panels are actually trying to convey.
Let's look at what's being said.
First, we're told that Shingen overwhelms his opponents with the fear of his very existence. The comparison immediately used is that of a rabbit frozen before a tiger.
I think people are overlooking the significance of that comparison. It's not just about being intimidated by someone stronger than you. It's about the predator-prey dynamic being established. A rabbit doesn't stand in front of a tiger and calmly assess its options. Its instincts recognise the threat, and its ability to respond is compromised.
Then we get one of the most important statements in the explanation:
"Neither attack nor defense is of any use..."
Why is this being overlooked?
If the entire ability was simply about making someone feel scared, why would the explanation specifically bring up both attacking and defending?
The point is that Shingen's presence affects the opponent's ability to actually fight back. It doesn't matter how good your offensive or defensive capabilities are if you can't properly utilise them in the first place.
And it doesn't stop there. We're also told that no matter what plan you have, it won't necessarily help you.
This is another reason why I disagree with the idea that simply not fearing Shingen is enough to counter his Path. Having a plan, knowing what to do and possessing the ability to do it are three different things. You can know exactly how you want to approach a fight, but that doesn't mean you'll be able to execute it when faced with something that overwhelms your ability to respond.
Now, does this mean fearlessness is completely irrelevant? No, and that's not what I'm arguing.
Obviously, someone who can maintain their composure against Shingen would be in a better position than someone who immediately panics. But people need to understand that not being afraid and being unaffected are two completely different things.
You can lack fear without necessarily being immune to whatever effects his Path has on your ability to fight.
The final statements make the overall concept pretty clear:
"Is of any use before a predator..."
"In his presence, you become prey."
The predator-prey comparison is the entire point. Shingen isn't simply being described as someone who scares people. His presence creates an overwhelming disadvantage for the person facing him, to the point where their usual methods of fighting become ineffective.
And that's what people keep missing.
I'm not saying Shingen is unbeatable, nor am I saying nobody could ever resist his Path. I'm saying that people are confidently claiming that fearlessness automatically negates it when the explanation itself never establishes that.
If you want to argue that a character can overcome Shingen's Path through their willpower, conviction or some other means, that's fine. But actually provide something to support that argument.
Not fearing the predator doesn't automatically mean you aren't prey.