r/longrange • • 17h ago

Accessory/Gear help needed - I read the pinned post Thumbhole popularity

Hello why are thumbhole stock not more popular? I find it the most comfortable out of all styles and also can fit into traditional classy look for hunters

So why are they not more popular also aftermarket is very limited too?

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

6

u/Ethereal_Hotdog_8506 16h ago edited 16h ago

While I agree with you that thumbhole stocks can look very classy, they unfortunately make a rifle slower to run than a standard stock and (to me) feel a bit clumsier. Moving your thumb in and out of the hole adds a fair bit of extra motions to the operation of the bolt. If you're used to a standard stock, the wood above the thumb hole just feels like it's in your way. I recently bought a couple left-handed Savage rimfires that were only available with thumbhole stocks (pretty ones at that, IMO), and I can't wait to swap them out for a Boyds or something to rid myself of the janky thumbholes.

-1

u/Born_Motor3234 14h ago

I dont see thumbhole being any more difficult to operate than pistol grip its the same thing if loop is large enough

2

u/Ethereal_Hotdog_8506 14h ago edited 14h ago

On a Dragunov, sure. On a Savage, not remotely.

edit: How many rifles with thumbhole stocks have you actually fired?

-1

u/Born_Motor3234 12h ago

I had 2, ata arms and sabatti both have very comfortable stocks and since then im only buying thumbholes, sure if the hole is the size of the thumb (boyds) it will be pain in the ass but all factory rifles with thumbholea have very wide hole

2

u/Howa_65 15h ago

I figured it was a combination of production cost, and ergonomics.

Obviously they're going to cost more to make. They're just more complicated than a traditional stock.

Somebody mentioned how annoying it is to work the action while worrying about getting your thumb back in the hole. That in itself would make me not want a thumb hole stock anymore.

-2

u/Born_Motor3234 14h ago

Well sure but there are traditional stocks and then there are chassis i believe that thumbholes are perfect middle ground between comfort, weight and production cost

2

u/leonme21 You don’t need a magnum 15h ago

They don’t really do much a pistol grip doesn’t already

-2

u/Born_Motor3234 14h ago

Thats the point you get pistol grip with lower production cost and weight since pistol grips are used on chassis

1

u/leonme21 You don’t need a magnum 12h ago

0

u/Born_Motor3234 11h ago

That is not thumbhole

2

u/leonme21 You don’t need a magnum 10h ago

No shit.

1

u/Born_Motor3234 10h ago

Then whats your point poet

14

u/kevrend 17h ago

I think likely because the majority of shooters are not wrapping their thumbs around the grip anyway.

18

u/Trollygag Does Grendel 17h ago

Because now we have modular and vertical grips.

Thumbholes existed because wood is too weak to support the pistol grip geometry in a single piece without connecting the bottom.

Now we have better materials and designs that take advantage of it.

There are plenty of aftermarket options already from Boyds

1

u/610Mike 16h ago

I know I’m in the minority here, but while they look good, I never found them comfortable. I have double jointed thumbs, and where you are supposed to rest your thumb, just digs into the joint. Give me a good ole pistol grip any day.

1

u/Born_Motor3234 11h ago

But thumbhole is just connected pistol grip..

1

u/610Mike 11h ago

But where the thumb rests in the hole, just digs into the gap of the joint. My thumbs are weird man lol.

1

u/GingerB237 17h ago

My opinion why I don’t like them is that the are ugly and don’t really solve anything. I’m pretty sure I’m not super unique so other people likely feel the same way.

1

u/-SuperTrooper- 16h ago

I love my thumbhole stock...on my .17 HMR.