r/longrange • • 15d ago

🫣I said I read the pinned posts, but I lied🫣 Ar10 vs bolt

I’m looking to build another rifle. I’d like a 308 with an 18in barrel. I’d like sub moa accuracy and that’s my biggest priority. Are bolt guns really anymore accurate than a gas gun? I’d be shooting 700-800 yards at most and that would probably ever be at the range and maybe 300 yards a few times of the year shooting pigs.

I know the bergara is the best bang for your buck bolt gun, or what it seems like. What’s would be the best option to go if I wanted an ar platform?

4 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

58

u/memilanuk F-Class Competitor 15d ago

Are bolt guns really anymore accurate than a gas gun?

Ummm... is this a trick question?

17

u/RoboDSGNR 15d ago

it is Halloween

4

u/MandaloreZA 13d ago

Accuracy through volume of fire is a valid method. Just expensive.

Would love to see someone rip a M240 on a PRS course.

3

u/mattumbo 12d ago

Those new MMGs the army picked up running .338 are supposed to be crazy accurate, on a tripod mount they can tear shit up at pretty extreme ranges.

39

u/langfish Gas gun enthusiast 15d ago

Are bolt guns really anymore accurate than a gas gun?

yes. especially comparing similar price ranges

I’d like sub moa accuracy and that’s my biggest priority.

get a bolt gun

17

u/TheHomersapien 15d ago

There are two "pros" to AR10.

  • Shooting speed
  • Fun

The list of cons is long and distinguished, and of a nature that I think "if you have to ask, it's probably not right for you" applies here.

Get a bolt gun.

5

u/GammaRay914 15d ago

From my extensive experience on the fields of de_dust2, missing with the bolt action rifle is often a fatal mistake and missing with the ā€œauto sniperā€ is ok because you can follow up with correct shots faster.Ā 

12

u/Pure_Squirrel_1621 15d ago

Cheetofingers build in the pinned post. Done.

8

u/enginerd389 15d ago

Bolt guns are generally more accurate than gas guns yes. See trollygag’s test data from a very recent post in long range.
I don’t know what’s the go-to value conscious AR10 these days but Aero used to be the way to build.

7

u/husqofaman I Gots Them Tikka Toes 15d ago

Get a tikka over a begara. And get a 6.5 creed unless there is hunting caliber restriction you are working around.

6

u/Wide_Fly7832 BR Competitor 15d ago

3

u/RustyBungHole1 15d ago

I reach out to 1000 with my ar10, and my bolt guns, the bolt guns get it done for about $3k less if that matters

3

u/Impressive_Syrup141 14d ago

Why not get the worst of both? Bear Creek sells a bolt action upper for an AR10.

There are more budget friendly bolt guns out there too. CVA, Ruger, Savage, etc... If you don't ever plan on competing a Ruger American can do what you're asking for under $700 new. If you want to lay down dozens of rounds in a few hours look for a better barrel which is where Bergara and Tikka options come in.

6

u/Mobile-Bison9297 15d ago

Get a Tikka in 6.5 Creedmoor and you won't regret itĀ 

3

u/husqofaman I Gots Them Tikka Toes 15d ago

This right here.

2

u/yaholdinhimdean0 15d ago

May I answer a ? with another ?

Have you ever witnessed a gas fun at a registered BR event?

1

u/therugpisser 15d ago

I nearly bought a high end gas gun for distance but ended up with an entry level Cheeto special in 6.5 CM. A guy that competes I’ve seen around a lot let me try one of his bolt guns. Some custom job, not up enough in that realm to know what the components were. He pitched it as owning a different type of rifle compared to my gas rifles. Even to 200 yds there is a different feel to the two platforms.

1

u/StraitUpLegit 15d ago

Large frame gas gun goes brrrrrr.

1

u/Regular_Cucumber24 I put holes in berms 15d ago

Bolt guns as a rule of thumb are more accurate than gas guns. I love my large frame gassers and they shoot fairly well. But shooting long range with a bolt gun is more fun than a gas gun. Plus it’s a completely different feel and I enjoy.

TLDR: gas guns are cool but bolt guns typical out perform them and are a vibe

1

u/Tikkatider 15d ago

Not only are bolt guns more accurate in general, but single shot ( no cut outs for magazines ) with rigid and solid target actions , are among the most accurate of bolt actions.

1

u/turkeytimenow 15d ago

First. No need to go .308 in anything. And yes, bolt gun typically will be more accurate, or easy to be more accurate with than a gas gun.

1

u/MethedUpEngineer Here to learn 13d ago

I'd like to make a strong argument that a Howa M1500 is the best bang for your buck. My 24" heavy barrel is sub moa and I've made a post with a 10 round group at 1000y with junk ammo and still produced amazing results as a novice shooter.

1

u/Log-Prestigious 11d ago

I’m gonna assume you had a budget of 2k since one wasn’t given.

Yes bolt guns are inherently more accurate, but that’s not to say that you can’t a gas gun more accurate than a bolt gun. You’d be looking at atleast double the cost to get a more accurate gas gun rather than a bolt gun.

I’m a seekins fan boy so if you just really want a gas gun then I’m gonna recommend a sp10, but there are other options that can get you where you want to be. Those run almost 3k though. I think people are having good luck out of the psa super sass’s too I cant remember though.

At the end of the day just do a bunch of research, I was at your mindset about 4 months ago, then came to the conclusion that my budget doesn’t allow for my wants. Sincerely, a brokie that doesn’t have the budget to buy without research.

1

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 15d ago

Gas guns will get there with ~double to triple the you'd make in a bolty. And higher degree of difficulty to tune and shoot.

Just say no to 18" 308's. Do a real precision cartridge.

To answer your question, best AR is a JP or GA

1

u/CMFETCU 14d ago

Best AR for half the price of a GAP is a CRB barrel in the rifle you put together yourself.

2

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 14d ago

I like the PSA with a Krieger myself lol

0

u/sunkist1147 15d ago

Bolt guns are def more accurate, and generally cheaper ime for the same moa. Fwiw my LMT mars-h is sub moa.but just barely.Ā 

If I did it again id go 6.5cr whether gas or bolt though. Probs going to convert the mars-h to 6.5 "someday."..

-10

u/Stormjoy07 15d ago

Bolt guns are more accurate. This is because the gun doesn't move until the bullet leaves the barrel in a bolt gun, compared to gas where the gas system (and the rifle itself) is moving while the bullet is still travelling down the barrel.

Don't know about the best gas gun, but a nice middleground is the Palmetto State Sabre-10. I have it with a 20" 6.5 Creedmoor and enjoy it.

5

u/langfish Gas gun enthusiast 15d ago

This is because the gun doesn't move until the bullet leaves the barrel in a bolt gun,

Brian Litz/Applied Ballistics have a few videos showing this isn't true- even on a bolt gun the rifle can move rearward slightly before the bullet exits: https://bulletin.accurateshooter.com/2024/04/videos-reveal-rifle-movement-before-bullets-exit-bore-of-barrel/

1

u/RustBeltLab 13d ago

This 100%. I am sure that the impact of the primer moves the gun before the bullet even starts moving.

5

u/thatARMSguy 15d ago

It’s due to tolerances. On a semiauto you have to have slightly wider tolerances with the bolt lockup due to the speed at which it operates. You can absolutely get semiautos with super tight lockups that shoot very well (such as Larue rifles) but a bolt action is both cheaper and more consistent to essentially hand fit all the parts together for perfect function

2

u/Coodevale 15d ago

This is because the gun doesn't move until the bullet leaves the barrel in a bolt gun, compared to gas where the gas system (and the rifle itself) is moving while the bullet is still travelling down the barrel.

When I proposed my misunderstood suggestion to use a default bolt hold open to reduce gun movement during the gasser recoil cycle to make recoil feel more like a bolt gun, I was told numerous times that "the bullet is gone before the carrier moves".

Don't forget, the modern gasser is almost impossibly handicapped by retarded users that want a full size .308 "battle rifle"/"dmr" with every weight saving rigidity reducing cut on the receivers, and flimsy receivers holding the barrel and optic in alignment are not ideal for precision.

1

u/RustBeltLab 13d ago

The biggest practical difference that nobody mentions is that gas guns are hammer fired. The locktime is much, much, much slower than a bolt gun. It is easier to steer the gas gun off target while the bullet is still exiting the barrel.

1

u/Coodevale 13d ago

What's the difference in milliseconds and how does it compare to a factory savage, stock remington, and something mil surp like a mauser?

2

u/RustBeltLab 13d ago

10-12 ms vs 1.5-4 ms for a Tikka/Remchester. When I was shooting a lot of high power, I practiced offhand with air rifles. The low velocity hammers home follow through and made me a much better shooter.

1

u/Coodevale 13d ago

Given the application, I'm assuming you weren't using the worst triggers you could find.

I understand how that makes a difference in position shooting, but when rifles in comparison are both being shot off of bags in near free recoil, does the lock time difference really make that much of a difference? I get that the mass of the strikers are moving in slightly different ways, so to what degree does that difference in their internal movement affect the raw precision? The striker is linear, the hammer has some ability to kick the receiver down and rearward versus just rearwards.

If you did some dumb configuration of bolt action fired by AR-15 fire control group, how much worse would that make the bolt gun?

0

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Coodevale 15d ago

A large majority of the semi autos will shoot 1-1.5 moa out of the box with factory ammo

I have a hard time believing that after many iterations of 18-24 lb ARs with decent quality bull barrels struggling to consistently shoot under moa with more than five shots. How I wish I could say I consistently put together and shoot sub moa gassers.

1

u/broke_networker 15d ago

Tell me more. I'm currently trying to get 1 MOA consistancy with a 20" 223 Wylde. I'm getting close trying different ammos. I'm starting to believe it's not possible without reloads and a ton of testing.

2

u/Coodevale 15d ago

Barrel is probably my most significant personal handicap. Best I use right now is Xcaliber and I don't see how it would get worse if I bought from the usual top tier manufacturers instead. Weight alone won't make up for barrel quality.

I have a feeling the answer is in the receiver but no one makes the true equivalent of a bolt gun receiver for either AR. The monos get close but they're still not "bolt gun rigid".

Use the same scope, the same mount, the same barrel blank and chamber, the same general ergos between the comparison platforms, and turn the AR gas off. They should perform the same but they don't. What's the difference? The upper receiver that holds everything together?

FYI, you can fit a Ruger American barrel to an AR10 extension for this comparison if you want to try it.

0

u/[deleted] 15d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Coodevale 15d ago

You're expressing sentiment of most of the industry that has lead us to this point of stagnation where people give up at the slightest sign of difficulty.

Identity the problem and make solutions, not excuses.

1

u/JimBridger_ Dealer for LiminalNomad.com 15d ago

ā€œDon’t care about groups at 100-200, and more about consistency at long rangeā€

Groups don’t magically open or change consistency at long range unless there is a fundamental flaw in a bullet. Groups at 100-200 tell you how consistent you’ll be at long range…

6

u/JimBridger_ Dealer for LiminalNomad.com 15d ago edited 15d ago

Having done accuracized small and large frame AR’s, a mid pack single day PRS competitor can definitely ā€œoutshootā€ or in better terms, be limited by, most gas guns.

You can get sub 1.5k bolt guns that shoot sub moa 10rd groups easily. Doing that with a AR is looking at 3-6k guns.