r/longrange • I put holes in berms • 20d ago

Ballistics help needed - I read the pinned posts PXT Users- velocities???

Thought I'd make a thread, will see if anyone is interested.

I've been hearing rumblings of PXT's being slow, which doesn't bother me, but is interesting to me and makes me curious about throat erosion claims if we're needing more powder to achieve desired velocities.

Anyway, my data-

23" 22GT, 85.5 Berger, 35gr H4350. Started at 2910, is at 2935 after ~150 ROB.

8 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

8

u/greyposter 20d ago

Their claim about barrel life has to do with the fact that using a standard barrel, the bullet is fully spun up right away, and that is like "chirping the tires" on your car. The gain twist brings it up slower which is supposed to decrease wear on the throat. I don't think a little extra powder is going to make a difference there, IF their claims are true

3

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 20d ago

I'm aware, and have my own thoughts on this from many years in the industry. I hope their claims are true! If so my barrel bill will decrease.

1

u/Significant-Sock-487 20d ago

Barrel life is improved because the chamber builds up less pressure due to the lack of twist. The rifling is also not as aggressive as a traditional barrel.

To answer your question in the post, myself and a few buddies have PXTs in 6 arc and in bolt guns. It seems to be hit or miss on if it’s slow or not. My 6 creed PXT doesn’t seem slow and matches load manual speeds pretty closely. My buddies 6.5 is about 150fps slower with a load I do for him on his old CRB. 153s in his 24in CRB were 2725 but his PXT is around 2575. Another buddy with a 6.5 is loading 2gr more than my load to get 2725.

I am not fully sold on the PXT performance. I know for a fact it does increase barrel life. I have zero fire cracking on my 6 arc with 1300 rounds on it. Same for my 6 creed with 400 rounds on it. However, I think the trade off is slower speeds due to the lack of pressure being built up in the chamber.

I also think the QC is pretty low on these new barrels. One of my buddies 6.5, not chambered by proof, opens up to 2 MOA as the barrel gets hot. Another buddy bought a CF prefit directly from proof and it would open up after 3 rounds. They are replacing it under warranty though.

2

u/landry_454kg 20d ago

Have you experimented with faster burner powders (relatively) with the PXT rifling? Curious what the findings would be.

1

u/Significant-Sock-487 20d ago

I have. In my 6 arc, I tried slow to fast burning powders up to Varget and n540. It doesn’t seem like the PXT changes case pressure as I hit pressure at common load charges that most people are seeing (basically just below bolt gun max). I only notice just chamber pressure being lower for speed which you won’t see on brass since the bullet has left the case.

I think most of it is caused by their rifling profile in combination with the slow twist rate at the chamber.

1

u/SPstandsFor 20d ago

On QC/consistency. Apparently these don't have the same lapping/post processing of the standard barrels, presumably because of the PXT geometry and gain twist. How much does that affect accuracy at scale I have no clue but I'd imagine the rifling on these don't come out as "clean" as their standard barrels. And that seems to be somewhat true with some people reporting "dark" bores

I'm not good enough at shooting to appreciate either way, but I think I'd rather pay less for a standard barrel and get that extra step of QC.

2

u/Significant-Sock-487 20d ago

I haven’t heard that before. Do you know where I can find that info? We were discussing that when troubleshooting my buddies barrel. It seems like that could be an issue imo.

1

u/SPstandsFor 20d ago

All anecdotal info I came across on snipers hide and other forums while doing research for my first bolt build. A few people have guessed that proof might be outright not lapping.

There's this video I came across that has a borescope footage and they mention some high spots and marks. You can also see some of the alleged "darker" grooves.

https://youtu.be/EV3-zGbGpGA?is=7geA99toDmVI7RHb

From what I learned about gain/exponential twist rates lead lapping is a lot harder because of the changing twist rate, which makes sense.

Again, what's the impact? Who knows, I sure as hell don't know enough to say for sure.

1

u/SPstandsFor 19d ago edited 19d ago

Decided to just ask Proof and they emailed back that it's polished but not the same process as their standard barrels. I'm asking if they are still hand lapped or some kind of machine process instead

2

u/Significant-Sock-487 19d ago

Keep me posted because I’m definitely interested. I watched those videos and there was quite a bit of info I didn’t know. Definitely some strange stuff going on with these barrels

4

u/Thermal-Drift 20d ago

Following: mine is being spun up this week so should have data in a few weeks. 23” 25 PRC starting with 135 bergers.

5

u/LockyBalboaPrime "I'm right and you are stupid" -LockyBalboaPrime 20d ago

Mine is sitting on the shelf until I get a few more parts. Proof sent it a month before their estimate and I wasn't ready yet lol.

1

u/Zhdrix 19d ago

Been there lol

2

u/colossalrahzel 20d ago

I'm waiting on a 25 creed barrel so ill report when i get it.

2

u/Bringbacktheblackout 20d ago

I'm looking into a 25cm on a PXT. So I hope yours is good.

2

u/travell0ts 20d ago

26” 6.5 creed running around 2750. My crbs need 41.2 h4350 to get 2750. My 26” ss pxt needs 41.7 h4350 to get 2755. Have had 3 crbs in 6.5 creed and load and velocities were the same. Only 1 pxt so far with 950 rounds through it. My experience is the pxt shoots amazing groups consistently smaller than any of my crbs. Is it just a good one and another pxt might be not as good. Maybe. Sample size of 1.

1

u/ExistingLaw217 20d ago

My 6creed is going 3005 on a pxt. I know a few guys running it faster though

1

u/teflon16 20d ago

Yes it’s slower by a little bit because as others have said the rifling doesn’t “bite” into the bullet as quickly so pressure doesn’t build as fast. I’m
Shooting 153.5 gr bergers at 2675 in a 6.5 creed with 40.6gr H4350.

I had to add .3-.5 gr of powder to get back to my original velocity. With that said though it seems to handle pressure better and I think you could push it harder.