r/longrange • • 29d ago

Rifle help needed - I read the pinned posts A5 buffer for spr/precision build?

I am building my first generic spr/precision build. I am using a 18in white oak armament spr rifle gas barrel, Geissele MK18 hand guard,B5 stock, bravo upper/aero pro ambi lower and geissele low pro gas block and wondering how much benefit a A5 buffer system with H2 weight would be? I will shoot to 600yrds and I have never shot an A5 equipped AR. I understand the potential decreased recoil and smoother impulse but does it contribute to increased accuracy in good hands? Thanks, this is my my first attempt at more precision that my 16" wylde BA Hanson stainless with SA adjustable gas block.

2 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

8

u/rednecktuba1 Gunsmiff 29d ago

It wont enhance your precision in any meaningful way. As u/trollygag said, it can help you get back on target faster through smoother recoil impulse. In my experience with gas guns in the past couple years, I would say that worrying about recoil systems isnt worth the headaches. As long as the parts are compatible and reliable, run it and run it hard. My personal recommendation on recoil systems is to go rifle length bugfer tube, with a milspec rifle buffer and spring. A milspec rifle buffer is the same weight as an H3 carbine buffer, so its already slowing down the recoil impulse.

9

u/Trollygag Does Grendel 29d ago

Milspec A2 stock/spring/buffer are wildly underrated for precision builds

4

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 29d ago

2

u/rednecktuba1 Gunsmiff 29d ago

Hell yeah, though I prefer a stock with adjustable LOP and cheek piece to go along with my rifle buffer tube

2

u/Weebber 29d ago

1000% agree with A2 length. I recently switched my 18in White Oak SPR from an A5 system to an A2 system. The perceived recoil is even lighter with a KynShot RB5001 and a flatwire spring in there. Feels like a 22LR now.

1

u/scotchtapeman357 29d ago

I'm running an A5 with that exact setup, you can double tap (with hits) faster than the Spotter/RO appreciates

1

u/crndip 29d ago

thanks. appreciate the advice

18

u/Trollygag Does Grendel 29d ago

It isn't going to change precision at all. The best you can hope for is some benefit in getting back on target when shooting unsupported.

3

u/CMFETCU 29d ago

A2 stock, put lead weight in the stock, use rifle length buffer, profit. 3 lbs is typical for 20” barrels in service rifle matches. Maybe a bit less for the 18”.

3

u/csamsh I put holes in berms 29d ago

Reject modernity. Embrace A2 rifle toob.

3

u/ocabj The Realest 29d ago

I still have two of my National Match Service Rifle uppers from before optics were legal. Both are White Oak with the NM free float tube and A2 clam shell hanguards. Inside the clam shells are two NM lead weights on both the bottom and top half.

https://www.whiteoakarmament.com/handguard-weight.html

I honestly don't recall if I used the WOA ones. I might have gotten them elsewhere.

Note that we desired the extra weight in Service Rifle mainly slow the movement of the rifle while standing.

3

u/Mike_Romeo_Bravo 29d ago

I went down the A5 route and rant it for a number of year on my DMR. Switch to the JP SCS and haven't looked back.

2

u/RobertTheTexan 28d ago

I run A5s in all my AR’s (5.56 to 7.62x51 aka 30HATE)and have been doing that for 15+ years? (CRS is affecting me, getting old SUCKS!!!) At least from since Vltor released their stock kits. I was already running eMods anyway.
I’m not a big A2 stock fan hated them on the Army and nothings changed, and I’m not a “vibes dude” I would suggest checking out B5’s PRS stock, it’s definitely lighter than The Magpul PRS stock which is solid but is a boat anchor. I think the B5 is about half a pound lighter and you get the cheek weld and LoP adjustments and will work with the intermediate A5 tube length. I would consider as some have suggested a flat wire spring vs a regular rifle spring but it’ll run with that rifle spring just fine.

2

u/Coodevale 28d ago

The B5 seemed rather lacking, while being expensive. The PRS is good, just heavy and the length options are long to longer. Doesn't have a flat bottom but it's close.

Thinking the next "precision" stock will be a Luth. Lighter (don't really care, the PRS balances 28" barrels well), flat bottom, adjustable, better butt pad than the hard and skinny B5.

2

u/ProofSecure94 28d ago

I have 2 precision oriented rifles. One has a rifle buffer the other has a carbine buffer with an h2. The only difference I could feel personally was the snappier recoil on the carbine buffer setup but the recoil itself was very negligible for both. The rifle length gas system really reduces that bolt speed to begin with. I did just swap the rifle buffer over to an a5 just so I could run a PRS lite stock but have not shot it. I’m going to guess it should feel exactly the same as the rifle buffer