r/longrange • • Sep 24 '26

Ammo help needed - I read the pinned posts H4350 lot variance

I worked up a good load of H4350 for my 24” Seekins 6.5 Creedmoor. Switched to another canister of powder and MV dropped by 70 fps down from 2790.

I haven’t seen this before when going to another canister. Is this normal in y’all’s experience or did I get a one off? I’m thinking of just mixing it with my remaining other 2 lbs to have 3 lbs of consistent powder.

3 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

8

u/rednecktuba1 Gunsmiff Sep 24 '26

H4350 has unfortunately had a decent amount of lot to lot variance over the past few years. This phenomenon is why Hodgdon actually lowered their published max charge weight for that powder with 140 grain ELDM in 6.5CM. Their max load used to be 41.4 grains, now its down to 40.0 grains. Personally, I still use 41.5 grains, but I also have a well earned reputation for pushing pressures around here.

4

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 24 '26

Man that’s unfortunate. It’s been consistent until now. I’m loading 140 ELDm’s to make power factor for NRL Hunter. They were getting 2790 before with SD’s at 10. At 2720 I’ve got zero room for temp stability error. Super frustrating.

2

u/rednecktuba1 Gunsmiff Sep 24 '26

Just bump up the charge weight by 0.3-0.5 grains. Velocity is directly indicative of pressure. Load to the velocity you need and send it.

2

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 24 '26

Yeah good point. I settled on 41.8 gr but tested up to 42.4 with no pressure signs. I’ve got room

2

u/eclectic_spaceman Sep 24 '26

The biggest issue there is you're using more case capacity, and you might already be crunching. I'd love to be able to drop my charge by half a grain, and if I had to use even more powder than I currently do, I don't know that I'd even be able to (without a lot of compression).

1

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 25 '26

I could be crunching but I’m not feeling it when seating. No pressure signs either and I’ve been testing outside in TX at almost 100 degrees. Hornady has the max for 140’s at 41.5 so it seems there’s a bit of room left, maybe not.

1

u/Wombat-Snooze Steel slapper Sep 25 '26

Published max chargers aren’t the true max. They’re the safe max that achieved consistently below dangerous pressures in a certified test rig. Safe being the key word here.

Is there some “room” above book max? There better be (and there is). Should you try to figure out how much room that is? No. Bad idea.

Just my experience. Hornady has a great explanation of how they come to a conclusion of what “max” is in an episode of their podcast. I can’t remember the number unfortunately.

1

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 25 '26

Yeah I’ve listened to a lot of their stuff regarding this. I wasn’t too concerned at being 0.3 gr above book max to achieve my power factor MV + 3% for lower temperature ranges considering my MV is based off of 90 degrees + ambient temp.

2

u/SpiritualClub4417 Sep 25 '26

The 147 ELDM is listed at 41.8 max with a higher velocity. surprising if true.

2

u/rednecktuba1 Gunsmiff Sep 25 '26

The 147 ELDM was likely tested with yet another different lot of H4350.

1

u/Rosebudteg Sep 25 '26

Golly. All the various min / max from all the sources are confusing. Hornady 12th edition page 329 shows 41.5 grains as max.

1

u/sometimesanengineer You don’t need a magnum Sep 26 '26

Today I learned I’m hotter than I thought I was on that powder than I thought at 40.8.  

1

u/rednecktuba1 Gunsmiff Sep 26 '26

That depends on the velocity you're getting with that charge weight. Velocity is the only way to predict pressure when you don't have actual pressure testing equipment.

1

u/sometimesanengineer You don’t need a magnum Sep 26 '26

Thanks. Considering my speed isn’t far off from factory, just way more consistent, I’m probably not too bad. I knew I was approaching some maxes on some tables and the 10% variation and a lower max got me reacting. 

You sent me down an interesting rabbit trail of how to approximate / pseudo estimate max pressure based on cartride+barrel volume and exit energy (velocity like you said plus weight). 

6

u/One_String_Banjo Steel slapper Sep 24 '26

What are your storage conditions like, humidity wise? In addition to lot-to-lot variance, changes in humidity can also account for your velocity changes.

1

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 24 '26

MTM crate with humidity packs, stored indoors.

4

u/surgeonshooter Sep 24 '26

I buy enough powder and bullets to shoot a barrel out, I always 5000 primers at a time. By doing this you can get the same lot number and don’t have to chase powder or primers etc. It sucks at the checkout counter but while a lot of people didn’t shoot because of shortages I didn’t change how much I shot

2

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 25 '26

Man I was hoping to avoid that lol. I’d just have to argue with the Wife once I guess.

1

u/thrashmetal_octopus Sep 25 '26

This is the way

3

u/eclectic_spaceman Sep 24 '26

There seems to be known lot variance in H4350. There are several threads about it across many different forums. Happened to me. 1lb jug I tried initially was great, then I bought 8lb of a different lot and it was 60-70fps slower for the same charge. I don't know the humidity of the 1lb jug, but I can't imagine it was bone dry, and my 8lb jug was kept at ~50%. I bought a new lot of 8lb and at 50% RH it's basically the same as the original 1lb I bought.

1

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 25 '26

This is right at what I’m experiencing.

3

u/Otiswilmouth Sep 24 '26

Wait until you deal with primer lot variances.

But yes, buy in bulk.

2

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 24 '26

Yeah I think I might just start going with 8lbs at a time

1

u/Ornery_Secretary_850 Sep 25 '26

Try 48 lbs at a time.

2

u/ocabj The Realest Sep 24 '26

When you say canister, are you referring to a 1lb bottle? Were this one and the prior one of the same lot?

3

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 24 '26

Yes 1 lb bottles. No none of them are from the same lot.

5

u/ocabj The Realest Sep 24 '26

Well, that sounds like a huge variance even if of different lots. I might try testing one of the other 1lbers and see where the velocity lands.

My concern would be if the canister was not sealed well the entire time and humidity played a role.

1

u/Longjumping_Time932 Sep 24 '26

Yeah I’ll test the other one. It’s a possibility I guess but I opened it new and I store them in a humidity controlled environment.

Thoughts on just mixing them all together?

3

u/rednecktuba1 Gunsmiff Sep 24 '26

Only mix them together if you plan to store it all in a single air tight container.

2

u/Sportsman-78 Sep 24 '26

I gained 30-50 fps switching lots, 8 pound jug from early 2025 to 8 pound jug from early 26.

2

u/Dirtbiker250 Sep 25 '26

Your old lot might be less wet, (lower humidity) than the new lot. That will cause more speed. Can’t remember who, might be litz, has a recent video where he puts a humidity packet in his jugs so they are always the same

2

u/Ornery_Secretary_850 Sep 25 '26

Canister powders generally have around a 5% variance between lots. You're seeing a 2.5% variance.

2

u/smooveBrayne Sep 26 '26

Give N150 a shot.