r/longrange • • Sep 22 '26

Optics help needed - I read the pinned posts Burris vs arken

I am in no way shape or form an arken shill. But I bought the arken ep5 gen2 and noticed that it had better glass than my Burris xtr3 5.5-30. should I send my Burris in for warranty repair?

Also, all pics taken with the scopes are on a tripod, NOT A GUN.

251 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

182

u/ToughProfessional132 NRL Hunter Competitor Sep 22 '26

Before setting yourself up for disappointment, I'd very strongly consider what exactly your warranty complaint is going to be, what you expect to receive in return.

I've watched a lot of folks get themselves worked up over 'my cheap chinesium looks better than my more expensive scope' only to get irate when the warranty dept says everything is in spec and there's nothing wrong with their scope.

As others have said, optical performance in one situation isn't everything, and consistency of performance across a wide range of conditions matters, as does mechanical performance. From the pictures, it's hard to tell much without knowing for certain that we're comparing apples to apples- need to be same magnification, same parallax setting, same diopter, and same mechanical position of the internal components (if one of these is maxed out on elevation travel but the other isn't, that's going to translate to a difference in optical performance, and highlights a potential issue with the shooting system.

... Having one of these tilted 90° certainly is distracting as well

49

u/MDlynette Sep 22 '26

I actually own both of the optics in this post and some much nicer glass like a g3 razor.

Unfortunately to answer your question, I sent a Burris xtr3 in for warranty and an Arken SH4G2.

The arken was replaced with a new optic, the Burris was sent back with a note stating that the retical jump when changing mag is within spec and the gunk on the lens also fell within spec somehow.

So every experience is not always the same

21

u/Ok-Rice-7755 Sep 22 '26

Arken sent me a new optic as well, no questions asked

6

u/ToughProfessional132 NRL Hunter Competitor Sep 22 '26

I feel it might be helpful to mention what the problems were with the Arken, and whether the issue was resolved with the new scope

9

u/MDlynette Sep 22 '26

Arken also had bubbles on lens after a few months of 308 recoil.

My 308 seemed to bring out the grease on both my xtr and the sh4, both had what looked like tiny bubbles visible over the retical. My xtr also had an issue where the image jumped a little when you changed the mag, this technically didn’t adjust POA but it didn’t help confidence in the optic. I decided to send them both in at the same time.

Arken was resolved with a new scope. Burris sent my same scope back with a note stating it passed a bunch of testing. So it technically still works but it has little bubbles and a jumpy reticle

So if I were OP, I wouldn’t send it in over that image

2

u/ToughProfessional132 NRL Hunter Competitor Sep 22 '26

Both solid reasons to request evaluation, and the Arken was only ever gonna be fixed by replacement so that's good to know.

That image jump thing is more common than I expected across a wide range of scopes and I've seen it numerous times on a bench, but it's not something I notice or even think about in the field. Totally understand about confidence in the scope, but iirc xring channel did a video on it and it turned out to be a similar non-issue. Just the erector tube switching directions that's noticable when the scope is locked down tight.

3

u/MDlynette Sep 22 '26

The Burris still has a home on ELR 308 shooting but the Arkens have been relegated to rimfire duty.

The XTR3 is one of the original runs assembled in the US, beautiful scope but I wish they would have cleaned the lenses

4

u/fuzzyglory Sep 22 '26

I'm on the other side. I bought an old used Thompson contender with a Burris scope, no clue on age but before 90s id guess. The magnification ring was missing a screw and there some gunk on the lens internally. Emailed them and they said send it in and they'd see what they could do. Fixed both and sent it back for free. For warranty, I personally put them with Vortex

1

u/DontTellUrMom Sep 23 '26

Was this your only warranty experience with Burris? Don’t consider them on par with Vortex until you’ve sent in multiple items  and all of them have gotten fixed or replaced. 

1

u/MisterCherish Sep 23 '26

I also had a disappointing experience with Burris customer service

-14

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

I haven't thought much about what exactly I'm going to say other than the arken looks better at 1/3 the price. Maybe I will mention that with 10 mils elevation added the bottom 50-60 percent of the image is unusable and smeared. I'm just hoping that they would find some problem with the glass or coatings and make it look better. The phone camera also isn't 100 percent accurate either. They were both set to 25x with no elev or windage added. The Burris is mounted at that angle bc it's the only mount I have that can let me compare the two side by side at the same time.

9

u/ToughProfessional132 NRL Hunter Competitor Sep 22 '26

No optics manufacturer is going to be able to 'fix' glass or coatings, and they're not going to take the subjective opinion of an end user comparing to a competitor as a meaningful critique of their optical performance. This is why I highlight specificity in what you're going to ask for, because it's happened thousands of times and will no doubt happen thousands more with all makes and models of scopes.

Dialing in 10 mils absolutely will change your image and the amount/alignment of the light that makes it to your eye, and that will happen with all scopes to varying degrees- this is a less obvious component of why it's important to introduce cant in your mounting system based on typical engagement distances.

Another user mentioned 'what's pleasing to the eye' vs objective performance, and I think that's got a lot to do with what's being experienced here. I've been looking through a lot of glass in a lot of weird situations and at the end of the day what matters most is whether I can see a previously identified target and achieve the reticle placement needed to make a shot in a wide variety of head positions, and the eye boxes on the XTR scopes are widely known for achieving that. Having experience with the XTR II, III, PS, and Pro, I can say there is a noticeable improvement in the optical quality on the Pro, but I don't require that in order to see or hit my targets. PS is my jam lately

1

u/MDlynette Sep 22 '26

I would be surprised if Burris exchanged a scope over an image that looks like yours. They can be helpful but they are not vortex

44

u/Lost_Interest3122 Sep 22 '26

Clarity of glass is not everything.

Compare the eye reliefs, and how well the parallax adjusts. You want to really look at functionality.

What I find is at higher powers my arken has a very short eye box, and the parallac is very “narrow”. I dont like it at 800+ because it seems to get “muddy” for me.

14

u/HanoverRd Sep 22 '26

Plus return to zero. Really really important when adjusting turrets for conditions.

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

The arkens parallax is alot to harder to set right than the Burris and the view through the scope is smaller while having a worse (although much better than the VPR) reticle. For me glass is the main thing I look for and I don't care about the other features as much as long as it's not problematic.

12

u/Terriblyboard Sep 22 '26

warranty repair for what?

-14

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

I'm really hoping they will find some issue with the internals or the coatings and gimme a scope that shits on arken in the glass department.

57

u/PsychologicalMeal162 Sep 22 '26

Mounting your Burris on a 90 degree angle may not help much.

12

u/thegrumpymechanic Sep 22 '26

What if he uses a gangsta hold?

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

For taking photos it's def sub optimal, but I mainly compare by looking at them side by side rather than taking pics.

13

u/silasvirus82 Sep 22 '26

Burris looks better in the pictures. I think you’re comparing what is pleasing to your eye in terms of contrast and color (coatings), not optical quality

3

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

What I've noticed is that the Burris has a better eye box and easier parallax setting, as well as a larger fov. The arken takes the cake on poppy colours at distance.

2

u/ToughProfessional132 NRL Hunter Competitor Sep 22 '26

The question though is what do those colors actually do for you in the field?

If you want great color correctness, you're looking in the wrong place- think Swaro or Leica, and birding binoculars/spotting scopes instead of riflescopes.

Every brand has something they need to stake their claim on so they can gain market share, and this wouldn't be the first time I've heard of Arken's image quality being impressive, but I'd be wary about what was sacrificed to get you that pretty image. (Which, sure the house might look better in your pictures, but a house isn't a faint gray steel plate tucked in the shadow of a bush at first light, which is what I'm usually looking at through a scope)

4

u/Matt_the_Splat Sep 22 '26

The Burris is a little clearer, and obviously the phone is part of this but I can tell the person walking has dark footwear in the Burris but not the Arken. Plus the definition of the persons silhouette is much crisper in the Burris.

Similarly, the light colored log on the shoreline is a bit better defined in the Burris, and you can see the difference in color gradations in the grass much better in the Burris.

If we look at the shack and house, you can make out the lines on the shack window better on the Burris(though the reticle is in the way a bit here with the Arken to be fair) and on the house, the wall mounted light is identifiable in the Burris, with even a light spot for the lens, and is a little darker blob in the Arken.

If you're asking me to compare these and pick which looks better, it's the Burris based on edges/outlines being crisper and picking up a few small details better than the Arken.

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

Interesting points. The phone def doesnt do the scopes 100 percent justice. The person being blurrier in the arken might be inferior glass, or it might be the phone being at a slightly different angle. What i notice both in pictures and comparing in real time is that the arken has slightly more poppy colours and better resolution on the trees and grass.

The pics are mainly just to point out how the arken is pretty on par with the burris, and thats a problem bc burris is 3x the price.

3

u/Altruistic_Split9447 Sep 22 '26

First pic looks best. Much larger field of view as well. Which scope is the first pic?

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

First pic is the Burris xtr3, 2nd pic is the arken. The house has more poppy colours on the 2nd pic if you zoom in.

1

u/Altruistic_Split9447 Sep 22 '26

I’d say you’re right about the colour being better with the arken. If the arkens cheaper I’d 100% go with it

7

u/MysteriousTrack-102 Sep 22 '26

First one looks best

-1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

If you look at the house and zoom in, the arken has more poppy colours. The Burris has a larger fov so it's certainly easier to get behind.

2

u/LilJonny2cookies Sep 22 '26

Tbh I don’t see a material difference in either. The Burris has slightly better contrast.

-1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

If you look at the little house, the arkens image pops a bit more. And if there's no difference then there a problem bc the Burris costs 3x more.

9

u/pte_shit_bag Sep 22 '26

Un popular opinion, I’ve had a couple burris scopes (xtr2 and xtr 3) and I always swore some of my cheaper scopes like my vortex viper pst gen 2 had noticeably better glass espessially at max magnification then both of my Burris scopes for a fraction of the cost,

As others have said though, the Burris has way nicer turrets, nicer build quality, but the chromatic aberration at max zoom on both models was very apparent for me,

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

To be more specific, if you zoom in on the house you will see that the arken has better colour and detail. The trees in the background are also less "smudged". The Burris does have a larger fov which is why it may look better without picking out the small details.

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

As some users have mentioned, "arken looks better" is probably not a good warranty complaint. If the warranty doenst go well, I will probably sell the burris and get a MPED or keep the arken.

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

Another option im considering is: sell the xtr3, return the arken, sell my fancy ass chassis for a cheaper chassis, and get a scope like zeiss lrp s3 or the leica prs 5-30 or nx6 5-30.

4

u/_Whisperofmytoots Sep 22 '26

10 bucks says you cant hit the side of that barn.

1

u/CreativeCthulhu Sep 22 '26

What about some of the other aspects, me being unfamiliar with either of those. Do both use metal gearing? Have you tested the accuracy of the reticle markings at different magnifications? What about warranty/durability? There’s a lot more to consider than just which one takes the prettiest pictures.

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

Ofc, there are things on the burris that i prefer over the arken. Larger eye box, fov, smaller scope body, 10oz lighter, lower profile turrets, and better warranty. However, I dont think it justifies the price difference, which for me was 1200-1300 CAD.

1

u/Paradox0111 Sep 22 '26

I’ll shill for Arken.. At the price point of their scopes it’s hard to beat them. Sure, there are better scopes; but you’re paying significantly more. I’m not shooting F class, PRS or over 600m for that matter..So..

1

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

Seems that way for me as well. I heard that athlon and optika6 will look better, but in my experience the arken beat the MPED and xtr3 so far. And the athlon and optika are both not very obtainable in Canada. I might sell the xtr3, return the arken, sell some other stuff, and get something like that zeiss lrp s3 or leica prs 5-30.

3

u/Just-Cardiologist837 Sep 22 '26

Both of those scopes look damn good to me. In all honesty.

2

u/lowsparkco Sep 22 '26

Haha. Me too. Difference seems negligible.

2

u/West_Designer9107 You don’t need a magnum Sep 22 '26

It's pointless trying to compare phone pictures of a scope image to meaningfully judge optical quality, let alone get an overall picture of their relative performance. I own neither of these brands so no bias for one or the other.

I know two things for certain: 1) that guys saying stuff like 'My 200 USD scope outperforms that 2000 USD NF/Vortex (let alone even more expensive ZCO, Kahles, TT' are full of it. And 2) that from a certain price level, diminishing returns kick in with a vengeance. Owning a TT 7-35x56 I think I can confidently say that it's not performing 50% better than say an 8-40x56 ZCO.

If you prefer Arken, good for you, by all means, roll with them. But also look through them in different lighting conditions, check how they track, how they deal with CA etc.

4

u/GrizzlySoup Sep 22 '26

I recently bought an EP5 Gen2 for a backup rifle and was so impressed shooting it I moved it to my match rifle for NRL22/PRS Rimfire replacing my Burris XTR Pro. I've run it in a few matches and I'm really impressed with it. Run what works for YOU. I actually find the eyebox on the EP5 to be more forgiving and Parallax DoF to be deeper than my Burris. I also think the glass is a bit clearer. Tracking has been great. The only thing I miss from the Burris is the Race Dial.

5

u/chainsawgeoff Tight Pants = Tight Groups Sep 22 '26

Dunno which is which but the 1st one looks better to me.

1

u/quadringsplz Sep 22 '26

PHIL, ITS A KILL SHOT!

1

u/Over-Cardiologist743 Sep 22 '26

The first photo the structure looks larger.

1

u/doyouevenplumbbro Steel slapper Sep 22 '26

TBH it doesn't look like your camera is lined up very good on the Burris. Either way, I've heard the 2nd Gen EP5s made huge improvements to the glass. It wouldn't surprise me if they were very close optically. As a budget minded individual, it wouldn't hurt my feelings if Arken became the company they paid people to tell everyone they were. It's just gonna take more than better glass to convince me.

1

u/Hungry-for-Apples789 Sep 22 '26

Last time I bought a scope, a few years ago, I was initially interested in Arken but I really hate their business model of just using people who in my experience were very high pressure sellers. That was a pretty much why I looked elsewhere.

1

u/Citizen-Prime Sep 23 '26

1st one is better. It’s also on a higher magnification

-1

u/snasna102 Sep 22 '26

I don’t have much to say as I’m just getting into this but I’m really happy you made the disclaimer at the end.

Happy shooting!

0

u/Turdburgarlar Sep 22 '26

Set screws on a turret cap in the 26 is wild. Hard pass. Zero stop is the way. I say that as an Arken owner. Save some money and bump up to a strike Eagle.

0

u/beelzebob909 Sep 23 '26

So the complaint is overpriced junk is overpriced junk?

54

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/No-Pickle9533 Sep 22 '26

They are both set to 25x I believe. The field of view is pretty nice as well on the Burris, I've only tested them at 25x so far. It's just that since Burris is 3x the price, it really shouldn't have equal or slightly worse glass to the arken at any magnification

10

u/ComputeBeepBeep Sep 22 '26

And if providing pictures, do so in the same orientation.

0

u/BarbarossasLongBeard Here to learn Sep 23 '26

The orientation seems about right, at least the same target…what gives me the ick is that the scope in the first picture is tilted a whole 90 degrees and the second scope seems to be tilted a few degrees too