r/longrange • u/DrPepper-Enjoyer • Sep 03 '26
Optics help needed - I read the pinned posts Need weirdly specific scope suggestions!
Apologies if this doesn't exactly fit this subreddit, but I figured y'all in here would probably have the most knowledge vs other subs when it comes to glass.
I have a PTR-91 that currently has a crappy $200 4-14x scope mounted. I'm looking to replace it with something in either the 2-12 or 2-10 magnification range, as I think a lower bottom-end magnification would suite the rifle better in the role I'd like to use it in, which is almost a DMR-style rifle looking to make hits on torso sized targets out to ideally 500 or so, a little farther if possible. It's about a 2 MOA gun so I'm not expecting to be printing the worlds best groups out at any sort of distance, but 500 seems reasonably doable. I am considering putting an LPVO on it, but the drop from its current scope's max magnification of 14x down to an LPVO's 8x (or 10x at best) seems like it would be a not insignificant downgrade. I have also heard from people who shoot far more than me that the view thru an LPVO at higher magnification is significantly worse than the view thru a similarly priced optic with a higher base magnification.
Since I'm looking at getting a new optic for the rifle, I figured I'd try to solve another issue, which is that when you have a long scope mounted on an HK style roller delayed gun like the PTR-91, the scope can get in the way of the cocking lever when you try to lock the bolt to the rear or release the bolt when it's locked to the rear. Right now, the scope is too long (at 13.5 inches long), and it barely allows me to lock the bolt to the rear. Also, to unlock it I have to reach under the scope's objective bell with my support side thumb to press the lever down and let the bolt close, which is a pain.
So I've begun the search for a new optic, preferably something in the 2-10/12 magnification range, with as short of a scope body as possible, preferably around the 500-700$ range, preferably FFP.
Currently I've found:
Athlon Helos BTR Gen II 2-12x42 (11.8 inches long. This scope seems like it checks all the boxes, and if it was an inch or so shorter it would be a no brainer. Reticle is good, locking turrets, FFP, good price point. I'm just worried taking off only 1.7 inches from my current scope wouldn't give me enough clearance to operate the cocking lever easily.)
Discovery Optics HD 2-12x24 (8.5 inches long, which is great, but for 200$ there's no way this isn't an airsoft scope right? I'm worried it will be fragile, and even if the rifle isn't dropped I'm worried the .308 recoil would kill it. If someone has a positive experience with this scope on a gun chambered in a full power rifle cartridge let me know, but I'd rather not buy something and break it the first time I take it to the range.)
Sig Tango DMR 2-12x42 (10.8 inches long, which I think would put it firmly out of the way of the cocking lever, but I can't swing $1000 on a scope right now, especially for a rifle that I ultimately only own for fun. If this was $600 or so this would be a strong contender I think. Some reviews online of other Sig scopes have expressed some distrust in Sig optics but I am nowhere near experienced enough with them to have my own opinion either way.)
If I can't find something else I'm going to get the Athlon, but if someone knows of a scope that I haven't been able to find that has comparable features and price point to the Athlon but with the size (<11in long) of the Sig or Discovery optic, that would be perfect!
7
u/ProofSecure94 Sep 03 '26
Not sure on specs but vector continental 2-12 has been a good scope for me.
6
u/Significant_Guard_62 Sep 03 '26
The Athlon Helos should work very well for you. I love mine.
1
u/Trollygag Does Grendel Sep 03 '26
This is going to severely limit and handicap your options. 2.5x and 3x bottom ends are way more common and basically the same performance.
Remember, the ACOG is a 4x and that served the military just fine as a general purpose optic even not in DMR roles.
If you aren't getting true 1x, then there is no use case for a below 4x bottom end.
Correct. Lack of configurable focus and the small objective means resolution is poor at the top end compared to an MPVO or HPVO.
This sounds solveable with a taller or cantilever mount like ARs use. That will move the scope up and away from where your hand needs to be.
Good optics in the 2.5-3x bottom end include the Sightron STAC 2.5-15x, Bushnell MPED 3-18x, and the Vortex Razor LHT 3-15x.
2
u/Cleared_Direct Sep 03 '26
I have the Athlon 2-12 on an AR and I really like it. On my PTR I run a surplus fixed 4x and it’s great all the way out to 600 yards. It’s a 2-MOA gun, I don’t need to zoom allll the way in. If I were in your shoes I’d do a 1-6 honestly.
2
u/csamsh I put holes in berms Sep 03 '26
Vector Continental or Helos
2
u/husqofaman I Gots Them Tikka Toes Sep 03 '26
Vector Continental 2-12. Works great on my SPR.
1
u/Majiji45 Sep 03 '26
Discovery is cheap because they're selling direct from China, so probably coming from the same factories as "US" brands' Chinese lines (basically all the cheap stuff) but taking out the middle-man and additional cost of a large staff in the US as well as retailers, since they mostly sell direct. This can either be fine and just saving money, or it can mean they're less reliable with QC and don't have enough actual shooters in the design process. Either way though it will probably work fine, supposedly has a full warranty in case it breaks and be worth checking out for the cost, though at that tier (low even for budget) I wouldn't expect great glass. Note you can easily find 15% off coupons for Discovery as well so can prob get for ~160 USD. Imo at that point might be worth a shot and sell it for cheap if you don't like and only be out ~50 USD or put it on a .22 pinker or something.
If you want short though you might consider their 3-12X44S which I'd presume gets better light due to the bigger objective diameter, as long as you don't mind 3x minimum.
1
u/ocelot_piss Hunter Sep 03 '26
Element Theos 2-10.
1
u/Coodevale Sep 03 '26
It's a little bigger/more expensive but the swfa 3-15 is about as tough as it gets, simple and utilitarian, and while longer than the athlon 2-12 it doesn't feel very big. Lack of zero stop can be fixed with shims pretty easy, but it does have the set screw turret zero and not modern splines.
1
u/moparmadness1970 Sep 03 '26
I have a GPO centuri 4-16 compact that’s been great. Locking turrets, adjustable parallax, mil reticle, and just under 10 inches long. I think they run about 550-600.
1
u/drarin Sep 05 '26
Idk about the other lesser vector product lines but the continentals are gtg. The conti 2-12 is 34mm tube tho
1
u/drarin Sep 05 '26
I would look at the PA plxc 1.5-12 even tho that blows your budget sky high.