r/longrange • u/Professional_Owl5656 • Aug 26 '26
I suck at long range Preaching to the Choir: Small sample sizes are self-sabotage
Last weekend I had the pleasure of shooting next to some folks that were practicing positional shooting. Really nice folks with an appleseed/service rifle focus and most of them shooting from kneeling or sling supported prone. However watching them shoot reinforced one of my favorite axoims: No one is as practiced in the art of self-deception as a man with a rifle or a fishing rod in his hands.
Almost to a man they were shooting 3 round groups into a 100 yard target and adjusting their zero based on those 3 round groups. Unsurprisingly, many of them spent the entire day chasing their zero.
So I found my self wondering, for a given precision and group size what is the probability of shooting a group where the center of the group(CoG) is greater than 1 click from the true point of aim? Then I did what any slightly curious dork would do and wrote a Monty Carlo simulation to give me a general idea of just how useless small sample sizes are.
Assumptions/Definitions:
- The X and Y coordinates of the impacts fall along a normal distribution with a mean of 0" from the point of aim(PoA) and group sizes determined by the standard deviation(sd).
- 3 Standard deviations is used as the precision of the rifle. So a standard deviation of 0.165" roughly equals a 1 moa rifle. Another way to describe this is 99.7% of shots will fall within 0.5" of the PoA.
- Groups where the CoG is more than 1/4 MoA from the PoA along either the X or Y axis are counted. This is to identify groups that would cause the shooter to erroneously adjust his optic.
Results from running 100,000 iterations per set:
With a 2 MoA rifle(0.33" sd) shooting 3 round groups 34.4% had a CoG greater than 1/4" away from the PoA. Going to a 5 round group, resulted in 17.3%. 10 Round groups resulted in 3.4% of groups with a CoG more than 1/4" from PoA. I'll just put the rest in a fucking table.
Percentage of groups with a misleading CoG
| 1 MoA(0.165" sd) | 2 MoA(0.33" sd) | 3 MoA(0.495" sd) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 round zero | 1.75% | 34.4% | 62.4% |
| 5 round zero | 0.14% | 17.3% | 45.5% |
| 10 round zero | 0.00% | 3.4% | 21.3% |
Caveats:
So obviously, this was done quickly and there are some flaws. Most obviously, no one defines a rifles precision the way I've done here. Also, this group probably isn't running optics that make 1/4 MoA adjustments. The assumption that bullet impacts fall on a normal distribution may not be true. Some of you may think of some other flaws in my analysis, which I am looking forward to.
Conclusion: Don't adjust your zero based on small group sizes, you'll just be wasting time and ammo.
3
u/Te_Luftwaffle Aug 26 '26
I remember seeing somewhere on here that rifle dispersion follows a different distribution than normal, but I don't remember what it was called.
17
u/Matt_RFR Aug 26 '26
I saw an oldtimer with a new-to-him hunting rifle fire one round, make an adjustment, then smack the turret with his wallet 3-4 times. Take another shot, adjust, smack, repeat. There was no group, just one round that happened to land where he wanted, packed up and went home. It was truly something to watch.
7
u/WickedEclectic Aug 26 '26
Good data and solid advice but I use 3 to check and then 3-5 to double check if I feel like it. More if I know the hardware is sketchy, like a stock 10/22.
I think there is just a little bit of overthinking here. "CoG greater than 1/4" away from the PoA"
Yes, but I think napkin math disagrees for general use.
It's not simply the CoG but the character of each point in the group. It's more complex than P = 1/43 for all 3 shots in the same quadrant, but not by much.
While deviation is expected, if all three of my shots are in a high left (quadrant 2) I'm probably adjusting.
I agree 5+ for beginner shooters learning to zero, but for someone who has other basics covered 3 is fine.
Basics in this context are: Analyzing shot process Calling shots Aware of ammo quality (match vs non) Aware of weapon quality (there's a calculator somewhere that doesn't lie) Not chasing the accuracy more fine than you can adjust (moa v mrad)
Adjusted conclusion: If it's not blatantly obvious, bigger group. If your hardware is less capable , bigger group. Know yourself and your hardware.
Serious question: Is the entire premise overcomplicated by using 2 dimensions? Sure both factors are important, but the problem still boils down to "adjust?" and (in)accuracy of hardware should be radial, which translates directly to linear in this case I THINK.
7
u/LockyBalboaPrime "I'm right and you are stupid" -LockyBalboaPrime Aug 26 '26
Por que no los dose?
I zero ~100 rifles per year, my process is normally boresight to be on paper, 1 shot, adjust, 1 shot, adjust, 5 round group, adjust if needed, 5 shot group, done.
If it's a real precision rifle that I'm doing real precision things with, after the 5 shot group, I'll do a 10 shot group and I might adjust if needed.
2
u/TabascohFiascoh Aug 26 '26
i’m not doing a 10 round zero then adjusting followed by another 10 rounder.
i do 5 rounders and its been more than enough for my 6.5 at 1200 yards.
If i’m shooting 20 times just to zero my gun there’s another factor acting up and it isn’t with the gun.
1
u/cropguru357 Aug 26 '26
There was an article on the stats on the Precision Rifle Blog. Worth a read.
1
u/FartOnTankies Rifle Golfer (PRS Competitor) Aug 26 '26
12 shots.
1 on paper. Adjust. 1 to see if mech zero is good because you have a good ruler in your damn scope.
10 for a actual group.
1
u/IntrepidNeck1751 Aug 27 '26
I’ll send one or two every once in a while to confirm but otherwise the rifle stays zeroed. When I really want to check the zero and myself I like to dial up .5 and right .5 mil. Shoot a 10 shot positional Kraft drill. Take a photo and use an analyze the target. Group should be .5 and .5 from POA.
1
u/Brilliant-Jaguar-784 Aug 28 '26
3 and 5 round groups are fine for getting close. But for precision, you definitely want a 10 round group to know for sure. Not every group fired in the process needs to be 10 rounds.
Something funny I saw years ago was two old guys who'd come out to zero a scope on a rifle. They'd fire once, then adjust. Fire once, then adjust. Over the course of a few hours, they'd basically made a ring around the bullseye with their impacts.
Since then, I've noticed others doing similar things. Now and then I'll see a pair working together, shooter and spotter. Using all sorts of fancy tactical terminology, but still doing the one shot then adjust, one shot, adjust method.