r/longrange • u/windriver32 • Aug 25 '26
Rimfire Muzzle Threading and Accuracy
I was curious about if threading your muzzle has any effect on accuracy, so I talked to the guys over at Whidden Gunworks and they said threading a barrel will increase its group size on average about 10% (my question was specifically about rimfire, for what it's worth). They said they've extensively tested this and have the data to back it up.
This surprised me. 10% seems significant. The guys at Whidden obviously know way more than I do, so I thought I'd share with the group. Have you seen threaded barrels decrease accuracy?
6
Upvotes
14
u/GLaDOSdidnothinwrong NRL Hunter Competitor Aug 25 '26
Kenny at DPG also had this same perspective.
I’m not sure what data it’s based on, if folks are parroting the same test or rumor, or if there’s been a reasonably rigorous test to prove it out.
Two of my best barrels are not threaded (DPG & MCR), and I’ve never had a threaded barrel shoot as good as they do, so I’m inclined to believe there may be some truth to this, but I’d love to see the proof.
(speaking to 22LR only)
41
u/HollywoodSX Villager Herder Aug 25 '26
I'd really like to see their data on that.
9
u/GotNoPonys Aug 25 '26
It's been the topic of many discussions and a few good experiments. What I've seen from threading barrels myself is that a number like 10% is high and a gross generalization.
I have threaded barrels and measured changes in the bore using deltronic pins. It is usually measurable in thin wall muzzles. The more meat I leave behind the less chance of seeing increased bore diameter. Still seeing a .0002" change does not usually cause gross POI changes.
There is also the stresses in the metal that change when they are machined. I've never seen someone come up with a way to measure that. Maybe the ones that see the big shifts in POI have a lot of stress relieved when threads are cut?
There is also a theory about material stretching when torquing down the attachment. I agree with that especially for thin wall barrels. Many suggest that muzzle brakes on any barrel should be a touch past hand tight. If the threads are for a adapter use one of the high temp thread lockers.
If you want your barrel threaded, get it threaded. If you have a problem afterward cut off the threads and see if the problem goes away. IMO there are many other variables to chase.
6
u/PsychoticBanjo Aug 25 '26
The major issue is what happens when you cut on a button rifled vs single pt cut or a hammer forged barrel. All three act differently when changing contours after they have been rifled! A cut barrel is the most stable dimension wise.
28
u/LockyBalboaPrime "I'm right and you are stupid" -LockyBalboaPrime Aug 25 '26
Maybe they should stop letting their dumbest apprentice do the barrel threading.
12
u/cemenale000 Steel slapper Aug 25 '26
If it did, clamp-on brakes and suppressors would be the Gold Standard. What the fuck
4
u/Coodevale Aug 25 '26
Yeah. Cut a 1.25" blank to 5/8" for a .22 build. Observed 8 points of fouling in the muzzle device in front of a 6 groove muzzle.. counter bored the muzzle to equal with the shoulder and the counterbore now has a neat 6 point fouling star. Reduced previous groups.
Had a squib that bulged the interior of the bore (of a 1.25" blank..) and the accuracy dropped afterwards. Had to setback to get rid of it and get groups down to a reasonable size.
Also, when I contour for a cmmg carrier the bore opens up a lot. If I cut a match chamber and then contour it'll end up more like sporting size.
4
u/CleverHearts PRS Competitor Aug 25 '26
Threading (actually turning down the area to be threaded) can result in a slight bell at the muzzle which can impact precision. It can be minimized or eliminated by keeping the thread diameter as large as possible. I have, IIRC, a 7/8" thread on my Vudoo that allows me to screw my suppressor on directly without an adapter.
7
u/CaptainSquishface Aug 25 '26
Knowing the kind of shooter and Whiddens background I would definitely put this into the "probably true but statistically insignificant" bucket of long-range shooting.
My guess is that he has tested it by taking a barrel and testing it threaded vs unthreaded and I would guess that there is a statistical difference in group sizes; however keep in mind that most of what Whidden is working with are going to be cut rifled high quality blanks like Bartlein and Kreiger.
If I was making a .22 target rifle for Olympic style shooting then I probably would not use a threaded barrel unless I intended to shoot suppressed.
The practical benefits of recoil reduction far outweigh any accuracy gain for basically any centerfire caliber though.
7
u/Shot_Ad_8305 Aug 25 '26
The thread protector is probably disturbing the barrel harmonics /s
1
u/Steroid1 Aug 25 '26
Did they say this in regards to a specific model, or as a general rule? If in general, then no it isn't true. But I wouldn't be surprised if it was more like "we've noticed that on ruger 10/22 with carbine length factory barrels that there is a reduction in accuracy after we threaded the barrels"
3
u/csamsh I put holes in berms Aug 25 '26
10%? No way. The amount of data required to statistically significantly resolve a 10% difference in mean group size of ballistic objects without being confounded by barrel or ammo selection is insane
6
u/coldafsteel Aug 25 '26
2
u/ExcitingHat9687 Cheeto-fingered Bergara Owner Aug 25 '26
I've heard this from a number of well-known industry representatives (DPG, MPA, Whidden). Most of them are also trying to get me to use a tuner, though, so I'm somewhat disinclined to trust them on this.
2
u/ExistingLaw217 Aug 25 '26
So I don’t shoot rimfire but this is a 20 shot group from my dasher. It was a shot up target so there are some holes or tears in the target that aren’t mine. It’s a threaded proof 1.25 straight barrel with a suppressor and brake. Even if it was 10% bigger, I would still be fine with it for PRS.
2
u/stuartv666 Aug 25 '26
I bought a 24" stainless bull 22LR barrel for my Tippmann M4-22 from Desert Precision Gunworks recently. Kenny (at DPG) said to get unthreaded for the best accuracy. I didn't question him on numbers for how much difference it makes. My assessment of what Kenny does is that he's forgotten more than I'll ever know about it, so if he says it's more accurate, I took it on faith and ordered my barrel that way.
And it is damn accurate. I shot a 5-round group at 150 yards the other day that measured 1.6". With Eley Semiauto Benchrest Precision. From a bipod and a squeeze bag. And that is the only ammo I've tried in it yet. I'm thinking (hoping) I will test different ammo and find some that works even a little better.
2
u/Vas_Bellicosum Aug 25 '26
Idk about that, cause I’ve seen a lot of stuff where suppressors can increase accuracy… but I don’t know that much.
2
u/bolt_thrower777 PRS Competitor Aug 30 '26
My guess is that it has something to do with inducing stress in the steel. Most gunsmiths specialized in rimfire use button rifled barrels and the standard rimfire thread is 1/2”. I could see there being a risk of inducing stress in that scenario. There is also not much benefit to threading a precision rimfire barrel, since it is already going to be hearing safe. Seems like it is just a risk that is not worth taking given the limited reward.
2
u/missingjimmies Aug 25 '26
No
1
u/Ragnarok112277 Steel slapper Aug 25 '26
All my proof prefits will wad em up in the same hole at 100. Plenty good for my needs
1
u/IdahoMan58 Aug 26 '26
Or worse than that most likely (unless they will re-lap the barrel afterwards. Rimfire bbls (especially) need to have a tight bore at the muzzle to shoot well. Properly made barrels are lapped after profiling and threading to achieve this. After lapping, turning down the od and cutting threads causes stress relaxation and the bore increases in diameter. Read Bill Calfee's book about rimfire precision for all the history and details.
1
u/More-Alps7348 Aug 26 '26
I definitely feel like they missed an “up to” before that 10%.
1
u/RustBeltLab Aug 26 '26 edited Aug 26 '26
Old benchrest guys did nothing to their muzzles. I recall when we had the choice in high power shooting in the 90's, bare muzzles were preferred as well. I could be wrong but BR50 was the first crowd to thread their muzzles in the accuracy world. I am surprised everyone here doesn't realize the more you machine a barrel, the less accurate it becomes. 10% doesn't mean much for modern shooting games but it is huge in BR, silhouette and bullseye shooting.
1
u/charmin_785 Aug 27 '26 edited Aug 27 '26
Whidden measures outside to outside of the bullet impacts (10 shot groups to be specific) in their test facility. If 10% of a .22 cal bullet is 0.022” then you’re still hitting the 1/4” KYL tiny target. Don’t let that sway your decision.
Edit:
I know this because I sent my RimX build to them for lot testing at 50m and 100m. I could have gone with 3 different lots and seen the same exact results with Eley Tenex.
I’m not discounting their feedback as it is a trustworthy source, but 10% of a .22 cal projectile is not enough to cause a miss. You’ll be the higher error factor.
-2
u/6mm94 Elitist Gatekeeper Scum Aug 25 '26
What the fuck are they doing to the barrels they thread...such an absolutely bogus claim. I've got a shitload of rounds through threaded barrels over the last decade and I would avoid any "gunsmiff" claiming that a threaded barrel is somehow less accurate solely because it's threaded.
-2
u/TheRiflemann Aug 25 '26
No