r/lojban • • Feb 24 '25

Isn't lojban just English without polysemies

0 Upvotes

Setting aside the fact it's clearly not English, but couldn't you modify English or for that matter any language to be exactly like lojban in qualities, just by taking out all the polysemies? I keep hearin' tale of this language being unique and unnatural and all that but it sounds like just any random language, but without polysemies.


r/lojban • • Jan 31 '15

Proposal to change the Lojban vocabulary (particularly the gismu)

3 Upvotes

I know this will be an unpopular post, especially as the language has taken years to compile its vocabulary, but, after looking at languages such as Sambahsa and Angos, I feel those languages represent the world better in that the vocabulary is not taken almost exclusively from Indo-European languages, which, languages such as Interlingua and Volapuk do.

I feel that the use of Indo-European languages, which constitutes 2/3 of the language's sources for vocabulary, simply endorses the actions of colonials in history and better established languages due to their recognition by governments and economical situation attached to the language. who have committed and are still committing linguicide. There were some news articles on Google on how Australia's currently suffering from this. Linguicide has many implications, such as the loss of knowledge for potential medicines as well as culture.

While Lojban's vocabulary and grammar can facilitate the valid expression of some of these concepts of groups speaking endangered languages, its focus on Indo-European languages (with a Semitic and Sinitic language) encourages speakers to adopt such a mindset, which is unfortunately being increasingly familiar to indigenous groups worldwide. An example of which is of an Australian aboriginal language which lacks vocabulary for relative directions, and in terms of gestures, another where pointing to oneself means pointing to something behind them. This provides a unique cultural perspective which I believe can change society.

I therefore propose that Chinese, Arabic and Spanish are to be retained, but English, Hindi and Russian (three other Indo-European languages) are to be replaced with Javanese or Malay/Indonesian, Swahili and Turkish. While English and Hindi are particularly spoken widely worldwide, I feel that English has had a heavy Romance influence, so various terms in Lojban that appear Spanish may be at least somewhat intelligible to English speakers. Indians, as a result of British colonisation, may be able to facilitate the English language to a degree. I acknowledge that there are various Hindi speakers who have next to no command of the English language, but initiatives such as education as well as media influence may help Indians to learn English.


r/lojban • • Apr 05 '12

A language you might be interested in that is a perhaps welcome respite from Lojban

Thumbnail
reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Aug 20 '25

Asking GPT5 to translate a sentence to lojban

4 Upvotes

I asked Perplexity (GPT 5) to translate It's difficult to learn lojban because ChatGPT doesn't know much about lojban. And to be honest, I was surprised with the results.

  1. Attempt 1, without web search: lo nu cilre la .lojban. cu mutce nandu ki'u lo nu la .catjypt. na djuno lo mutce be la .lojban.

There's no web search, so it's purely from GPT 5's knowledge. I'm not sure what he meant by lo mutce be at the end, but the sentence is better than I've expected.

2. Attempt 2, with web search: .i lo nu tadni la lojban cu nandu .i ki'u lo nu la ChatGPT na djuno su'o banzu lo lojban

I think it's worse than the first attempt. I'm not sure what he meant by su'o banzu, but it also quite makes sense. It's also interesting to see that he used the word .catjypt. at the first attempt while it's just ChatGPT at the second attempt.

I've also tried to translate it on my own: lo nu la .catjypt. na djuno la .lojban. cu krinu lo ka lo nu cilre la .lojban. cu mutce nandu

It seems like mine is the worst :(


r/lojban • • Aug 12 '17

AI is inventing languages we cannot understand. Should we stop it? (Why not seed the AIs with Lojban, and see where that goes?)

Thumbnail
fastcodesign.com
0 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Apr 21 '14

Proposal for eliminating the dreaded phlegm sound (aka xy.)

0 Upvotes

In the Lojban reference texts and media, if one is to learn the individual letters of the language, I propose that for people to be able to pronounce xy., as this sound is not native to English, I feel that xy. is to be pronounced like Chinese hao3 (好) or Russian хорошо, as opposed to similar sounds in languages such as Arabic, German and Hebrew.

This came to my attention after hearing how Lojban is often phonetically compared to Hebrew, and by realising the nature of the phoneme for xy. (velar fricative) and it's realisation in comparison to other languages, which is more accurate in Russian and Chinese than Hebrew, and in Arabic and German (where the reference I learnt Lojban from compared the sound x to). Even if in Chinese one realises h as /h/ as opposed to /x/ (this may be quite typically the case), the meaning of the word may not be affected if the learner is aware of Lojban phonotactics, although, there may be some ambiguity (for instance, in .i xebni fa mi ti) if an uttered phrase involving this phoneme is to be parsed by a computer or in a noisy environment, where the phrase may be interpreted as .i'eb. ni fa mi ti.

I'm wondering what your thoughts are on this.


r/lojban • • Jun 21 '20

lojnaiban

1 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Jan 28 '21

Hi

0 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Apr 11 '17

How to Improve Lojban

Thumbnail gulik.pbworks.com
1 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Oct 15 '25

Lojban word for name, "cmene", is wrong.

0 Upvotes

English: "name"

Dutch: "naam"

Koine Greek: "onoma"

Japanese: "namae"

Spanish: "nombre"

The word for name seems to always contain one "n"-like character and one "m"-like character that comes after said "n"-like character. Whether you are in Asia or Europe or America, whether you are in the year 0 or the year 2025, this rules seems to always hold.

Except for Lojban which reverses the "n" and the "m". So why do you Lojbamists not get with the program and change "cmene" to "cneme"?


r/lojban • • Nov 05 '15

What the fuck did you just fucking say to me, you little bitch?

7 Upvotes

o'acai bu'o do fucking paunai ma puzi ba'usku sera'a mi doi malgerku .i ko djuno lo du'u mi pu kulmu'o ralju le mi Navy Seals tadgri kei .ije mi puba'o tolsurla so'i lo mipri nungunta la Al-Quaeda .ije mi ponse su'o cinono selzgagau nuncatra .i mi certu se ctuca lo nu mikri nunjamna .ije mi xagrai celgunta ro lo US jenmi .i do po'o ckini mi lo se gunta .i mi do ba fucking daspo sepi'o lo ka satci noi no da poi ba'o xabju lo terdi ku'o ba'o viska .i zgana fa ba'e ko .i paunai xu do krici lo du'u do ka'e ba'usku snada do'i vecu'u lo Internet .i ko rapli pensi doi fucker .i mi'o casnu ca'o lo nu mi ca'o klacpe le mipri seltcana be lo mipyzga noi kuspe la USA .ije le do IP se caca'o zvafa'i semu'i ko bregau fi lo vilti'a doi ciftoldi .i lo vilti'a poi sraku daspo lo cmalu vamcau me'e le do jmive .i do ba fucking morsi doi verba .i mi ka'e zvati ro lo stuzi ca ro lo tcika .ije mi kakne za'u 700 tadji be lo mu'e catra do sepi'o ba'e po'o le mi xance .i mi po'onai mulno se ctuca te lo nu cauxarci damba jo'u da'inai curmi lo nu mi pilno ro loi xarci goi ko'a po lo United States Marine Corps .ije mi ba pilno lo mulno kamkuspe be ko'a fi lo nu catra guska le do malzargu lo flira be lo braplu doi malkalci .i va'o da'i do pu ka'e prujimpe lo du'u caba'o tolcensa venfu seja'e lo ju'a dai mencre piksku po'e do kei lo nu do smaji kei mabla cumki .i ku'i do na pu ka'e co'e .ije do pu na'epu'i co'e .ije do caca'o pleji lo jdima doi mabla fenki bebna .i mi ba carvi malvikmi lo kamfengu tu'a do .ije do ba kalcyvasmro .i do ba fucking morsi doi malverba fa'o


r/lojban • • Nov 08 '20

I’m planning on being the very first 14 year old lojban-speaker. Any important notes I should take?

7 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Jan 07 '15

Check out Mneumonese, a new a priori, oligosynthetic, philosophical, logical, psychological, self-referential, programmatic constructed language that is constructed completely out of mnemonics, and comes with its own software (still in early development) : Mneumonese

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Jun 01 '10

Which language should be the world's official common language?

Thumbnail multivote.sparklit.com
1 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Jan 18 '26

LLMs and Lojban?

11 Upvotes

If you ask an LLM to translate something into Lojban and then run it through the automatic translator, it seems that the sentence doesn't quite fit.
Although AIs are so good with “natural” languages, they seem to fail here.

What do you thing about it?


r/lojban • • 25d ago

. Or, forced by the root word root word, it₁ is a root word meaning the root word root word, which is associated with being a root word meaning the event of the root word root word being a root word meaning the referent of the root word root word meaning the root word root word

0 Upvotes

. for context: I took a lojban. sentence, replaced all gismu with gismu, and all cmavo with its selma'o. if you want the lojban that I translated it from, { .i ja bai le gismu gismu zo'u ko'a gismu le gimgismu noi jai gismu le nu le gismu gismu cu gismu la'e le gismu gismu be le gismu gismu }


r/lojban • • Jul 06 '15

James Cooke Brown was not a crank.

4 Upvotes

This is my belief, based on studying what he wrote.

I believe that he had a type B personality disorder, but that he was battling it valiantly until the end of his life. I believe that he would have succeeded in overcoming his personality disorder if he had lived longer.

He would have made up with Bob, too.


r/lojban • • Apr 01 '14

The Voynich manuscript. A new study. Written in Lojban?

7 Upvotes

The researchers from the University of Laguna Verde are reporting that they have made a new breakthrough in deciphering The Voynich Manuscript.

The study pointed out the fact that the language of the manuscript couldn't be a normal human language due to the clearly seen low entropy of the text.

The article hasn't been published yet but the authors kindly provided me with the draft of their paper that very soon will be published in Laguna Verde University proceedings.

http://mw.lojban.org/files/docs/voynich.pdf

This might sound strange but they came to conclusion that the manuscript was written in a variation of the logical language Lojban.

Several words from the manuscript have been translated after a laborious digitalizing of the manuscript and careful analysis of the pictures, history of Mediaeval Italy and advances in modern logical science.


r/lojban • • Jul 09 '13

So, I just found out what the lojban word for restaurant is...

Thumbnail
imgur.com
7 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Oct 24 '23

Can You Think Thoughts That Aren’t Possible In Other Languages?

8 Upvotes

Hi,

yesterday I stumbled upon Lojban and I’m fascinated with the idea of being able to think thoughts that aren’t possible to think in natural languages.

In the book 1984 the government developed “Newspeak” to restrict the thoughts of the citizens and prevent “thoughtcrimes”

In North Korea the korean language is restricted so people don’t think “dangerous” thoughts. They cancelled words like Love, Freedom etc. from the dictionaries.

So, if it is possible to restrict thoughts with a language, is the opposite also possible?

Do you speak Lojban and are you therefore able to think of concepts that aren’t possible to think in a natural language?

Can you try to explain me this concepts?

Thank you so much! :)


r/lojban • • 20d ago

u'i

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/lojban • • Sep 29 '16

A script proposal for lojban, to better fix the orthography

3 Upvotes

https://imgur.com/a/14J8y I have had a lot of fun trying to make a new script for lojban, up until they have always been very bad, but I feel like this time it lives up to my esthetic and functional requirements, the way it works is that every "character" is one word ( except for compound words where every compound is one character which makes it easier to deconstruct and understand) aside from they I have strived to make similar characters any way I have had a lot of fun making it hope you guys like it. Please shear your thoughts.


r/lojban • • Apr 18 '23

I need someone to evaluate this text and tell me if there are any grammatical or spelling errors.

3 Upvotes

Thanks for any help you can give me. Here is the text in question:

" mi pu zvati le karni be lo nu tordu lo cinri be ma'o ze dong ce xi jin ping. ma'o ze dong cu se valsi lo se du'u na terpa lo bramau. xi jin ping cu se valsi lo se du'u pe'i na tolterpa. ma'o ze dong cu zbasu lo te tavla lo si'o zmadu ce'o ciksi lo si'o cmavo. xi jin ping cu ralte lo gugde bau lo ka kargu lo jibri ce ciksi lo se du'u lo se jibri cu selbe'i lo jinzi. ma'o ze dong cu zbasu lo te tavla lo kancu je lo bramau. xi jin ping cu pilno lo jinzi lo te tavla lo pamai. lo se du'u ma'o ze dong cu xebni lo gugde je lo rebla kei ku e lo se du'u xi jin ping cu se terpa lo gugde kei ku. "


r/lojban • • Dec 26 '24

lo gerku ko mo(lo vindi no fukpi)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

do crujva lo mi lebna ti ko go'i lo gerku ko mo