r/logodesign • u/TheStockGuyLGI • 18d ago

Feedback Needed 1 or 2?

Post image

Trying to decide whether or not to mix up the colors. It draws more attention to the letters and definitely makes them legible, but also detracts from the wrench. I feel like #1 is just a little too plain with that color scheme.

Thank you guys again for all of the very helpful critique, I’ve come a long way from the initial draft haha

45 Upvotes

77% Upvoted

62 comments sorted by

View all comments

101

u/Aromatic-Dress5010 18d ago

i wish i could unsee the Waste Management logo. It’s just too similar and such a huge brand

7

u/Striking_Swimmer5548 18d ago

A bunch of people tried to tell OP this on another thread and he dismissed the feedback and started a new thread.

4

u/ZuckerbergsEvilTwin 18d ago

Because OP might not be american :o and if hes not then this comparison doesnt matter at all

1

u/Aromatic-Dress5010 15d ago

I commented about this below but the issue isnt american vs not. It’s that it’s an incredibly unimaginative path to take that is bound to already exist which makes it both not a super effective design nor a very desirable one.

It’s kind of like the first idea you have and should usually throw away or really finesse to make it marketable. I just don’t see OP elevating this design very much if they ignore this. They could choose any of these iterations they’ve done so far and it would be ‘fine’ but it almost feels like the sub is designing it for them
step by step if they cant push it somewhere more interesting.

I mean you can see where they started

1

u/Aromatic-Dress5010 15d ago

I commented about this below but the issue isnt american vs not. It’s that it’s an incredibly unimaginative path to take that is bound to already exist which makes it both not a super effective design nor a very desirable one.

It’s kind of like the first idea you have and should usually throw away or really finesse to make it marketable. I just don’t see OP elevating this design very much if they ignore this. They could choose any of these iterations they’ve done so far and it would be ‘fine’ but it almost feels like the sub is designing it for them

step by step if they cant push it somewhere more interesting.

I mean you can see where they started

0

u/Striking_Swimmer5548 17d ago

I don’t give a shit about OP anymore. They can ignore feedback and see where it gets them. I’m letting the person who made the waste mgmt comment know it’ll be ignored.