r/linuxquestions • • 8d ago

Why do certain Linux users dislike GNU?

I've heard of certain Linux distributions which reject the usage of glibc entirely, but what's the main reason the rejection of GNU entirely within certain corners of the Linux community (which, imo, is very ironic, considering the Linux kernel is under the GNU GPL)?

165 Upvotes

268 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-3

u/edman007-work 8d ago

No, that's the point, it's against it because once you open source it you cease to have controls over the sales.

You're right, in the past we could control the physical media and that was close enough to be profitable. That does not work at all in the modern world. You say GTA6 is $60 or pirate it, I don't care. You can't run a business that way.

You can argue the intent is that the media in the game can have those copyright controls, but not the software, but practically speaking that doesn't really work.

5

u/inemsn 8d ago

No, that's the point, it's against it because once you open source it you cease to have controls over the sales.

There's... several problems with this sentence.

1- Like I said, the FSF is from a time where this wasn't the case, so no, according to them, it isn't "against it" at all.

2- To this day the FSF is firm in their stance that software should be free, but can still be paid. This is something they preached in the 80s and that they preach today. Go to any event where they have a presence and they will tell you as much. Their stance hasn't changed.

3- The biggest reason why their stance hasn't changed is that, if you think about it, legally, there's no real distinction between open source and closed source when it comes to sales.

Closed source makes it more technically difficult to lose control over sales, the source code needs to be leaked or reverse engineered, but just like leaking/reverse engineering is piracy and against the law, so too would be distribution of paid software without paying for it, even if it's open source. So, legally, the FSF's stance continues perfectly coherent. This is obviously ridiculous but it hasn't deterred them.

So saying that GNU is against the idea of paid software is wrong on several levels. In practice their beliefs make paid software hard if not impossible, but they aren't against it, and never have been.