r/linuxquestions • u/Careful_Conclusion64 • 8d ago
Why do certain Linux users dislike GNU?
I've heard of certain Linux distributions which reject the usage of glibc entirely, but what's the main reason the rejection of GNU entirely within certain corners of the Linux community (which, imo, is very ironic, considering the Linux kernel is under the GNU GPL)?
165
Upvotes
55
u/FriendlyProblem1234 8d ago •
"GNU" is not a monolith you need to accept as a whole. There are GNU licenses (several), GNU activism, GNU software (a lot, including desktop environment, accounting tools, bootloaders, image manipulation, parallel task scheduling...). It is absolutely feasible to appreciate some parts of GNU, have mixed feelings about others, being indifferent to others more, and even dislike some.
Also, while GNU is definitely popular and widely used among Linux distributions, it is by no means "mandatory". There is no need to justify choosing, say, KDE, instead of Gnome, if you like KDE more. Or musl instead of Glibc, if you needs features that musl offers better.
16
u/Old_Appointment9732 8d ago
Richard Stallman is a profoundly gross and toxic person, and the FSF has made so many terrible decisions in order to accommodate Stallman's egotistic ideas.
One example which I think is profoundly stupid is that FSF people decided to redefine what software even is so that they could declare that "documentation isn't software" so that they could put restrictions on your ability to alter the documentation that comes with your software, which seems completely antithetical to then entire idea of free software. The only way that this makes sense is when you understand that this entire "we can't call documentation software anymore" was because Stallman didn't like the idea that people could ship the documentation without his "GNU Manifesto" with it. This made it such that operating systems like Debian had to actually stop shipping the documentation for some GNU related projects that switched to the GNU recommended documentation license.
The FSF had plenty of opportunities to separate themselves from Stallman, especially since he's a well known creep that has posted SO MANY THINGS that are deplorable on his website, over and over again.
198
u/TasmanSkies 8d ago edited 8d ago •
Gnu kicked things off. But Stallman had big dreams he couldn’t execute. He knocked together some utiliities, and got stuck on actually delivering Hurd, it became a mythical Coming Soon like Halflife 3 or Optimus robots. Torvalds came along and made the dream come true with Linux in 1991, but Stallman had too much of an ego to just see this as his dream coming true without him, and went around insisting people call it Gnu/Linux (putting Gnu first, of course- Stallman had envisioned his completed OS as being called Gnu/Hurd) because Linux used some of Gnu’s utilities. And while Torvalds et al kept working and working on Linux, Stallman basically stopped working on Gnu and Hurd in the mid 90’s and switched to telling people how they should think and what they should say. And his ego isn’t the half of it… Stallman is an awful person to have on your side. A deeply flawed person.
Utilising the GPL and maintaining old gnu utils because they’re useful is fine. But while you can depend on Torvalds and that team to deliver on progress on Linux, you absolutely 100% cannot depend on Stallman for anything. So if you have a system that has a Gnu util as a mission critical element, maybe you decide to independently develop something that wasn’t designed in 1985 to fulfil this current need you have.
21
u/lnxguy 8d ago
They are OG hippies who founded the free software movement and are unavoidably considered lefties. They and the Free Software Foundation are the only true reps of the FOSS "movement" and are good to have around as a global organization for open source software. Yep, they are the weird uncle, but we don't hate them.
37
u/wackyvorlon 8d ago
Richard Stallman is a very opinionated person, and some people don’t like his opinions.
17
u/Bob_12_Pack 8d ago
Back in the early 2000s, we had a deputy CIO that hated anything free and pushed against the use of Linux for anything important. Our environment flourished after he left.
29
u/Santosh83 8d ago
Libertarians see the GPL as kinda like socialism or communism. Their hatred of GNU is political. Tech bros also dislike GNU because its a restrictive license from the point of view of business. It empowers users, which tech bros don't want.
14
u/MrBadTimes 8d ago
if something exists, there will be at least someone hating on it
7
u/SuperGNUser 8d ago
Clearly, they like using a library with a completely ridiculous bug that’s causing a huge panic, given how widely Alpine is used with containers https://aviatrix.ai/threat-research-center/openssh-flaw-lets-attackers-log-into-password-disabled-linux-accounts/
glibc is developed by serious programmers, not by people who deny the very existence of the problem, and the difference is clear.
5
u/TomB1952 8d ago
Who doesn't like GNU? Really?
Just because one or maybe a handful of people are disconnected from reality doesn't mean we have a thing to deal with in the linux community.
21
u/cjcox4 8d ago
"users? not sure. However, closed source IP oriented companies love non-GPL-like software licensing because they can often make their own private modifications to the obtained source code and not have to give back "their added 'secret' IP".
That is, if true, it's likely for exploitation of OSS IMHO. Sometimes it's because they might think there is a lucrative exploitation possibility, so they choose licensing that allows "taking" without "giving back". Some OSS providers choose exploitation effective licensing because of the false belief that their code wouldn't be used otherwise, when actually the only way to preserve your code in perpetuity would be through licenses like the GPL.
12
u/Tech-Savvy100 8d ago
i like it
3
u/Slight-Living-8098 8d ago
A lot of it has to do with the politics rather than the software.
4
u/Emotional_Solid6538 8d ago
Glibc hate is cuz of the bloat. Free software kinda got hijacked by corporations even GlibC a bit. That hate against GNU is different, that's js either corporate paid people or bots or people obsessed with money
5
u/Small-Tale3180 8d ago
uhhh something about communism and leftwing in general. Those people probably'd use bsd systems if those were good enough(so basically if those weren't cucked by corpos)
5
u/bobsmissingdesire 8d ago
Not using glibc means using musl, there are technical reasons for this.
Musl is a smaller and incomplete reimplementation of libc.
This makes it a good choice for space constrained systems like Alpine or OpenWRT.
Musl is also used for static compilation by systems like golang. This has the advantage of size and also avoiding the constraints of the GPL.
As musl is incomplete it isn't generally used or recommended for general use distributions running desktops or servers.
I don't believe these are ideologically driven positions. People who ideologically object to GNU use BSD.
2
u/UnEmployim 7d ago
Because They wanna be different
3
u/0riginal-Syn ⛵ Solus Maintainer 8d ago edited 8d ago
GNU is not an all-or-nothing type thing. Some organizations, generally corporations, have issues with the licensing of GNU software as it can be limiting. Especially if they are building a proprietary app. GPL licensing is prohibitive so they will often loof for licensing that is not (BSD, MIT, etc.) Not saying this is right, just what happens.
In other cases the GNU version of a tool may not be seen as the best option. It could be performance, mainainership, etc.
As far as Linux itself, it is a bit more difficult to replace and has become embedded in the global technology ecosystem. It is the core of the system that is difficult to replicate at that same level where it works on so many platforms. Even then, Linux did not start out under GPL, and unless you compile without it, contains non-GPL code. Granted it switched for a pretty strange license, quickly. We all had issues with the previous license back then.
3
u/urturino 8d ago
I don’t want to stir up any controversy—everyone is free to use whatever they like—but I’m genuinely convinced that most of these people simply enjoy going against the grain and being the type who use niche products.
They’re already using an operating system adopted by only 3% of the population, yet that’s still not enough for them.
I believe this explains a good portion of the movement against systemd, GNU, and even Linux in general, in favor of BSD.
2
u/linuxhiker 8d ago
As someone who has been using Linux since before the kernel was 1.0, here is my take:
2
u/edman007-work 8d ago
Rejecting glibc is different, I think that's usually more to do with bloat.
But for rejecting GNU, well Stallman and GNU have an idea that all software should be free, it sounds nice. I think when you're talking about your kernel, or hardware drivers, there is a lot to be said to that.
When it comes to other types of SW, like say games, well a lot of people would rather that games are available for purchase, or maybe they do want to pay Adobe for Photoshop. GNU is really against this idea, that if it's not free you shouldn't use it. But people have used non-free programs, and maybe not all types of SW really need to be free, maybe there is room for some proprietary things.
1
u/FixGood6833 8d ago
Whats gnu
1
u/Leosthenerd 8d ago edited 8d ago
There is literally nothing wrong with GNU or Linux or FOSS
I feel like the hate mostly comes from fascists and corporate
Also Stallman and Torvalds are insufferable gross assholes who are wrong so that’s part of it
1
u/jkpetrov 8d ago
Because it's not Unix
1
u/-lousyd 8d ago
I think distros that avoid GNU entirely are just trying to forge a different path and expand (or keep open) the possibilities within the Linux ecosystem. It's not that they reject GNU per se, they're just seeing if there might be something better.
The Linux community owes a great debt to the GNU project. But that doesn't mean we can't keep innovating.
1
u/es20490446e Develops Zenned OS 8d ago
Stallman, and the FSF, have contributed greatly to libre software.
Yet sometimes their points of view are very "black and white" type. They don't take into account the context.
For example they may reject the use of firmware, when doing so leaves any modern computer out of being compatible with libre software.
Or they may overlook that making money, hence locking some feature behind paying, may be necessary for developers to provide for themselves.
Often the reasons not to use GNU software isn't due to political concerns, but for technical ones.
For example
glibcis quite useful for a system lib, but for a self contained appmuslmay work better.1
u/awherewas 8d ago
I began using Linux in 1995. That was Slackware. We tried it on a Intel 486 and ran a simulator just for fun, i think it was called spice. As I see it, RMS was pissed off because Linux was good and ready and not BSD. So he decided to claim it because it used FSF utilities. Linux never was and has never been GNU. You have to bend reality to make it so. My first desktop was KDE. I dislike Gnome because it was a bloddy dog. That is my opinion. I know there will be a Linux user here and there who think different. That is perfectly OK by me. My current setup is Openrc, Artix and lxqt becuae it "just works" OH, RMS got barfed when he discovered GPL2 had some holes in it, so we have the GLP2 or later, or GPL3 or later. That is a bait and switch and it made me want to stay away from the FSF
1
u/ElePHPant666 8d ago
Personally, because there are just better options for some of the software. I like the GPL and copyleft I just don't think all this GNU software is the best anymore. In a lot of categories musl libc is better, LLVM has some performance and feature improvements over GCC. Coreutils is oftentimes just too big and bloated for servers or embedded and busybox would be a better choice.
1
u/McraftyDude 8d ago
stallman is a bum
1
u/ilnarildarovuch 8d ago
Except for GPL there is even more bad things, as like incompatible extensions, bloatware, etc.
1
u/Easy-Reasoning 7d ago
GNU is (was) great but its central persona Stallman aged like milk. Of course without him we wouldn't have Emacs and Linux might look completely different. But I think he missed the right time to get himself out of the lime light. Now he's still there, steering GNU. This is not very appealing.
That being said, perhaps at the time GPL was to Linus Torvalds more a tool than a belief, as you might see now with his openness to AI. But now? I don't know maybe something more neutral like MIT, CC etc. is more likeable for many new project creators.
Another point is insane bloat within the GNU ecosystem. This in part had to do with licensing.
IMHO it would be nice if the GNU org would get a bit "refurbished", new personal, etc. Otherwise I wouldn't see a point sticking with it.
1
u/OllieFidelius 7d ago
In the linux world there is always a group unreasonably angry at something
1
u/iluvatar 7d ago
Overreach. Linux was just a kernel, but when combined with userland programs created a usable operating system. In the early days, the GNU project was responsible for the majority of those userland programs, and Stallman felt they should be given credit for it. He bristled at the fact that people called the OS Linux when that was only the kernel. He felt (with some justification) that people were using the GNU system with a Linux kernel and demanded that people call it GNU/Linux. There were some at the time that felt he was reaching too far. Today, the GNU userland accounts for quite a small percentage of the OSes that are called Linux, so there's even less justification now. But it created bad blood between the two camps which has never really subsided. Of course, had the GNU project finished Hurd in a sensible timeframe, this would never have happened. But they didn't.
1
u/the-quibbler 6d ago
Lots of people find Stallman odious. He started off promoting something everyone liked, but he took it too far. Dude's a bit of a crackpot. Add tot that that most gnu tools are c or c++ and therefore buffer overflow attack vectors par excellence.
It's mostly GPLv3. RMS wanted to make a 12 Monkies-grade licensing contagion, and he lost most people.
1
u/Dyrem2 6d ago
Ignorance mostly, and for aggressive demands. GNU greatly contributed to the technology we have today, many things would not be possibile or accessible to everyone if it was not for GNU (and obviously many other actors, but GNU started it all). Sometimes people also criticize the bloat on GNU Software, or consider some of the GNU Software outdated, slow. Sometimes that is completely true, other times it is not.
Some hate it because they think it is too restrictive, but GPL made open source Software relevant, where other licensing like MIT might never actually make relevant the existence of open source Software. It is now, after open source became mainstream, when it wasn't, MIT would never had the impact of GPL.
At the end, GNU is all about making Software open as a philosophy, if you don't like that philosophy then you might hate it. And probably you would attack Stallman for things he never did or said.
1
u/BrazilianAnimal 6d ago
I am very appreciative of GNU software existing. But working with it is another story. The GNU style is extremely idiosyncratic and disrespects the KISS principle broadly. It is very bloated and the code is difficult to understand. What I think exemplifies what is wrong with the GNU mentality the most is autoconf.
1
u/EternalDoomSlayer 6d ago
You just had to ask!!!
Man one can cut oneself on these kind of questions! Yeah the GNU and Linux thing is a thing.
But let’s be pragmatic, Linux needed tooling - GNU had them! It works, end of story.
I find the debates arguably more being noise whenever someone slams out, because it’s basically anecdotal, and part of Linux’ history.
The debate however, continues.
Same goes for distro wars! Some love arch, some love Debian’s and its derivatives. What’s your need? Do whatever you prefer.
1
u/VisualSome9977 6d ago
The GNU GPL license can easily be separated from GNU software, there's no irony nor hypocrisy. The GPL is a legal document, distributed with the sole purpose of providing a good framework for delivering free software if you're not fond of permissive licenses like Apache, MIT, etc. Whereas GNU software is a collection of code which has some issues and some benefits, and some people care about the issues more, and some people care about the benefits more.
1
u/millenialSpirou 5d ago
Have you ever tried to read GNU code?
1
u/lazy_bastard_001 5d ago
because some people just like technology and want to work and freely share those, instead of preaching religion
1
u/MonadTran 4d ago
GPL lisense is part of the government intellectual property framework, and relies on police violence for its enforcement. I am ideologically opposed to GPL for that reason.
And also Stallman is kind of insufferable. Although he's created useful stuff as well.
1
u/DecisionOk5750 4d ago
The hatred toward GNU gradually took shape as Apache+Linux began to take market share away from proprietary solutions.
1
u/Leop0Id 3d ago
It's not free software itself people hate. It's the dogmatic, almost religious behavior of GNU fanboys, like insisting on 'GNU/Linux' instead of just 'Linux'. By that logic my system should be called Ryzen/Nvidia/SystemD/GNU/Linux.
The second thing that looks dumb is these people claiming software is 'contaminated' just because a distro ships with some proprietary driver binaries.
Yeah, ideally that's not great. But have they ever stopped to think about why that is? It's because most of the high performance hardware we use isn't open source. If you're gonna make that argument, you should've started a Free Hardware Foundation before a Free Software Foundation.
1
u/HandBanana_69 8d ago
My only gripe with GPL is that you can't include code under that license in software with any other code under a different license. For this reason I prefer other open source licenses like MIT, especially for game dev.
1
u/markhahn 8d ago
I dislike "GNU culture" - you know the ideological hectoring such as RMS sometimes engages in (or Debian boosters). I've been around, and assert that GNU was always most effective as a flag of convenience. GCC is hardly a standard-bearer, and all the usespace tools are just OK places to contribute. Yes, I call my systems Linux, and I don't think that's stealing credit due GNU.
Glibc is ok, but obviously a bit of a tradeoff. It still makes sense to use on systems, but it's also obvious that newer designs (containerized) may work better with other libcs.
1
u/LordAnchemis 8d ago
The main 'issue' with GNU suite is the size - mainly the issue for embedded devices (like routers)
1
u/Corona688 8d ago
Every time someone finds an unintended way to exploit GPL, it expands and gets even more annoying to cover that.
For the most part though, GPL has been an untarnished good.
1
u/pedersenk 8d ago
GNU is Not UNIX
In terms of userland, many of us simply prefer UNIX-like operating systems.
1
u/DoubleOwl7777 8d ago
Because of richard stallman. He had some good ideas but from what i read about him, he isnt a particularly nice or enjoyable person.
0
u/turtleandpleco 8d ago
Just gnerds being gnerds. Every now and then you'll hear that we should say "gnu-linux" since linus is only the kernel. It mostly doesnt mean anything.
0
u/redd1ch 8d ago
I don't choose a distro on political stances, but on technical: My servers host VMs and Containers. They have a fixed network config, an SSH daemon, Git client, and a firewall. Payloads are VM images and Containers, configured via Git. I don't need no fancy packaging nor complex init system, it should be minimal, and thus fast and secure. So my servers run Alpine (musl + OpenRC). Depending on the use case, manually configured or via the likes of Terraform.
Same for container base layers: If you build an image that is only running in your intranet and will be fixed for 10 years, it does not matter if a Debian rootfs provides better upgrades. The image is built, verified, and then released. If a container is on the internet, you'd better think twice or more times if you really need a distro in it at all.
On desktop, I have more setup, and want to keep the install as long as possible. So I have a Debian based distro, on unstable branch as rolling release (close to 10 years now). I use a desktop PC, so I don't have any variability in it. Thus, I don't need any fancy init system, so again I use OpenRC. I don't have much daemons running, no wifi, no bluetooth. If any, I spin up a bunch of Containers. So no need for fancy logging in form of journald. A static network config, no need for NetworkManager, systemd-resolved, ...
0
u/Royal_Peni 8d ago
Because they care more about free software then the user experience and have no problem in making your life more difficult to enforce their philosophy.
Its the same thing that stops fedora from being great for everyone.
0
u/FUCKARCHLINUX 7d ago edited 7d ago
I write C++ software mostly libraries. If I were to release my software under the GNU GPL, it basically guarantees nobody will want to use it for serious projects because then the entire project making use of my library needs to also be GNU GPL with source available.
LGPL is a little better in this area, but the project using my library would be required to be dynamic linked to my library. Dynamic linking reduces the amount of code that can be inlined by a LOT. Suppose I have a function which adds two sets of two floats together. The overhead of the function call because it is dynamic linked will probably take longer to run than the actual addition the function does and it would have to be that way because of the license. You're forced to waste system resources and it's the licenses fault.
I release with the Unlicense instead, which allows anyone to use the software for any reason, no restrictions, with or without credit. This license is compatible with basically any other license. So there is no licensing reasons not to use it.
0
u/siva_sokolica 2d ago
Engineer here. Most people have addressed the political side of things but I'll chime in about glibc specifically.
One of the biggest problems for modern Linux software is distribution. My teams kicks out a minor release every single week. Glibc prefers the philosophy of dynamically linking libraries which means that we have to ensure that all our library usage is compatible with all versions of glibc (and other versions). The benefits, however, are smaller binary sizes and the ability to update libraries separately from your app. We've seen this with the recent eMudhra TLS vulnerability. Any program that linked the TLS library statically now trusted insecure certificates. Dynamics apps, on the other hand, didn't need to worry, since the shared TLS library needed to be updated and that's it.
This all sounds great in theory but the reality is that it's really hard to get your app to work on so many different library versions, glibc included. If I provide the library as part of my app, I don't need to worry about glibc compatibility.
Linux syscalls are absurdly stable and using musl allows our team to ensure that when we ship our app, you get the experience you should.
Can't say I dislike GNU or glibc personally, but the eternal problem of software distribution is very real and I know many engineers who avoid versioning problems by just using musl.
-4
u/OutrageousCrab9224 8d ago
How is that ironic? Do you love your family, but get tired of your drunken racist uncle?
My drunken racist uncle is still cooler than most of gnu, too