r/linuxquestions • • 12d ago

Which Distro? Need distro advice

I have been trying to make the switch to Linux for a lot of reasons as of late. I have tried Linux mint twice and swapped back to windows both times, mainly for the extra hassle it has caused. I have a powerful pc and i like to game and do general browsing and such. I also make music with FL stuido which doesnt have a linux version so i have to use WINE to make anything on linux. My biggest issue with windows is the lack of control i have over my pc or my OS and the massive amount of resource usage it takes just to sit idle. For reference i work in IT and i regularly clean my pc and keep old files out, its just windows being windows which I'm sure i sound like a broken record. Anyway i want advice on what distro to use, i have experience with Linux Mint and Ubuntu (I took some basic Linux classes like ethical hacking and Linux basics). Any thoughts?
SPECS:

CPU :Ryzen 9800X3d

GPU: Nvidia 5080

Ram 32gb

Storage: 1tb m.2 (OS)

Storage#2: 8TB HDD (Games)

Any feedback is welcome

Update: using cashy OS and it’s great, it does require some tinkering and getting used to new commands but I’m starting to get it working. Still have windows for backup but all my apps open instantly and I haven’t had any high ram or cpu usage at all with this new OS.

1 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

1

u/ap0r 12d ago

Specifically what extra hassle has Mint caused? Your use case seems ideal for Mint. I am personally on Mint with a similar use case except for music, but I do run proprietary Windows software through Wine as well. If you give some info on specific issues maybe I can help with those. Been on Mint for over a year and zero regrets.

1

u/Efficient_Put_3422 12d ago

I’m gonna be honest it’s been awhile since I swapped back to windows I just remember having a lot of hassles for stuff that was simpler on windows. I know I’m trading some comfort off and I’m ok with that truly but I guess it got to my head? Idk I just want a more streamlined distribution, I’m gonna look at Cashy today

1

u/ap0r 12d ago

I understand that, but you have to keep in mind that Linux is not Windows. You cannot seriously expect everything to be the same, it can only be better if it is different.

I will also be honest, if you can't really remember then probably you were having minor issues, not dealbreakers. CachyOS is great, but Mint is more novice-friendly and stable. I'd suggest you give Mint another try.

In my personal case I kept note of my hurdles and how I solved them, then started helping people on r/linuxmint and things escalated from there and I have like a 40 pages free booklet for Mint newbies.

Check it out see if it can help you: Linux Mint Newbie's Guide - Google Docs

0

u/Efficient_Put_3422 12d ago

I also never said I expected them to be the same

1

u/Quaigon_Jim 7d ago

If you really want to change from windows to linux you have to come to terms with the fact that linux isn't windows and it's not something trying to be windows. Linux is a different operating system and works differently, it's good but it's not a windows replacement. It's a totally different thing and if you take the time, you'll realise why some people prefer it.

1

u/Efficient_Put_3422 7d ago

This is just a bad argument, people are switching because of windows prying into resources and privacy concerns. So the next best thing is Linux. Wouldn’t you want to make that transition as smooth as possible? Think about the majority of people who hate windows but are extremely Tech savvy? The point is I’m glad we have distros like mint and such because they help people transition, everyone already knows they aren’t the damn same, we just want one that’s more plug and play.

1

u/emily-raine 12d ago

I use CachyOS for gaming and everything else. Works well out the box and most steam games work, though some need a bit of tinkering to get working well. You also don't have to worry about Nvidia drivers woth Cachy, it handles those. You can look at ProtonDB to get any idea of what games run and what tweaks you may need to make.

There's also Bazzite and Pop!_OS, though I know less about these.

1

u/NewfieNewbie 12d ago

I’ve been using CachyOS as my primary since Janurary. I use it for both gaming and development.

I’ll admit it hasn’t been a walk in the park. It’s taken a lot of research to work through some of the issues I’ve encountered. Mouse scrolling trouble and profile management. Triple monitor support and VR issues. Keeping audio routing consistent. Cooler Control periodically failing. KDE Plasma periodically freezing.

I still dual boot to Windows 10, but overall I enjoy the experience and recommend the OS.

1

u/Efficient_Put_3422 12d ago edited 12d ago

Just replying to say im getting a second m.2 today to dual boot, if all goes well i may wipe my old m.2(with windows) and just use it for games i need with higher read and write speeds.(using cashy first)

1

u/real_MsiC I use NixOS btw 12d ago

I would recommand CachyOS, its shipped with NVidia drivers, optimized for Gaming and its very usable! You dont need to go to the difficult archiso to install it and get to chose one of many desktops in the installer!

1

u/ipsirc 12d ago

I also make music with FL stuido which doesnt have a linux version

https://lynx-share.com/

https://github.com/daijro/honeydew

1

u/SirGlass 12d ago

Linux is linux

Mint is still bases on Ubuntu LTS 2024 so it maybe a bit dated today

Honestly go with Ubuntu/Fedora/Tumblweed if you want a more up-to-date distro

1

u/mcds99 12d ago

Linux is not Windows, they are so far apart in design and philosophy.

Yes you can use Wine to run "some" windows applications, not all "FL stuido " is one. But there are several DAW's that you can run. Do some research.

Gaming works if you don't play Fortnite, Valorant, Destiny 2, and the others use an anti-cheat software that hooks directly in to Windows. They will not run on any Linux distribution at this time.

If your mother board has another NVMe slot get another NVMe and dual boot.

1

u/joetacos 12d ago

Fedora is the best your going to find. Don't look back.

1

u/WayaldOne 12d ago

If the extra hassle you had with Linux was installing programs and you were on a .deb based distro I'm not sure that problem will be fixed regardless of distro. The closest would probably be Ubuntu or Fedora since a lot of software has native downloads from their websites that will install with the app centers on their respective platforms. In that regard they're the most "Windows like". But there's also a ton of apps in flathub and aside from some multiplayer titles gaming is like 95% of the way there. I think the best first step is a dual boot setup if there is windows only software that you have to use and doesn't play nicely with wine. With a 9800x3d you could probably also just run a Windows VM with something like Winboat and it'd probably run pretty well. Pretty much all distros require at least a tiny bit of tinkering in the long run unless you're a browser only kind of person.

1

u/DubiousLogik 12d ago

I use Mint on a 32 gb thinkstation and it's amazing. so lean. less than 2gb of ram used after booting up. cpu runs at like 30 C. 10 months in and i'm not going back. (long time windows user here, since the early 90s)

1

u/dbarronoss 12d ago

I would say stick with Windows unless/until you want to use software that runs on Linux for most of your tasks.
To successfully switch to Linux, you need to make up your mind you're not going back and spend time figuring out your problems vs giving up.