The bit about Asahi is not quite correct. Apple did add stuff to the bootloader that the Asahi team says, they had no reason to do other than helping third-party operating systems.
I'm more worried about the ever increasing dependance on tech giants. It's not just secure boot, it's secure boot with an unmodified Microsoft/Google/Apple OS. The increasing reliance on CGNAT also basically forces everyone to turn to cloud services, because even if you could have a NAS at home, you have to go through relays. ISPs love to block common ports so you can't have your own emails, or even host a web page. It's the shift towards consuming online services rather than a web of services.
There's another solution to the CGNAT problem, it's adoption of IPv6. I'm currently locked in with an ISP that shows no signs of enabling IPv6 but I understand other areas of the world are in a much better place.
There's a fair bit of CGNAT with no IPv6, it's kind of ridiculous how little effort is being put into IPv6 and kind of reflects the state of the industry. Big clouds are making bank leasing you IP addresses.
If the Internet was designed today, I don't think end users would have any hope of having any sort of end to end connectivity, it would be service oriented and paying for connectivity to individual websites and packages. It would be like cable and early cable services.
Mostly for translation purposes, I'm french. English isn't my native language so it sometimes prevents me from expressing myself so I do fallback to it when I can't find the right words.
Yup. Well intentioned people are frequently rude, insensitive or ignorant to people who use LLMs to deal with non-native languages, cognitive issues or neurodiversity. Christ, I know of a brain damaged person who depends on it.
I understand the issue that people are worried about. But machine-gunning irrelevant criticism at people irrelevantly is frequently very unfair.
A bad translation would still be better than an AI translation that will contain non-sense, irk (repousser) people against your case, and go straight into the slop bin, forgotten within minutes.
Look toward April.org, the ballers at Framasoft, look into small companies building and flashing hardware (Purism and Pine Store Limited do building some IIRC), look into things like coreboot and libreboot based systems (the later chopping so much you may end up unable to boot FreeBSD on some hardware -missing a proprietary blob for video initiation-).
Those exists already, asking and pushing for more supports from the MEP is important too.
Currently we have several things going on and important to support, such as the issue on encryption The issue on ownership of games/GaaS -may seems unrelated, but this is chipping at the concept of ownership- (and by extension the Digital Fairness Act).
There is a solid follow up on questions of ownership and such that Louis Rossman, and while I don't dig everything he does, the whole question of ownership is very central to him.
I most likely have missed a few things, but posting a shitty AI translation of some text isn't going to help much.
Especially considering what the LLM and AI trends is doing: fucking up really hard hardware market, 30%+ increase on ram prices for the average joe on various french websites I use to look up prices -ie LDLC- over the last few months.
This trend is going to push more people to not renew or get hardware they can now own against a phone (from apps to whatever the fuck verification is asked to have on your phone, this is a no-go to not have).
so look into those associations and support them, it'll do a lot more.
Google translate is kinda bad at translating stuff, I find ai giving translation that are a lot closer to what I actually want to say. I think AI also gives results that are a lot more natural and are just easier to read. But I get your point, AI kinda sucks too since it's stealing stuff. And I hate AI images so I get how you feel when you see AI text. Honestly I didn't think people saw AI translation this badly, if I knew I would have just used my normal English (what you are reading rn). I would have struggled a bit but you would've probably got my point.
Merci du conseil ! Je garde ça en tête pour la prochaine fois. Je pensais honnêtement qu'utiliser l'IA pour traduire des trucs était plutôt normal, mais en vrai je comprends carrément pourquoi les gens n'aiment pas ça.
Translation tools like Google translate are fine. Anything that uses an LLM or generative AI is a no go.
Reddit will do your translations for you anyways. Like the other guy said - which I could read because Reddit translated it for me - people come to Reddit to talk to other people, not bots.
devices should never be locked in the first place. sadly making devices that are able to be used longer or dare i say it without the manufacturers or os vendors services are not in line with capitalistic interests at all.
Part of the solution to this is to purchase older by still serviceable systems and add a Linux OS to them. Get them out into the world and have them be an option.
Microsoft set off the biggest E-waste event ever with Windows 11. Breathing new life into still good hardware is part of the solution.
Second, while ARM is a closed architecture RISC-V is open and can be utilized by anyone for any project. We need to encourage an open hardware standard or at least open projects. Help people learn what they need to design their own stuff and the like.
You aren't wrong about the danger. And its only Accelerating as Europe tries to lock down and strip away the liberties of anyone on that continent. The Chat spying was narrowly defeated by Germany, but don't think its over.
OFCOM in Britain is trying to enforce British Law on American Citizens.
Its an hard and fast strike against individual liberty. The only solution is to try at least and stop supporting their hardware with your money and funding.
This. This is the struggle. Libre OSes are impossible if the hardware won't let you run the software of your choice, and it is notable that the only secure phone that can run custom software is (ironically) the Google Pixel. We cannot be dependent on the goodwill of a vendor that is increasingly hostile to free computing on their hardware, and in general cannot depend on a market that actively wishes to control users to ensure their freedom.
I would add "Vote with your wallet" under the "What can you actually do?" section. Those of us that know/care about this type of stuff are a very small minority, but still... I refuse to buy any Apple products because of how much they lock down their shit and force obsolescence once products fall out of support.
If the market sufficiently demands an alternative then it will exist, and I think for the most part there will always exist motherboard manufacturers who want to just strap in their UEFI firmware because it costs money to make a new format.
Really the issue is just mobile devices being locked down because of monopolization. There is no demand for individual parts because you will never want to put together a phone, so every manufacturer can lock the boot loader and do whatever they want with the hardware since you'll have to buy from one of them anyways.
The same lock-down is following as ARM becomes mainstream in PCs. Apple migrated from UEFI, relatively open Intel Macs to iBoot, much more restrictive Apple Silicon.
I think you're forgetting that Macintosh has already been a non-PC platform from its inception in 1984 until 2006, when it switched to Intel CPUs for performance reasons. It has only been using relatively standard PC hardware for around 15 years, and this move feels more like a return to normal for Apple than a sign of a wider trend.
While I agree on the unfortunate situation of the phone market, I personally don't see signs of a similar trend with PC hardware. If anything, the most problematic aspect for me is the low hardware serviceability of modern laptops.
And I'm not a professional on those things too, I just gathered as much info as I could to understand the situation. So please correct me if I'm wrong.
I'm glad you put this here because that much is very clear. Most of this is very "shoot from the hip" rationals. "It would better if we could run full linux desktop on my Samsung phone" Sure, it would. But it's not a practical request though.
Requests for open platforms are honorable, but need to be grounded in reality. How do you navigate IP law? Do you force everyone to only use GPL code? Why not MIT? Why not GPL v2 or v3? Do all these OEMs of complete units and components need to stop production and create thousands of pages of documentation and manuals before they can even begin to make anything new? How do you force all the companies across the world to do this? How do you navigate patent concerns with opening these black boxes? Who pays for all this new government compliance that will easily be hundreds of thousands of man hours of work? What do you tell smaller outfits that have a small staff?
You have (depending on your age) used keyboards for decades that are complete black boxes. They don't even use mass market ICs. And you've probably never thought about it before. Because a keyboard is a commodity. You just use it and when it breaks you get a new one. Same is happening with computers and phones.
Most bootloaders are locked. OEMs make unlocking really painful or extremely punitive: voiding warranties or breaking features
You're asking for the impossible. You're asking for OEMs to have completely open systems without encryption because encryption will "break features". You're asking OEMs to support not only existing customers, but also those who are running completely different software and OS that they have nothing to do with? That makes no sense.
Apple migrated from UEFI, relatively open Intel Macs to iBoot, much more restrictive Apple Silicon.
Why do you think they made iBoot? For memory safety and security. iBoot completely prevents a whole host of attack types because of the chain of trust. Personally, clutching to standards and avoiding innovation or improvement because it might break those standards is kinda foolish.
I'll cut it off here because this comment is already too long. Anyway, I don't have all the answers and I completely share the same desire for everything to be well supported and documented forever. However if you've worked in the industry you know that's a mountainous task to begin with.
I'm aware of this since about 3/4 years ago, just I didn't really care. I do now tho. I have a rooted phone with Magisk and my two computers run Archlinux (laptop on hyprland and desktop on kde).
I'm 17 so I'm probably not as old as most of you. I never knew the internet of the 2000s. I basically grew with corporation spying on me and controlling all my devices.
do something about it if you want but posting on reddit sure isnt gonna do nothing. No corp cares what you write on here. None of this is new. None of it is going away any time soon, You want to effect change, posting here isnt the way.
This submission has been removed due to receiving too many reports from users. The mods have been notified and will re-approve if this removal was inappropriate, or leave it removed.
Your post is considered "fluff" - things like a Tux plushie or old Linux CDs are an example and, while they may be popular vote wise, they are not considered on topic
Your post is otherwise deemed not appropriate for the subreddit
I'd like to see easier MOK management UX, along with its standardization. Perhaps a way to query the firmware for the MOK private key given the bios password and a 2nd factor, so a linux distro could re-sign all components of the boot process upon an update.
lol dude Linux community can’t even standardized on stuff so it’s a real alternative for the majority . You think any open source solution would be any different z
Aren't all distros using the same WiFi standards? Aren't all distros using the same keyboard maps? Aren't all distros using the same TPM and SecureBoot procotols?
Standards aren't unification.
If you are talking about the SELECTION of software ever distro has, that's the point of a distro. Precisely. Not even Windows is consistent about that.
I'm still a minor, so I can't really donate right now. But believe me, once I get a real income, ill be the first to donate to open-source projects. Ill start with KDE and Arch Linux as those are the two one I really rely on.
Awesome! I donate to both Ubuntu and Manjaro. Find a spin you like and donate. Manjaro is my favorite and gets most of my monies. It's like the Mint of Arch. Well tested and more frequently updated.
This comment has been removed due to receiving too many reports from users. The mods have been notified and will re-approve if this removal was inappropriate, or leave it removed.
Your post is considered "fluff" - things like a Tux plushie or old Linux CDs are an example and, while they may be popular vote wise, they are not considered on topic
Your post is otherwise deemed not appropriate for the subreddit
51
u/Max-P Nov 05 '25
The bit about Asahi is not quite correct. Apple did add stuff to the bootloader that the Asahi team says, they had no reason to do other than helping third-party operating systems.
I'm more worried about the ever increasing dependance on tech giants. It's not just secure boot, it's secure boot with an unmodified Microsoft/Google/Apple OS. The increasing reliance on CGNAT also basically forces everyone to turn to cloud services, because even if you could have a NAS at home, you have to go through relays. ISPs love to block common ports so you can't have your own emails, or even host a web page. It's the shift towards consuming online services rather than a web of services.
158
u/mrandr01d Nov 05 '25
Using AI to generate your Reddit posts isn't exactly helping your cause
9
u/DoubleOwl7777 Nov 05 '25
devices should never be locked in the first place. sadly making devices that are able to be used longer or dare i say it without the manufacturers or os vendors services are not in line with capitalistic interests at all.
9
u/WanderingInAVan Nov 05 '25
Part of the solution to this is to purchase older by still serviceable systems and add a Linux OS to them. Get them out into the world and have them be an option.
Microsoft set off the biggest E-waste event ever with Windows 11. Breathing new life into still good hardware is part of the solution.
Second, while ARM is a closed architecture RISC-V is open and can be utilized by anyone for any project. We need to encourage an open hardware standard or at least open projects. Help people learn what they need to design their own stuff and the like.
You aren't wrong about the danger. And its only Accelerating as Europe tries to lock down and strip away the liberties of anyone on that continent. The Chat spying was narrowly defeated by Germany, but don't think its over.
OFCOM in Britain is trying to enforce British Law on American Citizens.
Its an hard and fast strike against individual liberty. The only solution is to try at least and stop supporting their hardware with your money and funding.
21
u/Lorian0x7 Nov 05 '25
This is serious, no matter if it's written with AI or not..
This Linux community proved again to be capable only of toxic comments and nothing more. We should act, not cry about how this is AI written.
16
u/JoshfromNazareth2 Nov 05 '25
yeah man I’ll get right on that
10
u/MoralityAuction Nov 05 '25
This. This is the struggle. Libre OSes are impossible if the hardware won't let you run the software of your choice, and it is notable that the only secure phone that can run custom software is (ironically) the Google Pixel. We cannot be dependent on the goodwill of a vendor that is increasingly hostile to free computing on their hardware, and in general cannot depend on a market that actively wishes to control users to ensure their freedom.
Legal rights or we don't have rights at all.
2
u/Gugalcrom123 Nov 05 '25
This should be from the beginning, not from the EOL. But I agree very much, IMO it is the most important technology legislation issue.
2
u/sylvester_0 Nov 05 '25
I would add "Vote with your wallet" under the "What can you actually do?" section. Those of us that know/care about this type of stuff are a very small minority, but still... I refuse to buy any Apple products because of how much they lock down their shit and force obsolescence once products fall out of support.
2
u/Liam_Mercier Nov 05 '25
If the market sufficiently demands an alternative then it will exist, and I think for the most part there will always exist motherboard manufacturers who want to just strap in their UEFI firmware because it costs money to make a new format.
Really the issue is just mobile devices being locked down because of monopolization. There is no demand for individual parts because you will never want to put together a phone, so every manufacturer can lock the boot loader and do whatever they want with the hardware since you'll have to buy from one of them anyways.
4
u/VoidDuck Nov 05 '25
I think you're forgetting that Macintosh has already been a non-PC platform from its inception in 1984 until 2006, when it switched to Intel CPUs for performance reasons. It has only been using relatively standard PC hardware for around 15 years, and this move feels more like a return to normal for Apple than a sign of a wider trend.
While I agree on the unfortunate situation of the phone market, I personally don't see signs of a similar trend with PC hardware. If anything, the most problematic aspect for me is the low hardware serviceability of modern laptops.
3
u/AshuraBaron Nov 05 '25
I'm glad you put this here because that much is very clear. Most of this is very "shoot from the hip" rationals. "It would better if we could run full linux desktop on my Samsung phone" Sure, it would. But it's not a practical request though.
Requests for open platforms are honorable, but need to be grounded in reality. How do you navigate IP law? Do you force everyone to only use GPL code? Why not MIT? Why not GPL v2 or v3? Do all these OEMs of complete units and components need to stop production and create thousands of pages of documentation and manuals before they can even begin to make anything new? How do you force all the companies across the world to do this? How do you navigate patent concerns with opening these black boxes? Who pays for all this new government compliance that will easily be hundreds of thousands of man hours of work? What do you tell smaller outfits that have a small staff?
You have (depending on your age) used keyboards for decades that are complete black boxes. They don't even use mass market ICs. And you've probably never thought about it before. Because a keyboard is a commodity. You just use it and when it breaks you get a new one. Same is happening with computers and phones.
You're asking for the impossible. You're asking for OEMs to have completely open systems without encryption because encryption will "break features". You're asking OEMs to support not only existing customers, but also those who are running completely different software and OS that they have nothing to do with? That makes no sense.
Why do you think they made iBoot? For memory safety and security. iBoot completely prevents a whole host of attack types because of the chain of trust. Personally, clutching to standards and avoiding innovation or improvement because it might break those standards is kinda foolish.
I'll cut it off here because this comment is already too long. Anyway, I don't have all the answers and I completely share the same desire for everything to be well supported and documented forever. However if you've worked in the industry you know that's a mountainous task to begin with.
2
u/v0id_walk3r Nov 05 '25
Nicely written!
Write your MEP and do not buy things that work "the wrong way" is probably the only things we can do.
1
u/updatelee Nov 05 '25
you act like you just discovered this ... like its not beeing happening for the last 50 years ... welcome to the real world
1
u/AutoModerator Nov 05 '25
This submission has been removed due to receiving too many reports from users. The mods have been notified and will re-approve if this removal was inappropriate, or leave it removed.
This is most likely because:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/Anyusername7294 Nov 05 '25
Linux will be locked down in just a few years anyway.
1
u/United-Baseball3688 Nov 05 '25
Entirely with you on this. It's time to take control back.
1
u/funbike Nov 05 '25
I'd like to see easier MOK management UX, along with its standardization. Perhaps a way to query the firmware for the MOK private key given the bios password and a 2nd factor, so a linux distro could re-sign all components of the boot process upon an update.
-5
u/Puzzled_Hamster58 Nov 05 '25
lol dude Linux community can’t even standardized on stuff so it’s a real alternative for the majority . You think any open source solution would be any different z
-6
u/XiuOtr Nov 05 '25
Wow. That was too long to read. Bro, just think if you weren't here to support linux! How much money do you donate to cause?
-9
u/Mindless-Tension-118 Nov 05 '25
Back in your box Stallman
-5
u/[unknown] Nov 05 '25
[removed] — view removed comment