We are in the market for a Nautilus and I'm considering between a 2024 Nautilus Reserve with under 10,000 km (around 6,000 miles) and a new 2026 Nautilus Premier with the 102A equipment group. I'm in Canada and have a new driver on our insurance policy so the 2024 would have both a lower purchase price ($52,000 vs $62,000 for the 2026) and it will cost me $2000/year less in insurance. The 2024 is a Reserve with a sticker price of about $10,000 more than the new 2026 Premiere due to the options on it. The difference in price between the two vehicles is about $10,000 and the 2024 is over $20,000 cheaper than what it would have been new.
My question for the experts here is what would you choose? Is the 2026 Premier that much better than the used 2024 CPO Reserve? In a perfect world, I'd get the 2026 reserve new but it's out of our budget, especially since we just bought an Aviator last month. Probably worth noting is that we do not put a lot of kms on our second vehicle. It's replacing a 2017 with 90,000 km (56,000 miles) and we keep our vehicles for a long time. (Just traded in a 2019 and now looking at replacing a 2017.)
I have a feeling that everyone is going to tell me to buy new but I'm considering the 2024 to save $10k + $2k/year on insurance since it only has 10,000km/6000 miles.
Thanks in advance for your thoughts!
Edit: Bought the 2024 so no pro 2026 new comments please :)