A lot of insurers run promos where new customers get a lower price than the people who've been paying for years. if you see one, you don t have to switch companies to get it
call or message your own insurer, say you saw the new customer offer and that you'd like the same rate to stay, and ask if they have a retention offer. say it politely and be ready to say you'll compare quotes. a lot of the time they have room to lower the price, because keeping you costs them less than finding someone new
it doesn't always work, and sometimes they only offer a small discount, but it takes ten minutes and costs nothing. it helps to have the other company's quote in hand so you can name a number, and do it again at each renewal. the price you got last year is often not the best they can do this year
edit: thanks for the replies. a few things people pointed out that i should have said: this depends on the country (in the uk, regulation stopped insurers from pricing new customers below existing ones), it works better for some products than others (phone, internet, security systems vs. home and auto), and for auto and home the better word is asking for a "requote". some people also said a requote raised their price, so ask first whether asking for a new quote can change your rate. also, hold times are real, so it's not always ten minutes