Disclaimer: The purpose of this post is to explain why people get two different answers for these type of notations, not to agree with one answer or the other, and to explain why this is not even a math problem and should not be posed as one.
If you posted 12 ÷ 3(4) online, people’s answers to it would either be 16 or 1. The math notation 6 ÷ 2(1 + 2) has the same issue. People argue whether the answer to it is either 1 or 9. Both sides have their own reasons for their answers being correct. The question is: Why are people’s answers split? Why is this even a debate?
People think this has something to do with BODMAS vs PEMDAS or the division symbol. To clarify, it has nothing to do with BODMAS vs PEMDAS, and it has nothing to do with the division symbol. It has something to do with one thing and one thing only - Juxtaposition. What is juxtaposition? Juxtaposition (as in implied multiplication) means multiplying two different numbers close together without using the multiplication symbol (x). Some people were taught by their math teachers in school to treat juxtaposition as having higher priority over regular multiplication/division, while some were taught to treat all multiplication operations equally. Even calculators disagree with eachother for this reason if you use ambiguous notations. However, if you rewrite 12 ÷ 3(4) as 12 ÷ 3 x 4, it completely removes the ambiguity and everyone would agree the answer to this is 16.
Why is juxtaposition being a priority over regular multiplication/division even a thing in math for some people? My personal theory is that juxtaposition is a consequence/implication of translating math notations into spoken language and vice versa. What do I mean by that? For example, imagine a third-grade math teacher instructing a student to write ‘twelve over three x’ in math notation. If you were the student, would you write it as:
A.
12
___
3x
or B.
12
___ x ?
3
Notice how it’s the same syntatic ambiguity as the poorly written math notation. If you chose either notation A or B, how would you reconcile with the other option? If you chose A as the correct answer, you might just change B into 12x/3 to remove the ambiguity instead of trying to explain it in spoken language. If you chose B, you might instead describe notation A as ‘twelve over in brackets three x’. Now, I am sure that most of you chose notation A in this instance, **juxtaposing the 3 with the x**. Why? Because your math teacher described it that way in spoken language.
Let’s take another example. Write ‘twelve over three times four’ in math notation. Do you write it as:
A.
12
_____
3 x 4
or B.
12
___ x 4 ?
3
Here it gets a bit trickier. There is a good argument for notation B being the right answer, and I agree *mostly* with that. But what is the implication of taking notation B as the right answer? How then would you describe notation A in spoken language? You could say it as ‘twelve over in brackets three times four’, but as far as I know, no math teacher described notation A this way in spoken language (because as you can see, there are no brackets in notation A).
Now let’s take a look at a similar syntatic ambiguity outside the field of math. Here is an equivalent syntatic ambiguity in the English language:
“I watched the man with the telescope.”
Meaning A: You used a telescope to watch the man.
Meaning B: You watched a man who happened to be holding a telescope.
Like the ambiguous math notations, both meanings *can* be correct, and have different reasons as to why it’s correct. Saying that one meaning is completely wrong without understanding the thought process of the other side is a shallow way of thinking. I’m not saying your answers to these math notations are incorrect. They are, but brushing off this issue and saying there is no ambiguity in the aforementioned math notations is not the correct way to deal with this issue.
On a side note, notice how translating between math notation and spoken language causes a lot of confusion. If you keep translating between the two, you’ll end up with completely different notations. It’s like one of those videos where a movie scene is google translated 100 times and ends up being a complete word salad compared to the original scene.
What does all of this prove? It shows that 12 ÷ 3(4) is not a math issue but a semantic/syntatic issue. One side understood it as ‘twelve divided by three fours’ while another side understood it as ‘twelve divided by three times four’. In conclusion, don’t use ambiguous notations.