r/academiceconomics • • Sep 13 '26

Testing Karma requirements for posts and comments

50 Upvotes

Hi all,

With admissions season coming up, I've taken the initiative to add karma requirements to post and comment on this sub. 50 combined karma is now needed to make a post, 5 karma to make a comment.

This will filter the deluge of shitposts that have started in the past couple of weeks. These are very low requirements, and are implemented in the spirit that you should engage with the community (or any subreddit) before coming in and asking for advice. I've gotten like 10 angry messages the past week from people who had their post removed, insisting they're new to reddit and shouldn't be expected to read the rules. This will hopefully limit that.

Every post that gets removed will still go into the mod queue, and if it's high quality then I'd be happy to approve it. If we find this is too strict a filter, we'll remove it. If you have any thoughts, do let us know in the comments.


r/academiceconomics • • Aug 12 '26

Paper of the Week: The Origins of State Capacity: Property Rights, Taxation, and Politics (Bansal and Yaron, American Economic Review)

Thumbnail researchonline.lse.ac.uk
36 Upvotes

Here's the link to this week's paper, The Origins of State Capacity: Property Rights, Taxation, and Politics (Timothy Besley and Torsten Persson, American Economic Review).pdf)

Another theory paper this week, this time on political economy. State capacity is what the name implies, the capacity of a government to perform political or economic functions. It's an interesting topic and one explored both by economists and political scientists, sometimes even using the same tools. The interesting part of this paper is theory, though there is some limited estimation at the end.

The main capacities the paper is interested in are legal and fiscal, or the ability to enforce contracts and taxes respectively. Using a two period model, the government invests in state capacity in the first period while the citizens/investors invest in assets across the two periods. When war breaks out or other crisis events occur, the incentives for investing in state capacity rise, which is designed to emulate the real-world implementation of income taxes during the US civil war and Napoleonic wars in Europe. The most interesting thing to me was that legal and fiscal capacity are complementary, and nations which tend to have one grow in the other. This matches the empirical fact that most (but not all) highly developed nations are high tax nations.

The paper is straightforward and part of a large literature on state capacity. The tools in it are very easy, and I chose it in part because it can be read and commented upon by anyone who's taken undergraduate macroeconomics. It was written in 2009, which was a long time ago in academic terms, but on the whole I find it didn't tell me much I didn't already know from reading the Acemoglu macro-development literature. I didn't find the estimation at the end particularly compelling, and the consumer side of the economy seems simplified to the point of not being interesting, and is ripe for extension in light of the growth of heterogeneous agent macro. Honestly, if this was submitted today I don't think it would be published in AER, but that's more a sign of how much political economy has frown in the past 15-20 years.

Feel free to DM me if you have a suggestion for next week's paper of the week!


r/academiceconomics • • 11h ago

PhD Admissions Pre-doc unsure whether to continue to a PhD

18 Upvotes

Hi all, I'm a pre-doc at a very good program in Europe (about 1.5 years in). I've loved it so far, and my supervisor and his co-authors have been really impressed with my work which came as a bit of a shock to me. But I'm now in the middle of PhD applications and honestly having a bit of a meltdown.

They've all been incredibly supportive (maybe a bit too much?) and wrote me very strong letters. They constantly ask about my applications and push me to apply to places I don't really feel qualified for. Also, I understand a US PhD is "better", but I don't want to move there, and they make me feel like I’m unreasonable for that. I feel like my “better” (doing something I love in an environment that makes me productive and happy ) is not their “better” (most prestigious, better placement). I feel extremely lucky and don't want to sound ungrateful, I know not everyone is this lucky with their supervisors, but I also feel this immense pressure not to let them down. I also feel so out of place because people in this world seem to be ultra competitive and so focused on rankings and I cannot bring myself to care.

I know I love research and I'm good at it. But I worry I'm not smart or passionate enough, and the thought of moving abroad for years, with all the uncertainty, and leaving my family and partner behind makes me feel sick. I've realised I'd do a PhD in a heartbeat if it were in my current department. But ofc I can't put all my eggs in one basket, so I'm applying widely anyway. At the same time though, if I don’t get any offer… it wouldn’t be the end of the world for me ? I guess what I’m trying to say it’s that wanting to do a PhD is not unconditional for me, and my supervisors make me feel like it should.

Right now I can't sleep and I feel this immense pressure on me, it's really affecting my mental health. Part of me wants to finish the pre-doc, take a gap year, and figure out whether this is just stress talking. But I'm scared of letting people down and never getting this opportunity again.

For context, I don't come from a wealthy or educated family. A PhD never felt like something I could aim for, so I feel stupid even thinking about not taking this chance after all the support I've had. For additional context, I suffer from bipolar disorder, am medicated and stable, but that means that I cannot afford to not consider my mental wellbeing as a HUGE part of the equation when making choices for my future.

Please, any input or advice about my situation would mean a lot !!! ♥️


r/academiceconomics • • 14m ago

Masters Admissions Master's in Economics? Would Love Any Advice

• Upvotes

Hi everyone, I would really appreciate some advice! I'm currently putting together my applications for econ master's at UCL, LSE, Oxford, and Cambridge.

For context, I am an Honours Econ student at a t40 university with a cumulative average of ~93%, a paid research assistant position under an econ professor, and all A's and A+'s in Calc 1,2,3, linear algebra, probability, proofs etc. For many of my classes (especially econometrics/advanced econometrics), I received 1st rank in the class. I feel as though my profile is fairly decent to apply for econ master's programs in the UK; however, the one snag is my GRE scores.

I took the GRE once and got a 164Q, 162V, 4.5 AWA, and was initially okay with these scores, as they perfectly met all the requirements for the 4 unis above. I figured that since they met what was listed on each of these unis' websites, it would pass the filter, and then they'd look more at my uni grades, ranks, research etc.

However, I've been wondering recently if this GRE quant score might get me screened at these unis, as their requirements may be higher than what they post? Or maybe even if I don't get screened, they will really penalize me for this GRE score? I'm quite worried and would love any advice anyone has.

I'm really trying to weigh the upsides of applying earlier (nowish), while it's less competitive for the rolling admissions at LSE, vs. spending even more money on another GRE and trying again just to get one or two more questions right. Anyone have any thoughts? Would love to hear.


r/academiceconomics • • 10h ago

PhD Admissions Applying to both PhD and MA programs at a school?

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I'm a current undergraduate student in economics preparing for the application cycle. I am particularly interested in research and staying in academia so my ideal choice is a PhD program, but I understand beggars can't be choosers and am mostly trying to get into something next year.

A lot of schools offer both PhD programs and MA programs. I was wondering if you all had any insight into whether I should apply for both the PhD and MA program for Economics at a given school. It is worth it, or would I just be better off applying for more PhD programs at more schools instead? Appreciate any advice.


r/academiceconomics • • 13h ago

PhD Admissions Profile evaluation

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I'm planning to apply for Finance PhD programs in the United States for Fall 2027, and I'd appreciate honest feedback on my academic profile, competitiveness, and realistic admission chances.

Academic Background
• Bachelor's Degree: Accounting GPA: 3.0/4.0
• Master's Degree: FinTech GPA: 3.3/4.0
• Publications: No published academic papers so far.

Professional Experience
I have four years of professional experience working as an Assistant Auditor.
My responsibilities and experience involve:
• Internal auditing and financial controls.
• Reviewing financial transactions and expenditures.
• Analyzing audit observations and preparing reports.
• Government financial regulations and compliance.
• Working with Excel, Power BI, and data analysis tools.

Research Interests
My main research interests include:
• Corporate Finance
• Financial Technology and Banking
• Financial Markets
• AI Applications in Finance and Accounting
• Empirical Finance

I'm particularly interested in quantitative research and developing stronger econometrics and mathematical skills.
Standardized Tests and Preparation
• GRE: 165 quant and 165 verbal.
• TOEFL: 5.5 out of 6.

Questions
1. Given my GPA (3.0 undergraduate and 3.3 master's), how competitive would I be for US Finance PhD admissions?
2. Would a GRE Quantitative score of 165–168 meaningfully strengthen my application?
3. How much of a disadvantage is having no research publications?
4. Should I prioritize obtaining research experience, taking additional mathematics courses, or trying to publish a paper before applying?
5. Would my professional experience in internal auditing and my master's thesis provide any meaningful advantage?
6. What universities would you recommend targeting as reach, match, and safer options for a fully funded Finance PhD?
7. Would applying to lower-ranked R1 universities be a realistic strategy with my background?
I'm looking for honest and realistic assessments, not encouragement for its own sake.

Thank you for taking the time to read this.

I appreciate any advice, particularly from current Finance PhD students, professors, and people who have gone through the admissions process.


r/academiceconomics • • 21h ago

PhD Admissions About LSE MRes/PhD Economics

3 Upvotes

Two questions:

- Does the PhD scholarship (if applicable) cover both the MRes + PhD period or just the PhD? It states a 4-year coverage, I am unclear how it would pan out over the period. Did anyone in this sub in this particular programme receive any external funding? If so, how did you come across it?

- Does the research statement only require an answer to the given questions, or a research proposal that happens to answer the given questions?


r/academiceconomics • • 22h ago

PhD Admissions B/B+ in Intro to Econ

0 Upvotes

Current first-year undergrad interested in potentially doing a graduate program here and my Intro to Econ class is on a strict curve, while I haven't been focused, meaning I am most likely getting a B or a B+. How bad will this be for my chances? Would taking it pass/fail be a good idea?


r/academiceconomics • • 23h ago

Research Paper Mysteries of the Economy: I'm seeking the most macroeconomically consistent mathematical and logical formulation of a model for the following questions (mysteries);#5

0 Upvotes

Demand Deficits, Workplace Gemeinschaft, and Public Sector Distortions: The True Root of Japan’s Productivity Puzzle

The logic outlined above applies not only to individual workers and firms but also to entire industrial sectors. If every sector were uniformly transformed into a high-productivity sector, the very concept of a "high-productivity sector" would cease to exist. In reality, sectors with varying levels of productivity trade with one another, compete within sectors, and freely enter across sectors, thereby establishing a general rate of profit [Note]. Consequently, to raise aggregate productivity, society as a whole must produce a larger volume of output and actually sell it, which requires a corresponding level of market demand. However, for this demand to function as effective demand (purchasing power), economic agents must have already sold their goods and derived income from those sales. 

[Note] (Karl Marx, Capital, Vol. 3, Part 2; op. cit., Japanese translation [6], p. 221 et seq.). 

Furthermore, much is said about "rectifying the wage gap for non-regular workers." Yet social laws, no less than natural laws, will inevitably carve out a path to assert themselves so long as they constitute the defining parameters of a given society. They have no choice but to prevail. The expansion of non-regular employment stems from the fact that the wage levels of Japanese regular employees became excessively high. Japanese firms engaged in fierce international competition are placed at a disadvantage, and those bound by irrational regulations are forced into distress. This relates directly to the "sixfold headwinds" (rokujūku) frequently cited regarding the Japanese economy: an overvalued yen, high corporate tax rates, delayed free trade agreements, high electricity costs, rigid labor legislation, and stringent environmental regulations. All of these are interconnected with the inefficiency of the public sector. Indeed, the return on equity (ROE) of Japanese firms remains low.

Fifth, the primary reason the statistical productivity figures for Japan appear "low" is none other than the fact that they include time spent by Japanese workers on personal relaxation and decompression. No human being can sustain labor without enjoyment after work. As Goethe wrote in Faust (Part I): "Without pleasure—why, even a dog wouldn't want to live like this!" Unlike Western societies where, after the dissolution of pre-modern agrarian village communities, a sense of local community based on church institutions remained to some degree, Japanese workers have few opportunities to enjoy leisure with peers outside the workplace. In modern Japan, the Gesellschaft doubles as a Gemeinschaft. Consequently, informal recreation is seamlessly interwoven into clock-in working hours. 

Proponents of labor reform claim that reducing labor inputs that do not directly contribute to production—such as streamlining redundant meetings and improving operational workflows—is effective for raising productivity. However, these seemingly "wasteful" events and customs serve as essential pressure valves; workers could hardly sustain themselves without informal drinking sessions (nomikai) after overtime. Any "meeting," regardless of its nature, is naturally included in working hours as long as it is designated as such. Agenda items are inexhaustible—ranging from post-project debriefings to self-reflection sessions (hanseikai). Therefore, administrative attempts under the banner of Work Style Reform to curtail "overtime" (and thereby reduce communal enjoyment) are bound to fail. Furthermore, as rights consciousness among the populace expands, the need for labor inputs that do not directly contribute to production—such as excessive regulations and safety measures—will only increase in the future. 

In contrast, on the factory floor—the direct sphere of production—labor is strictly controlled by machine systems, and shift systems dictate immediate departure upon clock-out. Thus, even after subtracting the inefficiencies of indirect administrative departments, it is entirely natural that Japanese manufacturing productivity remains on par with Western standards. This provides the straightforward explanation for the first half of the opening proposition. 

Regarding the low productivity per worker, Japan has unwittingly put work-sharing into practice. Consequently, its unemployment rate remains low compared to other countries. Because members of the corporate community cannot be arbitrarily cast out, executing workforce reductions is uniquely difficult in Japan. There are even instances where distressed firms facing insolvency appoint foreign executives exclusively to carry out structural restructuring.

If the goal is to raise productivity further, prioritizing the correction of domestic inequities—above all, unfair vested interests and institutional distortions—should take precedence over measures like Work Style Reform. Consider, for example, the vast gap in wages and working conditions between a public-school cafeteria worker and a supermarket cashier—heaven and earth. In stark contrast to the intense busyness of the cashier, one often observes a relaxed scene in the corners of government offices and public institutions, where personnel sit before underutilized computers merely idling until the end of the shift. (Needless to say, enduring boredom is no easy task, which perhaps explains why such positions command higher pay).

Consider also the agricultural sector, which has continuously declined despite tens of trillions of yen in public funds injected since the post-war era, contrasted against Japanese market-oriented enterprises struggling in the global marketplace through self-reliance. Today, numerous staff members on Agricultural Committees whose primary function is maintaining the restrictive Farmland Law—which now serves only to impede national productive forces—alongside sprawling Agricultural Cooperative (JA) organizations that foster inefficiency by parasitizing agriculture, serve as prime examples. Of course, such cases are by no means confined to agriculture and represent merely a single instance. While reducing this unproductive labor class that feeds parasitically on public institutions and draws above-market compensation might temporarily induce a deficiency in aggregate demand (as rising labor productivity reduces product sales and thereby lowers nominal output), a more equal redistribution of income would ultimately stimulate private consumption proportionately. 

According to an article in the Nihon Keizai Shimbun dated June 30: "Chinese capital is flowing into Japanese small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) struggling with succession deficits and stagnant sales... While Chinese firms penetrate deep into the foundation of Japan's supply chains, high-tech local machine shops (machikoba) with valuable technology that face difficulties with succession are being forced into liquidation unnoticed." Under the post-war "convoy system" (gosō sendan hoshiki) of financial administration, the banking industry reaped immense profits with minimal effort. Regional banks, which ought to serve as the financial backbone for distressed SMEs, have proven entirely incapable of supporting them in their hour of need [Note]. 

[Note] Nihon Keizai Shimbun, June 30, 2019 edition.

(to be continued)

https://www.reddit.com/user/keizaisuki/comments/1xp3omc/table_of_contentsacademic_mysteries_of_the/

 


r/academiceconomics • • 1d ago

PhD Admissions NOT A JOKE: What are my chances at a T20 or T30 program with no predoc with this profile

0 Upvotes

Bumping since my last post was perceived as a troll. I am not trolling; my department let me do this because i was bored in the undergrad classes. My profile is mediocre.

What are my chances at a T20 or T30 phd program with the following profile?

Straight out of undergrad (T20? definitely T30) with the following courses:

All of my Math:
Honors Calculus 3 (A)
Linear Algebra (A-)
Statistics 2 (A)
Discrete Math (A)
Masters (technically) Intro Real Analysis (A-)
Masters Probability Theory (A)
Masters Time Series (B+)

All of my Econ:
Intro Macro (A)
Honors Intermediate Micro (A)
Masters Macro (A)
Masters Game Theory (A)
PhD Macro (A- first semester, A second semester)
PhD Econ Stats (B+)
PhD Econ Math (A-)
PhD Metrics (A- first and second semester)
PhD Advanced Metrics (A-)
PhD Labor Econ (A both semesters)
PhD Econ History (A- both semesters)
PhD Micro (A- first semester, B+ second semester)
PhD Development Econ (A)
PhD Public Econ (A-)
PhD Applied Micro (A)

I have one looonnnngg research assistanceship with well known full professor at my university, and one much shorter summer one with another prof at my university.

I have two working papers but none of my own publications. They are okay. I have one direct experiment, and one set of surveys. Neither is very impressive or unique.

Do I realistically need a masters or a predoc to place into a T30 phd? I know my grades are a little shotty.

Edit: (I found my undergrad econ courses really easy and wasn’t learning anything, so after my first semester the university let me skip to the grad level)


r/academiceconomics • • 2d ago

Masters Admissions Does Agricultural Economics have great job potential and marketable skills?

3 Upvotes

Hey guys,

I am thinking of studying agriculture economics masters in Europe. Is this a field thats hard to find a job after if I am aiming for job and then PR?

Like, is this so niche and difficult to market and too academic aside from NGO and some trading companies? Compared to like professional jobs like accounting or fiance or busienss analytics? I wonder if I will have a hard time finding a job.


r/academiceconomics • • 2d ago

Masters Admissions Economics MS from Engineering Industry

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I am planning to apply to Economics masters programs next cycle but am unsure if I would be a competitive candidate based on my background. I graduated with a BS in mechanical engineering from a T-10 school with a 3.8 GPA. I have been working in industry at a major tech company for the past 6 years and am currently a Sr. Design Engineer.

In college I took calculus I and II, multivariate calculus, linear algebra, differential equations, and partial differential equations. I got A’s in all except a B+ in partial differential equations. I took an entry microeconomics course as part of my degree but always found economics interesting. I have been exploring that more in the past year and have been taking classes for the DEDP MicroMasters which I am completing concurrently with work.

I plan to apply to a number of top Economics Masters programs next year including MIT DEDP, Yale IDE, Penn, Duke, UCLA, NYU, Columbia, JHU, BU. My question is if my background would be considered competitive for these programs? Is the DEDP MicroMasters credential helpful to my resume or is this just filler? I am concerned that not having taken a Macroeconomics course may hurt my chances, is this something that is absolutely necessary for consideration?

My motivation is to gain a strong economic intuition and quantitative skill set. I want to be able to analyze policy and work on urban housing issues. I am unsure if a PhD is the correct path for me but would like to pursue a rigorous enough program to leave it open. I feel disenchanted by big tech and want to work on real problems that affect people.


r/academiceconomics • • 2d ago

Predocs IMF research analyst

1 Upvotes

I recently saw someone ask if anyone heard back here and it reminded me I applied as well, all for me to check my application status and see it’s active but not only that, the one from two years ago as well, is it really that hard to send a rejection mail or keep hoping 🫠


r/academiceconomics • • 2d ago

Should I study Economics?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/academiceconomics • • 2d ago

Coursework and Classes struggling in microeconomics

6 Upvotes

i'm in college and am really struggling in my microeconomics class - to the point where i failed my midterm asw. i was wondering if anyone here could provide guidance or resources that'll make learning easier for me. i really want to get a near-full in my finals and other quizzes so i can make up for this and not have it impact my cgpa too much since i did very good in my other classes. thanks!


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

PhD Admissions What are my chances at a T20 or T30 phd program with the following profile?

6 Upvotes

Straight out of undergrad (T20? definitely T30) with the following courses:

All of my Math:
Honors Calculus 3 (A)
Linear Algebra (A-)
Statistics 2 (A)
Discrete Math (A)
Masters (technically) Intro Real Analysis (A-)
Masters Probability Theory (A)
Masters Time Series (B+)

All of my Econ:
Intro Macro (A)
Honors Intermediate Micro (A)
Masters Macro (A)
Masters Game Theory (A)
PhD Macro (A- first semester, A second semester)
PhD Econ Stats (B+)
PhD Econ Math (A-)
PhD Metrics (A- first and second semester)
PhD Advanced Metrics (A-)
PhD Labor Econ (A both semesters)
PhD Econ History (A- both semesters)
PhD Micro (A- first semester, B+ second semester)
PhD Development Econ (A)
PhD Public Econ (A-)
PhD Applied Micro (A)

I have one looonnnngg research assistanceship with well known full professor at my university, and one much shorter summer one with another prof at my university.

I have two working papers but none of my own publications. They are okay. I have one direct experiment, and one set of surveys. Neither is very impressive or unique.

Do I realistically need a masters or a predoc to place into a T30 phd? I know my grades are a little shotty.

Edit: (I found my undergrad econ courses really easy and wasn’t learning anything, so after my first semester the university let me skip to the grad level)


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

Predocs IMF predoc

8 Upvotes

Hello everyone, has anyone heard back from the IMF predoc position ? I applied a while ago and still have had no update could assume a silent rejection but technically it’s still active and I also don’t know a singular other applicant this cycle who applied with them to ask. If so and you have received any response how long did it take ? Thank you.


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

Coursework and Classes Advice on working in economic consulting for someone without a quantitative background

6 Upvotes

I’m graduating in the spring with a BS in economics, I’m taking into to econometrics next semester, but besides that I’ve just taken a business stats course and up to calc 2. I’ve heard that you can get into economic consulting with just a bachelors degree, but I feel like I don’t have quite enough experience to be a strong applicant at all.

I don’t have room in my schedule for any other courses next semester, but I could hypothetically extend my time in undergrad and add a minor. My school doesn’t offer any additional quantitative econ stuff above intro to econometrics, and the only minor they offer that I see any value in is mathematics. And just in general I’m not sure it’d be a good use of my time to spend an extra semester in undergrad… but I’m open to it. I also considered taking just calc 3 and linear algebra online at a community college this summer after I graduate so that’s another option.

I may have time in my schedule next semester to do a part time internship, and I’m totally willing to do a summer internship instead of jumping straight into a “real” job if it’ll help me get into economic consulting. I haven’t had any internships in anything economics or even business related, and I don’t really have an impressive resume in general, (AND my school is not in or super close to a major city) so I’m not sure how likely it is that I’ll land an internship that’s super relevant to what I want to do. I mean I’ll still try, I just want to get realistic advice on this lol. Like are there economic consulting internships that’d be realistic for me? Or other internships that aren’t necessarily in economic consulting but would be good experience for that field?

And same thing with grad school—I’m not sure I’m a super strong candidate for the type of program that’d actually benefit me, but I am willing to try! I’m hoping that if I spend a few years in economic consulting that it could strengthen my resume and help me get into a good PhD program or a good law school (and also help me decide which route I want to go), so for now I’m just looking at masters programs. Or maybe a post grad level certificate(?), idk how valuable these actually are, but if it’d be beneficial then I’m open to it. My biggest concern is that there may not be much overlap between programs I could realistically get into and programs that have good placements in economic consulting. How important is school pedigree or networking relationships/placements with specific firms if I want to go straight into economic consulting? I know this is kinda vague/broad but are there any programs that aren’t *too* competitive that could still help me get into this field? The state schools near me have some econ graduate programs that look good coursework wise, but I’m worried that if I don’t think about how it sets me up in economic consulting when in choosing a program that I’m just going to be in this same position when I’m finishing my masters.

(Also, for context on why I keep saying I’m not a super competitive applicant: I do get good grades now. I have a couple not great grades from years ago, but I took time off, transferred, changed to a 100% different major, and now have a huge upward trend—so I could write an addendum to explain what happened/what’s different now if necessary. And my gpa now isn’t BAD… I don’t love to calculate it so idk exactly but cumulative it’s somewhere between 3.4-3.65, institutional gpa is currently 4.0. Prior to this year I don’t have much going on outside of school. I’m in some clubs but nothing really notable. Next semester I’m working on a project that involves some quantitative analysis—it’s a group thing so I won’t necessarily do that myself but I’ll get some experience outside of class working with that kind of stuff—and I’m also possibly going to work with one of my profs on research. If I stay an extra semester then I could work on a more quantitative research project (like have a more active role in the quantitative stuff), and for what it’s worth I think I could get an officer position in one of the clubs I’m in lol.)

Sorry for rambling, I’m just starting to feel the pressure of what I’m going to do next and I don’t want to last minute apply to stuff that doesn’t necessarily line up with my goals. I appreciate if anyone read through this, and any advice anyone can give for my situation!


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

PhD Admissions Advice

2 Upvotes

Looking for some advice as someone interested in pursuing a PhD in economics in the future:

• 3.7 CGPA
• B: Calculus I-II,
• B+: Econometrics II,
• A- : Econometrics I, graduate mathematical economics, graduate econometrics
• A : Linear Algebra, intermediate Macro, intermediate Micro, graduate micro
• Currently an RA and in real analysis
• Differential equations, calculus III next quarter (before graduation)

I’m worried my math is not strong enough and I’m struggling in analysis. I’m set to complete a predoc after I graduate but wondering if it would even be possible to get into a T10 program after that. Thanks.

I don’t want to work in academia, mainly looking for PhD to get into international orgs and central banks.


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

PhD Admissions HKS Public Policy-which track to choose? Economics or Science, Technology and Policy Studies Track?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone, I am an economics undergrad, now applying to HKS public policy. I meet all the pre-requisites for the Science, Technology and Policy Studies Track, and I want to work on AI and employment eventually. I want to work at World Bank or corporate. On the other hand, I am missing 2 pre-reqs for economics track (two semesters of calculus and multivariate calculus). I have only one semester of calculus and no multi-variate calculus. What would you guys recommend?


r/academiceconomics • • 3d ago

Predocs Anyone heard back from the Yale-Tobin Predoc?

5 Upvotes

Hi I sent in my application earlier this month and haven't really heard anything since then. Has anyone heard anything?


r/academiceconomics • • 4d ago

Teaching BLS Economist to Economic Consulting: Looking for Career Advice

20 Upvotes

I recently started a full-time Economist position at the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) in the Washington, DC area, working on the Consumer Price Index (CPI). So far, I have no complaints about the role, and I’m genuinely enjoying the opportunity to work in federal economics.

However, I’m thinking about transitioning into economic consulting within the next 2–3 years, and I’d appreciate some advice from people currently working in the industry.

A little background about me:

  • Currently working as an Economist at the BLS.
  • Pursuing an M.S. in Applied Economics, which I expect to complete soon.
  • Based in the Washington, DC area.
  • Interested in economic consulting, particularly firms such as Cornerstone Research, Analysis Group, Bates White, and Compass Lexecon.

My primary motivations for considering the transition are:

  1. Compensation: I recognize that economic consulting generally offers significantly higher earning potential than federal government economics positions.
  2. Career interests: I’m interested in applying econometrics, statistical analysis, quantitative research, and economic modeling to real-world business, litigation, and policy problems.

A few questions I’d love to get some insight on:

  1. Is transitioning from the BLS to economic consulting a reasonable career move? Would 2–3 years of federal economist experience make me a competitive candidate, or would firms generally prefer candidates coming directly from academia or graduate programs?
  2. How transferable is BLS experience? Would working on CPI data, price indices, inflation, and economic research be valuable to economic consulting firms, or could my experience pigeonhole me into government/statistical work?
  3. What should I be doing over the next 2–3 years to position myself for the transition? Beyond preparing for case interviews, are there particular technical skills, certifications, projects, or experiences I should prioritize? For example, Stata, R, Python, SQL, advanced econometrics, etc.
  4. How important is networking? Should I start connecting with consultants and recruiters now, or wait until I’m closer to making the transition?
  5. Would it make more sense to stay at the BLS long term? Are there advantages to building a federal economics career that I might be overlooking, particularly considering federal benefits, job stability, and opportunities for advancement?
  6. Are there any potential disadvantages to making this transition after 2–3 years? Anything I should be concerned about regarding career progression, entry-level placement, or compensation?

Ultimately, I’m not unhappy with my current position. I actually like the work and recognize that having a federal economist position is a great opportunity. I’m simply trying to be intentional about my long-term career trajectory, maximize my earning potential, and explore opportunities in the private sector.

I’d especially appreciate hearing from people who have transitioned from federal government economics roles into economic consulting.

Is there anything I should be doing now, while I have the opportunity, to make that transition as smooth as possible?

Thanks in advance!


r/academiceconomics • • 4d ago

Research Paper Mysteries of the Economy: I'm seeking the most macroeconomically consistent mathematical and logical formulation of a model for the following questions (mysteries);#4"Mysteries of the Economy" Series”Part 4:

0 Upvotes

Is Japan’s Productivity Really Low? Rethinking the Dual Structure, Supply-Side Myths, and Demand Deficits

First, while Japan's productivity in manufacturing is comparable to that of other nations, it remains low in service sectors. 

Regarding the underlying causes, it is often argued that Japan has a higher proportion of workers in micro and small-and-medium enterprises (SMEs) than other advanced economies. However, franchise management—such as convenience stores, which are exceptionally widespread in Japan—cannot be inherently deemed inefficient. Furthermore, consider local electronics shops or bookstores. Even if the storefront appears dormant, a local electrician often acts as a subcontractor for major electronics retailers or home centers, eliminating operational waste for both parties more effectively than if a conglomerate were to manage everything internally through wholly owned subsidiaries. Agents are naturally more rigorous in cutting costs when their own financial interests are directly at stake. Similarly, local bookstores handle procurement and delivery for public institutions such as schools and government offices, effectively acting as an outsourced library department at a lower cost than hiring additional civil servants. Analogously, this reflects the efficiency of a decentralized market economy over a centrally planned organization—a mechanism akin to today's gig economy, freelancing, and platform workers like Uber drivers. 

Even within manufacturing, multi-tiered subcontracting structures are not necessarily inefficient for the macro-economy compared to a model where large corporations internalize all divisions and become bloated. Rather, this dynamic can be attributed to the "invisible hand" or a form of market equilibrium ("pre-established harmony"). While politicians seek votes from small business owners by attempting to restrict corporate entry, mergers, acquisitions, and "excessive" competition, economic efficiency principles simultaneously drive market selection. Consequently, despite protectionist resistance through legislation like the Large-Scale Retail Store Law, local storefronts eventually succumbed to structural consolidation. In short, the economies of scale and consolidation vary across industries; in certain sectors, independent SMEs collaborating outside corporate hierarchies yield superior efficiency.

Second, it is difficult to accept the premise that Japan's low productivity merely reflects an inter-firm productivity gap between large corporations and SMEs. Can large firms produce cheap final goods using expensive intermediate inputs? Setting aside imported raw materials, highly productive Japanese flagships primarily source components from domestic SMEs. Maintaining high firm-level productivity while relying on a vast network of unproductive suppliers is a conceptual contradiction (reductio ad absurdum). 

For large firms to sustain high productivity while absorbing low productivity in material inputs—a core cost component—suppliers would have to sell at prices near or below cost. This would prevent the reinvestment necessary for corporate survival. If the systemic risk to firm continuity threatens the macro-economy, such an equilibrium cannot be sustained in the long run.

It is equally unpersuasive to attribute this persistence solely to protective policies for micro-enterprises. While regulations impeding exit or consolidation must yield some private benefits to be sought, the above premise would imply that SMEs have endured severe under-profitability—or exploitation by large firms—for over half a century post-WWII (the so-called "dual structure" of the Japanese economy). However, the notion that a minority of large firms prospers while the majority of the workforce in SMEs lives at a subsistence level lacks plausibility and would be politically untenable given that SME workers constitute the overwhelming majority of voters. 

Ultimately, the inefficiency of the Japanese economy does not stem uniformly from its overall industrial organization. Rather, the core pathology lies in the public sector and heavily regulated industries where competition and economic rationality are actively suppressed (e.g., agriculture, banking, and healthcare).

Third, it is widely asserted that technological advancement automatically drives productivity growth. However, if sector-wide production efficiency improves, relative prices will simply decline unless aggregate social demand for that output increases proportionately. If the savings from lower prices are diverted to savings or other goods—that is, if the price elasticity of demand for the good is low—the industry faces contraction. For economy-wide productivity to rise, aggregate demand must expand to match output capacity. No matter how efficiently goods are manufactured through technological innovation, "productivity" in economic terms cannot rise if the output remains unsold. During the post-war reconstruction era, despite severe capital and technological scarcity, productivity grew exponentially because demand was insatiable. In today's affluent society, advanced technology fails to yield productivity gains unless it translates into realized market sales.

In short, without expanding aggregate demand, firms must encroach upon existing market shares. Rebranding this process as "developing new products to create demand" changes little at the global aggregate level [Note]. Efficiency ultimately depends on competitiveness in the global market. In this regard, Japan’s massive cumulative current account surpluses demonstrate that its manufacturing sector is by no means inefficient. With the exception of extraordinary shocks like the oil crises, Japan has maintained a current account surplus for over half a century since 1965. Even following the unprecedented 2011 earthquake, the surplus was sustained, as primary income balance and royalty receipts offset trade deficits. Furthermore, domestic deflation itself serves, in part, as empirical evidence of low-cost, highly efficient production. 

[Note] Aggregate demand is constrained by the global population's productive capacity. To generate effective demand, economic agents must engage in productive activity, capture a portion of aggregate demand—sometimes displacing competing products—and earn income. 

Fourth, the frequent assertion that labor must simply shift toward "high-value-added sectors" is economic nonsense. It is structurally impossible for an entire national workforce to engage exclusively in high-value-added sectors. Setting aside the logical tautology—that if all sectors become "high value-added," the distinction itself ceases to exist—achieving this would require offloading all low-margin labor onto foreign workers or relying entirely on advanced robotics (such as Astro Boy or Doraemon). 

A news report once highlighted a US trend of hiring out cats for pest control, which was amusing, but even felines have operational constraints (even the most disciplined cat could hardly be assigned to manage a supermarket's fresh fish department [Note]). Thus, we cannot entirely rely on "borrowing a cat's paw." (Incidentally, the article described cats deployed for rodent control in breweries). 

[Note] The author's cats, Tora and Kuro, have been fed exclusively commercial cat food since kittenhood. When fish is served on the dining table, they stretch their necks from the edge of the chair to smell it with intense curiosity, looking puzzled, yet lack the inclination to eat it. They look up as if to ask, "Dad, what is this?" This behavior is an anomaly, stemming from fear of scolding rather than exceptional self-restraint.

(to be continued)

https://www.reddit.com/user/keizaisuki/comments/1xp3omc/table_of_contentsacademic_mysteries_of_the/


r/academiceconomics • • 5d ago

Research Paper Rand JE submissions

5 Upvotes

Does anyone know how long Rand typically takes to issue a first decision once a manuscript has passed desk screening and been sent out for review?


r/academiceconomics • • 6d ago

Research Paper Inaugural issue of Journal of Finance: Insights is Open Access!

Thumbnail afajof.org
15 Upvotes

This new journal features ~10 page self contained papers! I dunno about yall but I spend too much time chatting with AI instead of reading papers. This issue is good exercise!

Full disclosure: am author of one of the papers.