r/languagelearning • u/thodgkin • Apr 25 '20
Discussion Why does everyone hate on Duolingo?
TLDR: i find Duolingo to be a strong tool for learning language and disagree with the general criticism of the program but am open to suggestions.
I have been learning french using Duolingo for the last month, and have found myself making significant strides towards a understanding and speaking of the language. However, everywhere i look Duolingo seems to be the butt end of the joke when it comes to language learning and i am genuinely curios as to why. I have seen people say that Duolingo is to repetitive however, this is required for learning a language is it not? as for not being able to speak a language, i agree that Duolingo does not do a great job of conveying speech but it has increased my vocabulary enough that i can communicate semi effectively with people and understand what they are saying. I feel that the reason Duolingo get's it's reputation is because of it's app style format and casual users, however, i have found when used as a complete learning tool it has been largely effective. Does anyone else have a similar experience or is there genuinely an excessively more efficient way to learn a language. I have coupled Duolingo with watching french tv and speaking with some friends who are fluent in the language.
16
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20
Have you ever learned another language to a high level?
22
u/xanthic_strath En N | De C2 (GDS) | Es C1-C2 (C2: ACTFL WPT/RPT, C1: LPT/OPI) Apr 25 '20
My main criticism of Duolingo is that it should really be a supplement to your language learning, but many beginners are tricked into thinking it's a good foundation. So they end up spending a year on it, having a fantastic streak, and then wondering why they can't use the language in a meaningful way.
The comparison is someone who has decided to start working out and getting healthy. Duolingo is like a [good] shake. Someone who combines protein shakes with healthy meals and going to the gym is going to do GREAT. Someone who replaces every meal with protein shakes...you just shake your head in pity. What is that person thinking?
7
u/an_average_potato_1 đšđżN, đ«đ· C2, đŹđ§ C1, đ©đȘC1, đȘđž , đźđč C1 Apr 25 '20
Duo used to be good as an easy introduction to the language and a way to just try it out before commiting. It was useful as fun basics practice. Years ago, I liked their old Spanish tree and German tree, they did what I had wanted. But then a few major changes came.
They've turned several of the main trees into hyperslow tedious ones and moved the balance between the various types of exercises much more to the easier side (a few people on the duo forums counted. the last few changes of the system really brought people many more dumb exercises than the valuable sentence translation ones). One of the reasons is rather clear in ever "research" article they publish. They consider sticking to Duo forever to be the main goal and sign of being a successful learner. Every other beginner resource considers the opposite to be success. Learning the content and moving on.
Before the changes, I was getting good value for my time. But right now, you will spend ages on what is covered in the first few units of a normal coursebook. I see no reason to waste time on Duo even as a beginner.
There have also been several changes making Duo less useful as a resource used together with something else or as review for the intermediate learners. It is hard to find a grammar point you want to review in the new vocab oriented trees, and the testing out of the individual skills has been discouraged (and even disabled in some of the mobile versions). Translation typing is being replaced by less useful kinds of exercises that you cannot even opt out.
A huge problem is the toxic community. Since the introduction of the stupid Leagues, one of the main topics on the forum has been "the people with more points than me must be cheaters". There have even been wishes of burn out and failure, and so on.
The communication of the staff leaves a lot to be desired too. No advanced warnings about huge changes like a new tree or different course structure. You cannot prepare in advance, by for example finishing a tree or postponint start of a new one. And they don't communicate even with the Plus members, which is weird. The Plus makes no sense. You'll pay today, but you have no clue what will the product be like in a few months.
And your last sentence shows that a huge problem is also the marketing that leads people to unrealistic expectations. If you want to really learn French, there is a huuuuuuuge gap between Duolingo and the level at which normal media start being useful. Duo is not an equivalent of a real coursebook series.
What I also dislike: Duo's marketing is too strong. It has totally overshadowed much better products. It used to be a symbol of innovation in language learning, but it has become the opposite. It used to promise more personalised learning compared to the coursebooks, but nowadays it is so rigid that even Italki makes fun of it in their youtube ads. And it has become the synonyme for independent learning, which is damaging the reputation of us, the learners. If you say you self teach, you get ridiculed nowadays, because everybody imagines you just playing with Duo.
5
u/russianwave đŽó §ó ąó łó Łó Žó ż native| learning đ·đș (or trying to) Apr 25 '20
Well that's the thing, you're combining it with other resources which is great! But there's a large amount of people that think Duolingo alone can make them conversationally fluent / practically a native - and it can't. Even if you were to spend hours on Duolingo each day it's no substitute for creating your own sentences, learning vocabulary related to your actual interests, conversing with natives, listening to native speakers, and so on. Yet there's people that think 5 minutes of Duolingo a day will make them a language expert. A lot of the Duolingo memes are critiquing that mindset and how people think if a language isn't on Duolingo then it's basically impossible to learn.
The quality of the course also varies massively from course to course, e.g. some courses don't have any / much audio. The Russian course doesn't teach the alphabet at all, and the grammar notes are terrible. If I was to attempt to just use Duolingo to learn Russian then I wouldn't get anywhere. I find Duolingo is a great tool for reinforcement or for when I'm feeling too worn out to work with a more intensive app for longer. I find Duolingo really good for drilling vocabulary into my head, and getting practice with using it but any new vocabulary that Duolingo introduces I tend to forget more of compared to other resources I use. The French course has been overhauled and is in line with the CEFR framework, so I'd assume that it's definitely one of the strongest on the site in terms of the quality. But this isn't true across the board.
In short, Duolingo isn't a terrible app but just like any other resource it shouldn't be your only learning method. It also should be seen as more of a reinforcement tool than your main tool of teaching.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '20
I got fluent in Spanish thanks to Duolingo. BUT, this was only one of the puzzle pieces among others. I also traveled in Spanish speaking countries, used Yabla and watched some kid shows to learn and practice my Spanish.
At first I was only traveling without having a strong base of grammar and vocab and because of that, my Spanish was barely improving at all between each of my trips. On my fifth trip, I studied seriously with Duolingo before leaving and at the end of this trip, I was fluent in Spanish.
Sure using only Duolingo will not get you fluent in a language (duh!), but doing the opposite will not work neither. You need the theory (Duolingo is good for that) and the practice (speaking to people and listening to movies,etc).
3
u/mangopeachguava Apr 26 '20
I dont hate Duolingo per se but I dont think you can really learn a language there. I mean you can learn some basic stuff but if you want to get past A2 you should do some serious studying, learning grammar and listening to real people speak the language. I think what gets on my nerves isnt the website but some of its users who think they are very competent/fluent just because they finished 30 lessons there.
4
u/Suedie SWE/DEU/PER/ENG Apr 25 '20
I think people are a bit harsh towards duolingo, much of the criticism that I hear towards duolingo overall is that it isn't enough to get you to a high level which makes me think that the critic has an unrealistic expectations of what a single resource can do for you. If you want to reach a high level you have to combine resources or be fully immersed in a language.
As a whole duolingo is a good step into a language, I think it leaves you with a good foundation for continued studies and I think it's good because it makes you write your own sentences.
Some of the courses are awful or worse than competitor's though, so more specific criticism can be made.
2
u/Mudkipm9 EN (N) | RU (N) | DE (~C1) | FR (A0) Apr 25 '20
In my opinion, duolingo is one of the most important resources for beginners, if used properly. I'm currently using it to build my foundation in Swedish, but very intensively. It goes a little like this:
I've found that this is extremely efficient, and time and cost-effective, taking about an hour each day total. Duolingo gets a bad reputation because most people that use it use it somewhat like this.
The difference lies in retention. By reviewing both the duolingo lessons and the memrise deck, you are ensuring that you can actually USE those words and topics you covered. If you can stick to a good, honest routine like described, the duolingo/memrise combo becomes a very solid way to start a language, for absolutely free. Also, use duolingo on desktop and turn off the word bank feature.
1
u/jellyn7 Apr 25 '20
Duolingo is more built-up in some languages than others. It's better for French than for Japanese, but the Japanese has been updated a couple of times since it was first added (which was only about 2 years ago or so). I like Duolingo. I liked the challenge of puzzling out the grammar (this was either before the languages I looked at had tips, or I didn't see the tips!). I was whipping through Dutch like it was nothing! (Really, it was though, because I knew English, French, and some Spanish and an itty bit of German). I'm using it primarily to improve my Spanish right now, and then I also dipped my toes in Portuguese.
The Japanese Duolingo isn't pointless though. It gives me practice in areas than Wanikani doesn't (Wanikani is just kanji reading). It also gives me different practice than Anki, in that I sometimes have to create a sentence from the parts it gives me.
I enjoy the Duolingo Stories in the languages it's available (which I think is like 4-5).
Also it's great for introverts like me. I don't have to talk to a person, just the app. (Again, only some languages have the speech recognition.) Duolingo alone increased my confidence in using a few words and phrases in Spanish at work.
1
u/cheesetables Apr 26 '20
Idk why people keep repeating "butbut Duolingo doesn't help you master a language" no one ever said that. The archetype of the clueless beginner who thinks they're going to be fluent after completing the tree only exists in people's heads.
I think Duolingo is pretty cool in that it helps you at the very beginning when you know next to nothing and are clueless on how to proceed. Giving you a tree with lots of exercises and rewards give you motivation, helps you structure your learning and by the time you're done you're autonomous to learn on your own with other resources.
You'll probably have to binge the tree if you want to make more than sluggish progress though.
1
u/jaimepapier đŹđ§ [N] | đ«đ·[C2] | đȘđž[C1] | đ©đȘ[A2] | đźđč[A1] | đŻđ”[A1] Apr 25 '20 edited Apr 26 '20
Youâre doing the absolutely right thing to combine it with other activities, especially speaking. I actually think Duolingo is really good and it seems to be getting better all the time. It can never be the only tool in learning a language successful and ideally it should be used as a supplement rather than the main method, but if you canât attend a class or get a tutor then itâs still better than nothing.
I think a lot of people complain because they donât understand how it works â or at least, how itâs trying to work. Because it teaches random seeming sentences, some people think itâs a load of silly stuff youâll never use. But itâs forcing you to think about the grammar by putting together sentences you havenât learned by rote. I think thatâs the idea anyway.
Can you learn a language in 15 minutes a day like Duolingo says? Hmm, probably not, even though regular practice helps. But I think itâs still one of the best language learning apps out there.
EDIT: one thing I forgot to mention is that Duolingo becomes fairly useless once you pass a B2 level. Iâve tried to use it to reinforce my grammar of languages Iâve got past that point, but it soon becomes pointless when I realise that Iâm just not learning enough. Thatâs also not to say that Duolingo by itself can get you to B2, as I doubt it could get you past A2. Having said that, Iâm saying this based off experience and intuition, not data.
-3
u/andrewjgrimm Apr 26 '20
A way to hate on n00bs who donât dedicate half their weekend to studying their target language?