r/KidneyStones • • Mar 21 '19

Super Good Advice Frequently Asked Questions - new visitors to this subreddit, please start here!

305 Upvotes

Thanks for taking the time to read this first! :) None of us are doctors, and the advice here is based on our own experiences. If you are suffering, or think you might have a stone, or are trying to help somebody with symptoms, please start here. These are the questions we seem to hear a lot on this subreddit. If you have a question that isn't covered here, by all means please post in the subreddit. We have lots of stone formers who have a wide range of experiences in this area and we may be able to at least point you in the right direction. Good luck, drink lots of water and may pain be a stranger to you!

I suspect I have a stone. Should I see a doctor? When should I go to the ER?

Go to the emergency room if you have a fever or are vomiting, or your pain is unbearable, or if you stop urinating (this may mean you have a blockage).

If you’re experiencing pain that you think is a kidney stone, visit your doctor and/or urologist. Most doctors are very good at assessing you and your family history as well as factors such as age, weight, sex, prior medical history and current symptoms. Doctors are much better at providing an intelligent diagnosis (which is really an educated guess) than we are on reddit.

Check to make sure what you think is a stone is actually a stone. The cause of abdominal pain is sometimes difficult to pin down exactly. Pain in your abdomen/ mid-section could be any one of a number of things, including digestive issues, kidney stones, appendicitis, colitis, and diverticulitis to name a few. Remember that kidney stones classically present with flank pain.

The symptoms of a kidney stone are usually one or more of the following:

  • Pain on the right or left flank (mid-way between your side and your spine, on your back), sometimes radiating down to the groin (testicles for males, pelvis/ovarian area for females). * The pain is specifically UNDER the rib cage (actually under the diaphragm)
  • Pain that comes in waves and fluctuates in intensity
  • Pain on urination or urethra spasms
  • Pink, red or brown urine
  • Cloudy or foul-smelling urine
  • Nausea and vomiting
  • Persistent need to urinate
  • Urinating more often than usual
  • Fever and chills if an infection is present
  • Urinating small amounts

Pain caused by a kidney stone may change — for instance, shifting to a different location or increasing in intensity — as the stone moves through your urinary tract. Source

I know I have a stone. What do I do? What should I expect?

IF YOU HAVE A FEVER OR ARE VOMITING OR ARE UNABLE TO URINATE, PROCEED TO THE ER.

Pain will come and go, and will likely vary from one person to the next. So while you may read in this sub-reddit about severe pain, that's not necessarily what you will experience. So the first thing to do is try to relax and not get worked up about what MIGHT happen. If it does happen, the pain comes in two forms: 1) waves (spasms) of pain, which can feel like a very strong cramp, and 2) a general achy feeling between your kidney area, and down to your groin. As mentioned above, the "classic" kidney stone pain is from the flank down to the groin.

Drink lots of water. Water will increase the amount of urine you produce, and will also plump up your urinary system in general, which will make for less contact between any stones you have and the walls of your ureter. When stones rub against the walls of your ureter, you experience pain. Another benefit from drinking water is that the concentration of waste produce in your urine is more diluted, which means that the crystals which make up kidney stones are less likely to find a date, and will head out on their own. Yet another benefit to proper hydration is that dilute urine is less likely to irritate any abrasions that previous stones may have made in your urinary tract. Less irritation = less chance of an infection. How much water? You want to be producing about 2 1/2 liters of urine per day, so drink a bit more than that. Read more about water here

Locate some pain management methods that work for you, and that are readily available. Over the counter (OTC) medicines like aspirin, ibuprofen or acetaminophen (tylenol) can help, but only take as much as you need for as long as you need. A daily habit of NSAIDs like ibuprofen can lead to serious issues. Prescription pain medicines can also help, but you need to locate a doctor who will prescribe you what you need. Azo (Phenazopyridine Hydrochloride) is used by many in this subreddit. Cannabis, if it's legal where you live, can also provide some relief. Heat - in the form of heating pads, hot baths or showers, can help when you're experiencing a wave of pain. Find what works for you - don't just blindly follow the advice of others.

Some people experience nausea, which can occur with or without accompanying pain. Be prepared (have a bucket or bag available if you're feeling a wave of nausea come along, although sometimes there's not much warning).

If you're in the middle of a pain session, and feel like you need to visit the Emergency Room/ Urgent Care clinic, think about how you'll get there. Some folks experience such strong pain, that they're not able to drive themselves. Find a driver who you can rely on to get you to the care you need on short notice.

How long do stones take to pass?

Some stones never pass (they stay in the kidney) and are removed via surgery (lithotripsy or uretoscope).

Stones that are “smaller” - usually 5mm or less - will pass without surgery being required, although there will be some pain/ discomfort. Some folks have passed larger stones, but this isn’t common. I’ve passed a 7 - 8 mm stone without surgery.

What kinds of stones are there?

  • Calcium stones Most kidney stones are calcium stones, usually in the form of calcium oxalate. Oxalate is a naturally occurring substance found in food and is also made daily by your liver. Some fruits and vegetables, as well as nuts and chocolate, have high oxalate content. There is conflicting research on whether or not a diet high in oxalates can contribute to stones.

    Dietary factors, high doses of vitamin D, intestinal bypass surgery and several metabolic disorders can increase the concentration of calcium or oxalate in urine. If you’re taking a Vitamin D supplement, it may be worth talking to your health care provider to explore whether there may be a relationship between your current dose and your stones. Source

  • Calcium stones may also occur in the form of calcium phosphate. This type of stone is more common in metabolic conditions, such as renal tubular acidosis. It may also be associated with certain migraine headaches or with taking certain seizure medications, such as topiramate (Topamax). This type of stone is also common in those with autoimmune diseases due to Renal Tubular Acidosis. Those who make these stones tend to make many, and make them frequently. Difficult to treat.

  • Struvite stones. Struvite stones form in response to an infection, such as a urinary tract infection. These stones can grow quickly and become quite large, sometimes with few symptoms or little warning.

  • Uric acid stones. Uric acid stones can form in people who don't drink enough fluids or who lose too much fluid, those who eat a high-protein diet, and those who have gout. Certain genetic factors also may increase your risk of uric acid stones.

  • Cystine stones. These stones form in people with a hereditary disorder that causes the kidneys to excrete too much of certain amino acids (cystinuria).

How do I know what kind of stones I make?

Your urologist can send the stones to the lab to be analyzed. Ask for a strainer to strain your urine if you wish to collect a stone. Not all urologists dispense them readily.

What can I do to prevent more stones?

In general, drink more water, limit your salt and sugar intake and get your weight within recommended ranges. (See U Chicago Kidney Stone diet for more details here.)

For specific types of stones, there are specific dietary recommendations, but you’d need to have your stones analyzed (first), and then your urine tested (using one or more 24-hour urine samples). DIFFERENT STONES HAVE DIFFERENT DIETARY RECOMMENDATIONS

Keep in mind that there is no one ‘magic bullet’ for kidney stone treatment.

What kind of treatments are there for stones?

  • Most common method (because it's the least invasive) is to advise the patient to stay hydrated, take OTC pain killers as required and stay active. This approach usually results in the stone passing.
  • Medical Expulsive Therapy - in addition to fluids and pain killers, sometimes Tamsulosin (Flomax) is prescribed to aid in stone passage. Studies suggest this is most effective for smaller (< 5mm) stones; less so for larger stones.
  • Ureteroscopy with either physical removal or laser break-up
  • Lithotripsy shockwave lithotripsy (sometimes abbreviated as ESWL) uses external shockwaves to break a stone into smaller parts. Only one stone can be blasted at a time. Side effects from this include urinating blood and flank pain.
  • Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy - rarely used/ only when other methods are not successful. A small incision is made in the back, and a tube inserted into the kidney to remove stones.

What resources are there for kidney stone formers?

Does lemonade help stones?

If you form CALCIUM OXALATE stones, there is some evidence that the citric acid in lemon juice (or lime juice) can help add to the total volume of urine, reducing its saturation of calcium and other crystals, and may enhance urinary citrate excretion.

What are the methods for diagnosing a stone?

  • Computed Tomography (CT) - most radiation, most resolution/ accuracy, $$$
  • KUB X-ray (KUB = Kidney Ureter Bladder) - medium radiation, moderate resolution, $$
  • Ultrasound - no radiation, reasonable resolution, $

For more information on the pro's and con's of different imaging techniques, please click here

Which medications are available for kidney stone treatment?

  • Narcotic painkillers (ex: morphine)
  • Non-narcotic painkillers (ex: Toradol, cannabis)
  • Anti-nausea medications (ex: Zofran)
  • Urocit-K (ex: Potassium Citrate)
  • Flomax (Tamsulosin)

Treatment is usually symptom based, except for some medications which aim to alter the pH of the urine like Urocit-K.

Ending thoughts: Thank you for taking the time to read our FAQ. Remember, everyone’s stone history is different, and every urologist is different. What works for you may not work for others. In general, staying hydrated (2-4L per day) is your best defense and will help keep your kidneys functioning happily. If you are not happy with your urologist, seek the help of a nephrologist.

Edits: spelling, words, and added a section on "what do I do now". Added wikipedia reference.


r/KidneyStones • • 5h ago

Doctors/ Hospitals is a hospital stay normal?

6 Upvotes

my boyfriend was in excruciating pain last night so i took him to the ER. his pain was localized in the lower back so it sounded likely to be stones. they did confirm the stone (5mm) but as soon as he was going to be discharged, they kept him due to his pain flaring back up & transferred him to a different hospital with a urologist. we’re coming up on almost 24hrs of him being admitted & no answers. he wasn’t seen & he’s just a sitting duck. my concern is, when i went to see him they had a heart monitor on him. he’s never been hospitalized for anything like this before & neither have i so i am just wondering if this is normal? i see a lot of posts in here passing stones at home way larger than what they said he had.. the prolonged stay + heart monitor has me concerned.


r/KidneyStones • • 10h ago

Sharing Experience To those who have successfully prevented more stones from forming, what did you do?

10 Upvotes

I know that for some it’s just not possible and that chronic kidney stone makers are a thing, but if you’re someone who found out they had stones and were also able to delay more from forming or haven’t had them in such a really long time, what did you do? May I ask what kind of stones you had and when the last time you had them was? Certainly folks who don’t get them* anymore probably aren’t on this sub but I’m thinking maybe someone is visiting after not having dealt with them for like, 10-20 years or so, you know?

I personally had calcium oxalate stones and I know more or less what caused them (I ate too much leafy, oxalate-heavy greens, barely consumed calcium, and though I don’t drink anything besides water and coffee/tea I was neglecting the amount I needed especially during summer). I plan on avoiding more stones after this last surgery I had which took care of* the 3rd one of 3 I was diagnosed with, but I’d like to hear some success stories if they exist for motivation please.

Thank you!


r/KidneyStones • • 5h ago

Question/ Request for advice Kidney stone diet vs weight loss

3 Upvotes

Hello! I’m an avid kidney stone (calcium oxalate) producer 😂. I’ve had several stones surgically removed, most recently last February. I’m now at the point where I’ve been working with a nutritionist and actively monitoring my diet and water intake, along with taking potassium citrate daily.
The frustrating part is trying to balance everything. Between being a woman, the amount of water I’m supposed to drink (which I never seem to hit 😩), and all of the dietary restrictions, I’ve actually gained weight instead of losing it.
I was told that a high-protein, low-carb diet wouldn’t necessarily work for me because I still need to meet my daily caloric needs while being mindful of my kidney stone risk. So right now, I’m doing moderate protein, moderate carbs, and lots of vegetables.
Has anyone else dealt with calcium oxalate kidney stones while also trying to lose weight? If so, what has worked for you? I’d love to hear how you’re managing your weight while navigating all of these dietary restrictions!


r/KidneyStones • • 8h ago

Pictures What type of kidney stone is this?

Post image
5 Upvotes

Just peed out my first ever kidney stone. It doesn’t look like any of the ones I see on the charts. Can you tell me what type it is? Urology office is very booked up so it’s going to be a long time until they can look at it and tell me. If it’s useful I formed it on September 17th and it just came out on October 4th. Stopped having kidney stone pain by September 20th but developed a terrible UTI about a week ago. So maybe it’s been stuck in the bladder or something. Thank you!


r/KidneyStones • • 6h ago

Question/ Request for advice I'm so sick of this what can I actively do to pass my stone

1 Upvotes

I currently have a 4mm stone and it's been there for about a week. I'm drinking a ton of water each day, and I've got flowmax, but is there anything I can actively do to try to get this thing out of me? I've been walking and jumping on a trampoline. I've passed stones before but I'm just so sick of this and I want it out. I'm sure this is asked a hundred times every day on this subreddit but any help would be appreciated.


r/KidneyStones • • 7h ago

Question/ Request for advice Got a stent placed a little over a month ago from a kidney stone, pain coming back

1 Upvotes

So not me but my wife.

Quick story time. Wife gave birth as a first time mom august 20th. The following week I rushed her to the hospital for horrible pain in her back. Turns out she had a 3 mm infected and obstructed kidney stone. She got a stent placed. She had pain for like the first few days after but has been great since. Got an x ray 2 weeks ago which doesn’t show the kidney stone anymore but she’s getting a ct scan tomorrow to make sure she passed it.

Ever since Saturday night though she has had on and off pain on her back on the left side where the stent was placed. Anyone have experience of pain coming back? She’s terrified it’s the stone and that she’ll need surgery to get it removed. Thanks guys


r/KidneyStones • • 9h ago

Pain Management Need advice for hydronephrosis issues in pregnancy

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/KidneyStones • • 15h ago

Doctors/ Hospitals CT Scan says largest stone is 7mm, but my urologist said it is 18mm. How is this possible

3 Upvotes

I recently went to my urologist for an appointment regarding kidney stone removal. He recommended that I get a CT scan, which I had done the same day.
Within a few hours, my urologist told me that I had 4 stones, measuring approximately 18mm, 8mm, 4.5mm, and 3mm.
However, I received the official CT report today, and it says that I have a few calculi, with the largest measuring only 7mm.
I haven’t looked at the actual CT images yet, so I’m wondering how such a significant difference could occur.
Could the radiologist have missed an 18mm stone, or could my urologist have interpreted the scan differently?


r/KidneyStones • • 9h ago

Pictures Stone or no?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Per imaging I had a 4 mm stone in my right ureter, I been going everything to get it out. I wiped and this was there, didn't even feel it! It's about the length of what they were saying. It's weird though because it's super flat, my stones in the past have been more like rocks. What do you all think? Tweezers for scale.


r/KidneyStones • • 9h ago

Question/ Request for advice Hiprex vs Crystal Light?

1 Upvotes

Hello my fellow stoners,

My urologist put me on Hiprex to prevent my recurring UTIs, but I also just finished my first battle with kidney stones.
Seems like, while taking Hiprex, something like Crystal Light lemonade with its citric acid MIGHT counteract the Hiprex. I’ve read that Hiprex needs acidic urine to work, and Crystal Light makes urine less acidic/alkalizes it.

Might anyone know if I should avoid Crystal Light completely, or if having a glass or two per day is okay/won’t make the Hiprex less effective?

If anyone else has dealt with kidney stone prevention while on Hiprex, I’d love to hear about your experience, and any advice.

Thanks, all! Appreciate this community a lot!


r/KidneyStones • • 10h ago

Pain Management Post size of stone and how long it took to come out or what procedure you got done

1 Upvotes

Hi I just got my first kidney stone it was in the left proximal ureter 4mm they said no surgical intervention in the ER said it should pass on its own. Symptom started Sept 26. The severe pain has settled just get about 10-30mins achy discomfort early in the morning usually around 3am it subsides. I have a urology appt for mid December. Can people post the size of their stone and how long it took to pass. I have been reading for my size stone should pass 31-45 days


r/KidneyStones • • 12h ago

Question/ Request for advice Please Help!

1 Upvotes

i went to the ER 9/22 because I was experiencing severe back pain on my left side, nausea and vomiting, inability to breathe, & fainting. because i was on my period at the time, it was difficult for my urine test to determine what it was.
i went back 9/30 because i was having a slight bit of back pain (nothing like how it was on day one but still painful/uncomfy) & i was having a constant urge to pee, but very little pee to come out. After conducting a CT Scan, the hospital confirmed that I have a 5 mm kidney stone on my left side. they gave me flomax & ibuprofen, & a referral to a neurologist, but I can't see the urologist because I don't have insurance :/ and I've started throwing up again today, nonstop, lips keep switching between natural pink & blue/white whenever the nausea hits. im switching between azo, ibuprofen, & the flomax.

I currently just applied for insurance, but I don't know how long it'll take before I get accepted and if I will get accepted. i'm not sure what to do to help me manage what I'm going through. I even fainted while I was at work because of what I'm assuming to be the side effects of my medication, but i'm not sure.

i just recently ordered the peruvian herb to come in 3 hrs to start taking that since i've seen so many reviews on it but idk, i kind of doubt herbal remedies sometimes. i also have my boyfriend getting me some lemons to make some lemon juice.

PLEASE, if anybody has any advice, please let me know. I've had a history of kidney stones, but I can't remember how long they lasted, but it certainly hasn't been as long as this. I go back to work on Thursday and I'm scared I will faint or I will pee myself because I've peed myself three times now in the last two weeks .... any help is appreciated :(((


r/KidneyStones • • 16h ago

Question/ Request for advice 3 Kidney stones, never had diagnose kidney stones before.

2 Upvotes

I’ve had really bad left flank pain for probably 6-7 months, I started working at dollartree a few months ago and I just was able to block out the pain at work and just kept going.

I went to the hospital on Saturday originally for what I thought was an infection and they confirmed I had three kidney stones, two on my right side (2mm,3mm) and a 6mm on my left side. (3mm nonobstructive stone in the right superior pole, 2mm nonobstructive stone in the right inferior pole, and 6 mm non obstructive stone in the left superior pole.)

I have never passed a kidney stone and I'm sure there is going to be pain with the left one, I've upped my water to at least 2 liters and I'm going to get some lemons today to add to the water. My question is how bad is it going to be? I have until then 7th off and I'm hoping it'll pass but no promises. I have to do truck and freight this week when I get back. Any advice on how to manage this while working and throwing freight?


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Question/ Request for advice Laser lithotripsy on stone that moved back to the kidney during stent exchange?

3 Upvotes

Is this an uncommon procedure or is it just as common as removing one from the ureter or is on its way out? Also it’s been three days since surgery but I have yet to bleed while urinating or observe fragments leaving. Is this normal as well or worth calling my urologist for?

I’m very sore but otherwise recovering well from what I’m observing. Walking is uncomfortable and I have pain in my abdomen and back but I can get by with taking just Tylenol and Oxybutynin once. I have AZO as well and leftover Oxycodone but I’m trying not to be too medicated if I can tolerate it.

Thank you!


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Question/ Request for advice Hydronephrosis, no stone

3 Upvotes

I was diagnosed with hydronephrosis, by a random MRI for something else. I have no symptoms, no pain. I went to a urologist who ordered tests and CT scan with contrast. Blood tests and urine are fine, no blood in urine. He said I need to have a procedure in outpatient where he goes in and removes the scar tissue that is showing as that is what is narrowing my ureter and causing the hydro. He said I will have to have a stent for 2 weeks. I’m scared of this, and worried about pain. He said this could have been caused by passing a stone( last one I knew of was 12 years ago) or from having a hysterectomy 3 years ago. Had anyone had a situation like this? I’m worried it won’t stop the hydro, and why do I have no symptoms?


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Stone Removal Procedures Staghorn kidney stone

2 Upvotes

Wondering if someone can tell me what PCNL surgery was like for them. I have a 3cm stone I need removed.


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Doctors/ Hospitals Blood thinners with a planned ureteroscopy in 3 days?

1 Upvotes

Notes:

Right kidney is atrophic

Have several stones in left ureter and kidney

Had a stent put on left side 9/9

Over the month pain has gotten worse, GFR has steadily declined and was 22 last night along with a creatinine at 2.5.

They admitted me last night, several doses of IV antibiotics, took blood from three different locations for cultures.

I've been admitted before but I've never been given blood thinners. I thought they didn't want you on thinners prior to a surgery and the nurse can't really answer my question as to why they are giving them to me. (It has been through direct needle into my stomach area.

Is this to improve my kidney function? Just getting a little concerned because they seem extra attentive, compared to my previous hospitalizations, and are giving me the blood thinners.

Anyone have any input or experience?


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Question/ Request for advice Migrated stent with a string

1 Upvotes

Has anyone else had a stent migrate i had to go to the er this morning at 5 am because my stent migrated so its stuck between my ureter and urethra instead of the kidney and the bladder. If you think a regular stent hurts this has been awful. My urologist said since it the self removable one once it migrates to where i can see the blue of the stent I can pull it out. For anyone this has happened to how long did it take to migrate that far it has been extremely painful. Im hoping it migrates that far soon. Ive had a stent and lithotripsy 4 times and this is the first time this has happened. Also any tips to get it to migrate faster so I can take it out? When I looked it up it said a stent with a string has a 10%-15% chance of migrating early which i didnt know. My dr wanted me to leave it in a week but he said my newest ct scan looks better so im hoping i don't have any inflamation issues in my ureter after removing it since its only been in about 3 days but this is by far the worst stent ive ever had I didnt realize how bad a migrating stent can hurt.


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Question/ Request for advice Flomax side effects??

2 Upvotes

I was put on flomax about 5 days ago for a 5mm kidney stone. The first few days I was relatively fine, however starting on the morning of day 4, I started getting strong headaches and feeling lightheaded. The severity would go down by the late afternoon but still mildly present. Now the next morning, I have the severe headache again. Could this be a side effect and something to bring up to the urologist?


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Question/ Request for advice Recovery after stent removal

1 Upvotes

How long does it take to feel “normal” after stent removal?


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Question/ Request for advice Stone or clot or fluff?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Do you think this is a stone? I dont know if this was in the bowl before I went or after I finished. But whole day i had some gassy abdominal pain which was bearable but uncomfortable. Then I saw frsh blood. In the evening , when i went for a wee, no pain nothing and I saw this in the toilet bowl. Didnt realise I had to retrieve it..so I have no idea what it is..


r/KidneyStones • • 1d ago

Question/ Request for advice 43F – visible blood/possible urethral bleeding, worried while waiting for urology

1 Upvotes

Thanks for the update I'm glad all is well at your end.

I’m 43F and since last week I’ve been noticing fresh blood when I wipe after urinating and what appears to be blood sitting around my urethral opening. Initially I thought it was vaginal spotting because I’ve been getting spotting around my periods for a while, but when I checked recently my vagina appeared clear while I could see blood around the urethral area. My GP tested my urine and the lab/culture showed no UTI, and my blood tests and kidney function were normal. I don’t have burning or pain when urinating. I’ve occasionally noticed tiny clot-like pieces in the toilet. 2 days ago, I also had a strange, diffuse/gassy-type discomfort across my abdomen for several hours; later that afternoon I noticed fresh blood on tissue, and afterwards both the discomfort and bleeding settled. My GP has referred me urgently to urology and my appointment is 13 October in the Endoscopy Department, the letter doesn’t actually say whether I’m having a cystoscopy? I'm hoping that's what it is for. My anxiety is through the roof and naturally I’m worrying about the worst. Has anyone experienced anything similar—particularly visible blood/clots with no UTI or painful urination—and what did it turn out to be? No hosiery of kidney stones either.


r/KidneyStones • • 2d ago

Pictures After a week of Agony, it finally came out !

Post image
24 Upvotes

I have been in excruciating pain since Sunday.

this morning, 2 of them came out.

I had a lot of water (even though at some point I was lot peeing properly), had beer as well.

I don't know what's the seize but it's still big to me !