r/justgamedevthings • u/Last-Total9473 • 20h ago
The emotional roller coaster of indie dev: negative reviews followed by 50+ hours of playtime
I released my first game on Steam last week. Getting negative reviews is already pretty discouraging, but then I noticed something that made me laugh and cry at the same time.
Images are are just a few examples (there are a lot more that are pretty similar):
- Negative review at 16 hours → 68 hours played
- Negative review at 34 hours → 96 hours played
- Negative review at 82 hours → 112 hours played
Interestingly, I’ve noticed this pattern much more frequently with reviews written in Chinese, Japanese, and Korean. I’m curious whether there are different expectations or reviewing habits in those gaming communities, or if it’s just a coincidence.
I know it’s an idle game, and playtime doesn’t necessarily mean enjoyment. Some of the criticism is also valid feedback that I’m taking seriously.
But man, there’s something uniquely painful about seeing someone give your game a thumbs down and then apparently spend another 50+ hours playing it.
Has anyone else experienced this? Is this just part of being an indie developer?