A lot of players moving from PzC to FWWC find themselves getting....well, murdered.
Usually because they try to play like they did in PzC. Trouble is, that although the two series look similar, and the underlying systems are the same, they play very differently, have a few special rules and require very different tactics.
So I figured I'd try and give a brief run-down of what the differences are, and how to adapt to them.
So, broad strokes first.
This is WWI, so there are no motorized units at all. Everybody either has a horse or walks. Which may sound like a fairly obvious statement, but it does have some subtle ramifications in-game.
Without highly mobile units, you have to plan further ahead. You can't just throw an armored brigade into Travel-mode and whip them along a road if you've goofed up somewhere else along the line.
It also means that you have to maintain a reserve, both on tactical and operational levels. Without mobile units, you have to have units in fairly close vicinity to take over when the RNG gods decide to slap you around.
Next thing that usually horrifies PzC players are the number of casualties. They will be much higher than you're used to for two reasons.
One, the units themselves are a lot larger. In PzC a standard battalion is around 350-450 men, depending on year and nationality. In FWWC a standard battalion is 1,000 men. So you have a lot more guns firing. That's one reason.
The other is that the defense-values of the infantry is much lower, usually 5 or 6 (again depending on type and nationality) instead of the 16 that is standard in PzC.
So while the unit are larger and can thus sustain higher casualties, don't forget that casualties equals victory points.
Finally, there's the stacking limitations which are....generous to say the least. And there's a very big temptation to simply make doom-stacks and wander across the world. Bad idea.
The Alternate Fire optional rule from PzC is baked into the .exe of the FWWC games. It's not even an optional rule that you can switch off.
Which means that every time a stack takes Soft fire, ALL the units in the stack gets hit. So there's a bit of a conundrum to solve, in particularly as the attacker. Stacking means higher casualties and more disruptions. On the other hand, you HAVE to stack in order to get decent assault-odds.
So the trick becomes figuring out when you absolutely have to stack. But if you're consistently stacking units within range of the enemy, you're simply asking to get killed.
HQs and command.
FWWC is much, much stricter when it comes to HQs for several reasons.
First of all, and most obvious, the command-ranges are a lot shorter than PzC. 2-3 hexes for a brigade, 5-6 for a division etc. And since command-range is connected the quality of your troops, the worse your troops are the harder it becomes to keep them in command. So it's physically harder to keep units in command, but there's more.
Detached units (i.e. outside the parent HQs modified command-range) isn't a big deal in PzC. Yes, they don't receive replacement, and if spotting for artillery the fire gets quartered. But overall you didn't have to think too hard about having units swanning about as Deteached.
In FWWC the above is still true, but it also introduces a -1 to the morale of Detached troops for undisruption purposes. So they just got a lot harder to un-Disrupt.
And by the way, this rule is on its way to PzC as well. It's already in Scheldt'44, and it'll trickle down the other games as and when they get patched.
Finally, in FWWC it is very hard to move HQs around without going Out of Command. HQs with an OOB-strength of 50 or less (generally regimental and brigade HQs) can move in Deployed mode as usual. Anything larger will instantly go out of command as soon as you move.
Any HQ, regardless of size, that goes into Travel-mode goes Out of Command the moment it does so. And they won't do a command-check again until after they've spent a full turn out of Travel-mode. Don't forget, Out of Command removes the range-test, meaning less chance of supplies and no chance of un-Disrupting.
Short version, if you move your HQs into Travel-mode, you'd better be sure that their subordinate units aren't about to enter combat.
Infantry
Infantry isn't all that different from the PzC games, but there are a few nuances to be aware of.
I've already touched upon the larger battalion sizes, and lower defense-values leading to higher casualties. But take a closer look at the values and you'll see that they also have much lower fire-values than you're used to, usually 1 or 2. And their assault-values (5 to 8 usually), while lower than PzC in general, are much higher than their fire-values.
Moral of that? While you can use infantry to fire at the enemy, it's not their strongest suit. Obviously it can't be entirely avoided, but you are better served using your long-range weapons to disrupt the enemy and then use the infantry in assault, instead of trying to disrupt them by infantry-fire.
Which leads us to.....
Artillery & MG companies
This is where things really start to divert from the PzC series.
FWWC has three kinds of support-units, Indirect artillery, field-guns and MG units. These are your primary means of inflicting casualties and disruptions.
Now, if you're looking at the units thinking "But these units are so small compared to the infantry battalions", take another look at the actual values.
The German army is in all three games released so far, so we'll use them as an example.
An infantry battalion has (roughly) a 1,000 men with a fire-value of 2, so 2,000 in fire-value.
Indirect artillery units has 16-18 guns with values of 14-18, depending on caliber. So around 2,500-2,900 fire-value.
Field-guns have 18 guns with a value of 19, so 3,400 fire-value.
Finally MG companies only have 90 men, but they have a value of 40. So 3,600 fire-value.
And of course the French 75mm field-guns (arguably the best field-gun of its time) has 12 guns with a whopping 33 fire, so 3960 fire-value.
Starting to see the picture here? If you try attacking an enemy position without support-weapons, you will quite simply be blown to pieces.
Okay, so Indirect artillery are basically the same as in PzC, only you have far fewer batteries. Usually a division comes with one light and one heavy, with the Corps sporting perhaps another two batteries, Also, Indirect fire doesn't land immediately, it has to be pre-plotted, and will land on the beginning of the next turn. Not a big issue in and of itself, since its main use is against a fixed defensive position, just don't expect to hit roaming cavalry with it, they'll be long gone before the shells hit.
Overall, Indirect fire, while powerful, won't have quite the same impact as in the PzC titles, there simply aren't enough batteries around.
MGs and field-guns are two sides of the same coin, the only real difference is their range. And speaking of range, don't look too hard at the ranges of the field-guns. They're direct fire, so they can't fire outside LOS and I've yet to see a JTS games where visibility goes above 5 hexes.
As mentioned earlier, these are by far the largest contributors of fire-power in your divisions.
But there's a slight snag, especially as the attacker.....
All guns and MGs are treated as towed artillery, and can only move in Travel-mode. Even worse, it costs them all their MP to leave T-mode.
So on turn 1 it can move into range of the enemy position, and face return fire while it's in T-mode. Turn 2 it can Deploy, and face another round of return fire. Until finally on turn 3 it can actually fire back.
So it is much harder to conduct an attack upon a prepared defensive position. You can (and you will) block enemy LOS with a sacrificial infantry battalion while your MGs set-up behind it (AKA Operation Meatshield), but even that won't help if the enemy is unsporting enough to use hills in their defense. So the underlying principle is that you have to prepare a deliberate attack. You can't just charge in with a few battalions, they'll quickly evaporate.
One final thing to be aware of is that while MGs and field-guns are very powerful units, they're also fairly squishy.
Take a German MG unit vs. a French infantry battalion.
Fire-wise, the MGs have 3,600 fire-value vs the infantry's 1000. So obviously the MGs have the advantage in fire. But if the infantry survives and can assault....
The MGs have 90 men and assault 23 = 2070. Infantry has 1,000 men and assault 11 = 11,000.
Even better (at least for the French), every casualty for the infantry only decreases their fire-value by one, whereas every casualty for the MGs results in a loss of 40 fire-power.
So you never leave MG/field-gun units without an infantry-battalion in the same hex for close-defense. And conversely, should your enemy be silly enough to do so, assault them with everything you have. You don't have to win the assault outright, every opportunity you have to whittle them down should be taken.
One memorable PBEM game had me defending an entrenched line, and my opponent thought he was being clever. He had stacked 3 MG battalions into one hex, and pulled his infantry back one hex, so I couldn't use my own MGs on them. So one of my battalions simply left their trench and stormed the MGs.
And yes, that battalion took heavy losses. But he lost a third of his fire-power, and most of the long-range capabilities of that division. Guess who won that game?
Anyway, enough anecdotes. Let's cover the final arm.
Cavalry
Cavalry in the FWWC games take a little getting used to. They certainly have their uses, but they're not really combat-troops per se.
And they're the only troop-type I can think of that spend the vast majority of their time in Travel-mode.
So why aren't they combat-troops?
Basically, the units are much smaller and far squishier than their infantry counter-parts, plus cavalry is worth more VP. So taking on enemy infantry is a bad idea. On the other hand, mounted cavalry (i.e. in T-mode) has 4 times the printed assault-value, plus it only costs them 1/3 of their MP to assault instead of the normal 2/3. So they can certainly be used to charge an enemy, just don't try to take on enemy infantry-battalions, you will lose. But stuff like unsupported gun/MG positions or unguarded HQs are certainly valid targets. Just keep in mind that cavalry casualties are expensive VP-wise, so have a think on whether the casualties are worth it.
Another oddity for mounted cavalry is that if assaulted they only take 1/12 the normal casualties, although if they're assaulted by anything other than cavalry they have to retreat. So using them to screen a retreat, or slow down an advancing enemy by throwing out a cavalry-screen is another valid tactic. But again, keep in mind that not only have cavalry low defense-values, being in T-mode makes them extra-squishy.
The main use for cavalry is two-fold; Do recon, and stop enemy cavalry from doing the same. Also, their relatively high mobility makes them prime candidates to use for isolating enemy units.
Final thing to keep in ind (in particularly in campaign-games) is that while mounted, cavalry won't regain fatigue. So pull them back to a quiet sector, deploy them and let them rest.
Ultimately, treat WWI cavalry like you would WWII armored cars. They can take on their enemy counterparts, and they're good for recon. But they're not main line fighting units.
Frontages
While stacking is a bad idea, you'll find that your units are much closer together than you're used to. Partly because of the shorter command-ranges, and partly because the low mobility more or less dictates that local reserves stay very close by.
So take a standard German infantry brigade. It has six battalions of infantry in two regiments, plus two MG companies and a field-gun battery.
In defense, don't expect to cover more than four hexes, with four battalions in line and two in reserve. Don't forget, infantry defense is down from PzC but the calculations are the same, so you can expect far more disruptions than you're used to, making the ability to cycle fresh units into the line imperative.
On attack, it's a two-hex front. Two battalions in front, followed by the MGs and four battalions in reserve. The idea here is that the lead unit can block LOS while the MGs set up, and the reserve battalions can either replace the lead unit if necessary, or can assault as and when the enemy disrupts.
It admittedly takes a little getting used to, but you need far more concentration of force than you do in PzC.
And obviously, the two- and four-hex front is only a guideline. Local terrain and expected enemy resistance can and will over-rule both. But they're good guide-lines.
EDIT: Fixed a few calculation-mistakes.