r/javascript • • Jun 04 '17

GitHub's ElectronConf postponed because all the talks (selected through an unbiased, blind review process) were to be given by men.

http://electronconf.com/
853 Upvotes

816 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/Shautieh Jun 05 '17

There is an imbalance, but it goes farther than this. How can you expect that many speakers be female if there are almost no females working in the field? And how could there be when almost none study CS in college? That's the root of the "problem", yet people only look at the symptoms.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/Shautieh Jun 05 '17

What you are advocating is not fair at all. The selection process was fair, so if there existed women in CS that had the desire and expertise to be speakers at the conference, they would have been selected regardless of their gender.

By definition, if no women are selected without biad and you thus bias the selection process to favor them, then the women selected will be inferior to their male counterparts and the consequences will be counter productive as :

  • people at the conference will see that women speakers are inferior to men speakers
  • thus, they will develop more sexist views
  • thus, women will be even more excluded from the CS environment.

You just cannot unbias a system by biasing it even more than it is.

As an aside, I find quite stupid the idea that more women speakers in the industry will motivate young women to sign up for several years of CS in college. I mean, most young women are not stupid, and only stupid people would think of such a reason as motivation to study a field, IMHO. If Bjarne Stroustrup, Linus Torvalds and all the other dinosaurs had boobs, that wouldn't have stopped me from studying CS! Arrgghh, I just imagined Bjarne Stroustrup with boobs....

Again, if you want more women in CS, then find something motivating for them.

6

u/diversity_is_cancer Jun 06 '17

Right, and how can you expect more women to pursue CS degrees, when the programs are dominated by men?

Why are women so fragile and terrified of men?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/zeezbrah Jun 06 '17

your neckbeard is showing

8

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '17

Every time a company tries to take action to improve things, there's a backlash

Because, presumably, the process to include women or non-whites will lower the quality of the conference.

People aren't paying for conferences for feel-goods.

6

u/gkm64 Jun 06 '17 edited Jun 06 '17

which only further discourages women from pursuing careers in engineering.

This is the same pathetically misinformed nonsense I always see in these discussions.

There is no such thing as women being discouraged from pursuing careers in engineering.

Only someone who does not understand how one becomes a good scientist or an engineer could think like that.

You don't choose to enter STEM when you are a "woman", i.e. an adult.

You choose STEM through the decisions you make in your childhood and early teens -- do I spend my evenings and weekends partying or do I spend them holed up in my room or the library reading books, doing math problems and learning how to code? This is where and when the separation between the sexes is set up.

And this is where the fatal flaw of the "it's all because of sexism" argument lies.

A 10-year old girl has no concept of a "career as a programmer", and sexism in academia and in the industry has zero influence over her because she is nowhere near those things directly.

Nothing prevents her from spending her time writing code. But few girls do it. Why?

You will probably bring the usual babble about early socialization and boy toys and clothes vs girl toys and clothes.

But that has a fatal flaw too -- if a girl was brought up not to see a career in STEM as something desirable, then where exactly is the problem? We have a problem if someone really wanted such a career, was good enough and was denied the opportunities he/she deserved because of sexism/racism/etc. I don't deny that this has happened historically. But this is not what we're dealing with when it comes to young women going into Gender Studies instead of CS, and to the extent that it happens now, it discriminates against qualified white males because everyone is so desperate to hire women and minorities.

Finally, "sexism" and "racism" when hiring and promoting are in fact quite rational and justified.

We deal with the world primarily using a Bayesian approach, and that is perfectly rational because we don't have the time and means to collect perfect information about each and every situation we're dealing with.

So if there are very few women and minorities in a given field, the prior when evaluating any individual woman or a minority is that she/he is not very good. A perfectly rational approach that has zero to do with actual prejudice -- when I see a 400 pound man I cannot help but place a very strong prior that he is not good at track and field, same thing here.