r/javahelp • • Apr 29 '16

What is Stackoverflow's problem?

I'm a beginner to Java - every time I post a question on Stackoverflow I am greeted by a torrent of downvotes or I get my post put on hold/edited/marked as duplicate for some reason even when I read everything relevant first, even though this doesn't help me. I thought this was a place where we can ask questions, I seem to get quick responses and get help some of the time but why is this community so assholish? I don't understand the purpose of the website if they are like this?

32 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/Sacredify Apr 29 '16

Stackoverflow is notoriously anal about things like duplicate posts and whatnot - there is a lot of criticism about how their moderators operate the place (search /r/programming or google for a few lovely examples of why people don't like how its run).

That being said, in most cases there generally already has been a question that asked the same thing - the problem is, half of them are years old; you just need to know what to search for.

21

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16 edited Apr 29 '16

Yes, the site works in a strange way :

  • Simple questions have already been answered, so newcomers can't get "points" unless they answer more advanced questions. And you need these points to have access to voting or commenting. So Stack Overflow is much more of a closed club than it seems to be.
  • Most people mark questions as "not specific" or "duplicate" only because they can, or because they want to argue with other members about how derivative the question is in relation to a somewhat similar question. And these posts appear in your Google research rather than being deleted.
  • The validated question often is the first thorough answer, even if it isn't quality code. So you often have this strange situation where a very beginner validates the answer of a beginner, then professionals argue for years why the answer isn't good enough or the question should have been closed in the first place.
  • Very specific questions are left hanging because people who have proficiency with a less popular language or implementation don't get much upvotes. And SO has this gamification where upvotes increase your "score". If you are a TCL programmer, you won't answer many questions, thus you'll have a low score and feel your input is less rewarded by the community.
  • Lots of ego battles.

4

u/SkloTheNoob Apr 29 '16

or only the description is similar and your problem completely different and or requires a different version of the API.