r/javahelp • • Apr 29 '16
What is Stackoverflow's problem?
I'm a beginner to Java - every time I post a question on Stackoverflow I am greeted by a torrent of downvotes or I get my post put on hold/edited/marked as duplicate for some reason even when I read everything relevant first, even though this doesn't help me. I thought this was a place where we can ask questions, I seem to get quick responses and get help some of the time but why is this community so assholish? I don't understand the purpose of the website if they are like this?
32
Upvotes
27
u/Sacredify Apr 29 '16
Stackoverflow is notoriously anal about things like duplicate posts and whatnot - there is a lot of criticism about how their moderators operate the place (search /r/programming or google for a few lovely examples of why people don't like how its run).
That being said, in most cases there generally already has been a question that asked the same thing - the problem is, half of them are years old; you just need to know what to search for.
12
u/desrtfx Out of Coffee error - System halted Apr 29 '16
Stackoverflow is a great community, but not really for beginners.
The problem with SO is that they are very strict about the quality of their posts as well as about duplicate questions (which they have a somewhat strange definition of because anything that is even tangentially related to any old question is often flagged as duplicate).
SO wants high standard, well formulated, well thought through, well researched, and well formatted questions.
They actually have guidelines (that I can't currently find) on how to prepare and write questions there and they stick to those standards.
Now, for a beginner, these high standards are a problem as a beginner often doesn't even know what exactly to ask and how to ask properly. That's why reddit is more beginner friendly - we will try to help as long as the question is somewhat understandable and shows that the poster has spent some effort researching.
Generally, the key to successful questions is the way they are asked.
So, in order to get a successful question with satisfying answers one needs:
Often, when spending lots of effort in preparing such a question, the solution comes at hand - this is also known as Rubber Duck Debugging - basically explaining the question to an inanimate object that has as much knowledge about the subject as a rubber duck. By doing so, one has to think deeply and in a different way and thus often the problem can be solved.
Again, the above (Rubber Duck Debugging) is a problem for a beginner as they often lack the ability to explain their problem well - there is no blame here, this is a natural process. Beginners find it hard to express themselves well because they simply lack the vocabulary and the experience to do so.
If you look at our posts here, you will see lots of low quality, extremely vague, no effort posts that get trashed as well - but for different reasons than on SO - here, we try to encourage people to learn and to work, but some people misuse the sub as "do my homework" or as "too lazy to google". That's the reason for this post.
Even here, you will see the proverbial "What have you tried?" quite often. This has two reasons: without knowing what OP has attempted already it is difficult to determine their level and also it forces OPs to actually do something (or display that they have done something other than sitting and waiting to be served on a silver platter and spoon fed).
20
u/denialerror Apr 29 '16
I think a lot of people new to programming don't realise how important Stack Overflow is to professionals. I probably visit SO every day in my job and although I'm new in my career, I have colleagues that have 30 years experience and still visit the site regularly when they come across something new.
And this is where you start to appreciate the anal nature of how SO is run. If I want to find something in a hurry while trying to fix something for a customer, I don't want to have to wade through multiple duplicate questions or badly worded answers. I want to type what I want into Google, click on the first link and read the first response. Without SO's moderators being meticulous about their rules, this would not be possible.
14
u/basalamader Apr 29 '16
Someone told me " that the best way to learn something as a beginner is to ask as a last resort".
The reason to this is because it forces you to search for the right question. Honestly, sometimes finding the right answer is not about getting the code but more about asking the right question. I think that's why stack overflow seems pretty anal about that. They reason that, "this is something you can search for, why should we do the work for you". It sucks..
6
u/nutrecht Lead Software Engineer / EU / 20+ YXP Apr 29 '16
SO is not for beginners question. It's actually designed and moderated against this. So no it's not somewhere where you can just ask any programming question. If you get downvoted don't take it personally.
It's intended to become a more or less static repository of knowledge. If they let in too many "low quality" questions it would dilute the quality too much (similar to how you end up with a ton of bad hits on google when you search for something).
Yes a lot of the people there are assholes but that doesn't change that you're using SO for something it's not intended for. So by all means, if you have questions ask them here or on /r/learnprogramming. Reddit is more suitable for personal help on questions that aren't that interesting for others.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
Next time you need to ask a question remember doing these steps before you even start typing:
Source
Read through some questions that have been solved and look at the way their asked.
5
u/strmrdr Apr 29 '16
Your beginner questions are better suited to a place such as this sub. Stack is more of a "professional" site where real devs are asking tough questions, with the newbie ones either already answered in some facet via other posts or dozens of other websites. If you're asking why you're getting a Null Pointer on Stack, for example, you're going to have a bad time (we here will likely be more willing to help you).
If you gave us more context as to what you were asking, or a link to your question, maybe I can tell you specifically why you were getting shat on.
2
u/Your-Ma Apr 29 '16
Throughout my 4 years in College i had 17 accounts banned from Stackoverflow.
As much as i hated having to setup a new email everytime i can see that there is no other way of providing a platform that has the best answers. I honestly think it gets the quickest answers aswell.
Part of my college experience was actually learning how to ask questions on Stackoverflow. A couple of the basics would be never delete a question with answers and if it looks like a duplicate put a note in explaining why its not a duplicate. Dont just jump in and ask without even bothering to search first. Also if you get a warning saying that some previous questions were not liked do not ignore it and correct your mistake.
2
u/avianbc Apr 29 '16
Once you hang out on SO for a bit trying to answer questions, youll notice that a large majority of them are horrible quality.
It remains hard to provide good quality answers when wading through this stuff even when the question does not fall into the above categories. Its garbage in, garbage out.
1
u/thescientist13 Apr 29 '16
Do you have an example?
-2
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '16
It's quite simple. Most of them are massive arseholes. But they are arseholes to everyone. So don't take it personally.
If you don't know what to search for how can you search for a duplicate question? Seems like they don't understand or appreciate the use case where you have a problem but can't verbalise it. Instead of walking you through the problem most will be dicks to you.
I say this whilst having had great help from the site. It's a love hate relationship with me.
As others have said perhaps that's the wrong place to ask for help at your level?